Germany nd
After hours of negotiations, the Union and the SPD agree on relief for electricity and fuel. The compromise is thin.
Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English
Federal Finance Minister Lars Klingbeil (SPD) and Chancellor Friedrich Merz (CDU) negotiated late into the night. Photo: Michael Kappeler/dpa Friedrich Merz has received his electricity tax cut. At least for a year. After more than eight hours of negotiations, the leaders of the Union and SPD agreed on Wednesday night to reduce the electricity tax to the European minimum for all consumers and companies from January 2027. However, the financing is initially only available for twelve months. In return, the SPD will receive a fuel price cap that will initially apply for three months from January. An agreement on compensating for the cold progression was not reached. The coalition committee also had no result when it came to pensions.
After a heated argument, the coalition partners have agreed on two relief measures. However, the compromise is not a big deal. The electricity tax cut had already been agreed in the coalition agreement, but its implementation had been delayed for months. It will now be extended for an initial period of one year. There is still no solution for permanent financing. There are also important questions unanswered when it comes to the fuel price cap. The coalition has achieved one thing above all: it has prevented the dispute over electricity tax from turning into another government crisis.
The agreement was particularly important for Merz. The Chancellor had repeatedly announced the reduction in recent days and made it a question of his political credibility. On Monday he had promised a quick agreement. He expected the talks to last “relatively short.” In fact, it was a negotiation that lasted until two in the morning.
Reports about a possible break-off of the talks show how tense these negotiations were. According to information from "Bild", Merz is said to have left the room angrily shortly before midnight. “I’m not going to take part in this anymore,” he said. The background was the SPD's resistance to what they considered to be inadequate counter-financing. Merz returned shortly afterwards with a scarf and laptop bag, apparently to leave the Chancellery. CSU boss Markus Söder finally brought him back to the negotiating table.
The German Press Agency also reported, citing participants, that a chancellor was about to dissolve the group. However, Union parliamentary group leader Thorsten Frei contradicted the representation. Although the negotiations were demanding and took a long time, the atmosphere was good.
The conflict had already escalated in the previous days. Merz really wanted to reduce the electricity tax without initially having viable financing for it. Vice Chancellor and Finance Minister Lars Klingbeil (SPD), however, demanded that the Union provide serious counter-financing. Last week an agreement failed in the budget negotiations. This caused considerable dissatisfaction in the Union faction. Ultimately, Merz – driven by critics from within his own ranks – publicly promised relief and thus increased the pressure on himself.
The solution that has now been found provides that the missing 5.4 billion euros for 2027 will be raised through financial leeway in the promotion of renewable energies in the EEG account. Among other things, remuneration and sales proceeds for electricity from wind and solar systems are recorded there. How much money actually remains depends on the development of electricity prices. If the surpluses are not enough, the coalition wants to decide on an additional package of measures. What could be in it remains unclear.
Financing for the period after 2027 is unclear anyway. The coalition is aiming for a permanent reduction, but is making this dependent on sustainable counter-financing in the 2028 federal budget. Klingbeil accordingly insists on a solid solution. “We do what we can seriously finance,” explained the SPD chairman after the deliberations. The financial situation is not getting any easier: there is already a gap of around 25 billion euros in the budget planning for 2028.
For private households, the decision initially means comparatively small financial relief. The electricity tax will fall from the current 2.05 cents to the European minimum of 0.1 cents per kilowatt hour. If the reduction is passed on in full to consumers, an average household with an annual consumption of 4,000 kilowatt hours will save around 93 euros per year, according to calculations by the comparison portal Verivox. That corresponds to just under eight euros per month. A single household with 1,500 kilowatt hours of consumption saves around 35 euros annually.
The reduction does not only benefit private households. While the manufacturing industry as well as agriculture and forestry have benefited from the reduced electricity tax since 2026, the other sectors of the economy are now also included.
The head of the Federal Association of Consumer Organizations, Ramona Pop, welcomed the agreement as an important first step, but called for permanent relief. Given the high energy and heating costs, the reduction alone is not enough. The German Federation of Trade Unions also sees the lower electricity tax as an incentive for electrification and thus an opportunity to reduce dependence on fossil fuels.
The economics are much more critical. Monika Schnitzer, chairwoman of the Advisory Council, believes the reduction makes sense in principle, but criticizes the time limit. It creates little planning security and does not provide sufficient incentives for long-term investments. The measure remains an expensive short-term relief, the long-term financing of which is unclear.
