Germany nd
Digital Identity Verification | You are Germany
Anyone who wants to identify themselves online should be able to do so in the future using the “D-you” app. Experts also view this state digitalization critically.
Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English
Karsten Wildberger (CDU), Federal Minister for Digitalization and State Modernization, presents the name and logo of the EUDI wallet “D-you”. Photo: dpa/Bernd von Jutrczenka In the 2025 coalition agreement, the federal government set out to create a technical infrastructure for digital administrative processes. Things have been moving quickly since then: The Federal Ministry for Digitalization and State Modernization (BMDS) announced the app for January and gave it a name that is probably intended to do justice to a modernized state: “D-you”. But the Bundestag has so far only passed the draft for its legal basis. The Digital Identity Act passed its second and third reading in October with the votes of the SPD and CDU. Now it’s up to the Federal Council.
With this law, Germany implements the European Union's eIDAS regulation: Each member state should introduce a European wallet for digital identity, or EUDI wallet for short. The states are allowed to design them themselves, but must adhere to certain requirements. Accordingly, D-you should store documents and evidence in encrypted form directly on the smartphone. In addition, access is secured by PIN and biometric features. Authorities and companies can register to query individual data. Users should be able to identify themselves online and offline across Europe. This means you can also conclude legally binding contracts and complete administrative procedures online. The app is free. According to the draft law, citizens should save a total of 3.9 million hours of effort every year. Last but not least, the digital procedures are intended to reduce ongoing administrative costs by around 121 million euros per year.
D-you is part of D-Stack, a central project of Federal Digital Minister Karsten Wildberger (CDU). A “stack” is a bundle of technical components on which various applications can be built. There is currently no comparable infrastructure that is actually used in Germany. The federal ID, which citizens are supposed to use to identify themselves at various authorities, is considered bulky and has little appeal. The electronic patient file ePa is also unpopular.
The association D64 – Center for Digital Progress e.V. critically accompanies the development of the D-Stack. Board member Bendix Sältz generally welcomes a secure way to identify yourself online. However, there is still a lot to improve on the passed identity law and the technical implementation.
»We assume that companies will ask for all stored data.«
One point of contention is the implementation of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). It stipulates that organizations may only request data that is necessary for a contract or to comply with a law, or if the use is given informed consent. In practice, however, the requesting bodies determine which information is required. »Place, date of birth, citizenship, address, gender – these are all interesting data for companies. That’s why we assume that they will also ask for all the data,” says Sältz. In addition, there is no guarantee that consent will be well-informed.
Sältz and other civil society critics see this as a parallel to cookie banners. These were intended to secure the GDPR, but hardly led to sovereign decisions in everyday life. »We are seeing real cookie banner fatigue. In everyday life, people don't manage to seriously look at these banners and the consequences for the tracking of their data on every website. Many people simply clicked away the notices with their consent to data collection in order to get to the website. Obtaining consent is an easy way to obtain far more information than necessary.
»That's why we don't want the wallet to be launched before the authorization to query the data has been regulated. Otherwise, people get used to sending all their data upon request, essentially presenting their entire wallet, just to get an age rating, for example,” says Sältz.
Personalized data collections involve risks. Data brokers already trade user data from the advertising industry. The data not only reveals something about consumer behavior, but also about whereabouts and personal contacts. Even anonymized data can be assigned to an advertising ID and can enable conclusions to be drawn about identity, place of residence and work. This was shown by research by “Netzpolitik.org” from 2024. Hacker attacks and data leaks from organizations that use the wallet are also possible.
“In order to guarantee the safety of people, it must be prevented that data profiles can be created about them,” says Sältz. The wallet contains particularly sensitive personal data. "In this case, in contrast to those that are already being traded, we are talking about signed data." In the case of driver's licenses or ID cards, the state confirms the information. “If we now even have a biometric photo in the wallet, they will become unmistakable.” That could make the data even more valuable for retailers, says Sältz. After objections in the digital committee, the wallet should initially not contain a biometric image. However, a later addition is planned.
D64 also supports the request to equip the app with a pseudonym function. It is intended to prevent a query from automatically transmitting the individual signature or real name. This is provided for in the draft law. According to the developers, the function is already available. However, D64 criticizes that it cannot be clearly identified in the visible source code. It is also unclear why the ministry did not advertise the app publicly. Instead, the ministry's specially founded subsidiary, Common Code GmbH, received the order.
In addition to data protection, it is also about possible discrimination. Bianca Kastl from the Public Health Innovation Association warned at a hearing of the Digital Committee against excluding people who cannot or do not want to use the app. The draft law stipulates that the use of the wallet is voluntary for citizens. It should enable digital processes, but not completely replace them. But digital offers can make analogue transactions more difficult or more expensive. Berlin outdoor pool guests know an example from everyday life: online buyers don't have to wait in line at the checkout and also receive a discount. Anyone who doesn't have a smartphone or an account with an online payment service provider is at a disadvantage.
Neither the personal effort to weigh up the benefits and risks of the app, nor the civil society commitment to protecting against data misuse is included in the time savings calculation for introducing the wallet. Nevertheless, there is still time to get involved in the draft law.
Other media have corporations or billionaires behind them. We have the nd.Genossenschaft and readers like you. That makes us independent and that’s exactly how we want to remain. But it also means: without you the calculation won't work. We need 300,000 euros by the end of the year.
You can donate directly here, one-time or regularly, so that nd stays.