The SPD can claim a small success with the fuel price cap. The fuel discount that has been in effect since October expires at the end of December. A price limit will now apply from January 1, 2027. The regulation is initially designed to last three months, but can be extended. The federal cabinet is scheduled to approve a draft law and an associated legal ordinance on December 2nd.
The SPD is thus opposing the original draft by Economics Minister Katherina Reiche (CDU). This had set such high hurdles for activation that it would hardly have been possible to expect any intervention in practice. The price of petrol or diesel would have had to rise more than five percentage points more than the average in the other EU countries in three consecutive weeks. The SPD therefore criticized the proposal as ineffective.
However, it is still unclear how the new price cap will actually work. The coalition wants to ensure that supplies remain guaranteed. The countries should also take regional characteristics into account and be able to set different maximum prices. It is therefore not yet possible to say how much of the burden on drivers will actually be relieved.
Immediately after the agreement, the coalition partners tried to present the compromise as a success for their respective sides. Merz explained that the government had promised to reduce electricity taxes and had "kept its word." The Chancellor expressly thanked the members of the coalition committee for following his suggestion.
CSU boss Markus Söder also rated the result positively. North Rhine-Westphalia's Prime Minister Hendrik Wüst (CDU) described the resolutions as a good success and as evidence that the federal government is capable of acting. Wüst had repeatedly advocated for the electricity tax reduction and declared that it was a “good success” for the Chancellor. Thuringia's Prime Minister Mario Voigt (CDU) was less satisfied. He welcomed the agreement but called it merely a good start. Families and smaller companies in particular need long-term clarity. The electricity tax reduction must therefore be implemented quickly and secured permanently.
Immediately after the agreement, criticism also came from the SPD. The budget spokesman for the Bundestag faction, Thorsten Rudolph, was in favor of the electricity tax now falling, but: "For the big announcements the Chancellor has made, the result is quite small," he told the "Rheinische Post".
Rudolph accused Merz of a lack of courage. The Chancellor could have advocated for a permanent reduction and also eliminated climate-damaging subsidies. It is astonishing that Economics Minister Reiche has suddenly discovered that several billion euros less will be needed in EEG funding next year than was assumed in October. However, this is not permanent counter-financing.
What was also notable was what was missing after the coalition committee: a joint press conference by the coalition leaders. Instead, the decisions were communicated in writing and individual politicians commented separately. The lack of a joint presentation is consistent with a result that was urgently needed politically, but offered little reason for a major performance. The electricity tax cut had already been promised, its financing remains provisional, and the specific design of the fuel price cap is still open. There was also no agreement about pensions or compensation for the cold progression.
This is a great opportunity for the opposition. The Greens speak of a long run-up and a little hop. The energy policy spokesman Michael Kellner welcomed the fact that electricity was becoming cheaper, but criticized the time limit. Left parliamentary group leader Sören Pellmann pointed out the disparity between the billions spent on armaments and corporate interests and the minimal relief for the majority. Party leader Ines Schwerdtner explained: “The federal government has understood that it finally has to relieve the burden on the people in the country. But financing the reduction in electricity prices with reserves from the energy transition is politically fatal and dangerous when electricity prices on the market rise. "The government once again does not trust the billions in excess profits of the oil companies, said Schwerdtner.
Even within the Union, the question of whether Merz has actually achieved political success has not been conclusively answered. Wüst and Söder are supporting the Chancellor with their assessments, but Voigt warns that this does not represent a long-term solution. CDU General Secretary in North Rhine-Westphalia Paul Ziemiak, in turn, criticized the SPD for the lengthy negotiations. The agreement could have been reached much earlier, he said. After all, the electricity tax cut is already in the coalition agreement. At the same time, he pointed to potential savings in government spending and subsidies.
What will be crucial for Merz is that he can even produce an agreement after last week's failed negotiations. The Chancellor was under considerable pressure from his own ranks, who questioned his ability to assert himself against his coalition partner. The fact that the electricity tax should actually fall for everyone takes some of the wind out of the sails of this criticism for the time being.
The meaning of this limited compromise lies less in its design or its actual effect, but rather in the importance that the coalition partners attach to it. Merz in particular had to show that he was able to assert himself against his junior partner, even if the content itself called the symbol into question. Whether this will become more will become clear at the latest during the budget negotiations for 2028 and the upcoming pension decisions. The next conflicts are already waiting there. With agencies.
Other media have corporations or billionaires behind them. We have the nd.Genossenschaft and readers like you. That makes us independent and that’s exactly how we want to remain. But it also means: without you the calculation won't work. We need 300,000 euros by the end of the year.
You can donate directly here, one-time or regularly, so that nd stays.