Politics nd
The Left and Elif Eralp | New government in Berlin: Take the fear mongers seriously
The campaign against a left-wing government has already taken place in a similar way in New York City. So it's time to question the scam, says our columnist.
Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English
Elif Eralp (left) wants to become the ruler of Berlin. Photo: dpa/Sebastian Christoph Gollnow "Fear is not good, fear eats up the soul." With this sentence, in the film of the same name by Rainer Werner Fassbinder, the Moroccan Ali addresses the German widow Emmi, who is newly in love with him, at the breakfast table, the morning after their first meeting. With Ali, for the first time in German cinema, a guest worker did not represent a problem, but rather a person who was allowed to want, desire and fail. He was played by El Hedi Ben Salem, the director's Tunisian partner. Three years after the film's premiere, Salem was dead, having died in a French prison as a result of a robbery.
In his Berlin novel entitled “Fear eats Ali,” which was recently published in English, the author Edwin Nasr, unlike Fassbinder, does not focus on the majority society's fears of strangers, but on the gay partygoer Ali from southern Lebanon, who was targeted by the police after October 7th. While his home village is razed to the ground by Israeli troops and he is threatened with deportation, Ali fantasizes about an impending bombing of Neukölln by the Bundeswehr as part of the state's fight against anti-Semitism. A literary exaggeration, but in view of the statements made by right-wing actors about the district, it somehow no longer sounds so unrealistic.
The fact that criminalized foreigners can also have fears like in Nasr's book hardly seems to play a role in the media debates these days. On the other hand, since the Left's electoral success in Berlin, the issue of fear of people of foreign, especially Muslim, origins has been on the agenda. Just two and a half hours after the polls closed on September 20th, the chairman of the German-Israeli Society, Volker Beck, commented on an article on the X platform about the presence of the Berlin businessman Issa Remmo at the election party of the Neukölln district association of the Left with the words: "That scares me."
Yossi Bartal has been an enthusiastic Neukölln resident since 2006. Growing up in West Jerusalem, he learned early on that self-hatred is the noblest form of hate. With a healthy dose of skepticism towards the state and the law, he writes for nd.Digital every third Monday of the month about parallel societies, (substitute) nationalism and the fight for a better world.
Strangely enough, Remmo and Beck have a lot more in common than they thought, aside from their media affinity. Beck regularly defends Israel's genocidal warfare in the German media. And just last week, Remmo was an official guest at a joint conference between the Israel lobby organization ELNET and the conservative EPP group in the European Parliament - and even visited the large synagogue in Brussels. In an interview with the Jüdische Allgemeine, he, like Beck, attested that the Left Party had an “anti-Semitism problem.”
Research by Jonathan Peaceman and me recently showed that Remmo's circle of friends is particularly close to the Berlin CDU and other pro-Israel actors. It also stands to reason that Remmo was not only in the Berlin House of Representatives in 2025 at the invitation of the CDU, but was also at an interreligious conference of the Abraham Accord Institute, a pro-Israel organization led by CDU politician Armin Laschet. In contrast to the statement made by a friend of Remmo's to "nd", who confirmed his participation in the conference, the institute denied that Remmo was present when asked, but did not want to rule out the possibility that he could have taken part in an "informal city tour" uninvited on the evening before the conference.
The man's exciting political ventures shed a completely different light on someone who is repeatedly declared the godfather of Berlin, even though he himself has never been legally convicted despite numerous arrests. The suspicion arises that the figure of an all-powerful clan boss has been exaggerated by the media for years - after all, it's not every day that you find such a popular and accessible villain who serves all of the readers' stereotypes. Remmo, for his part, enjoys this media attention and now wants to use it as a head start for a political career - he repeatedly talks about founding a new party.
It fits into a certain sales model: media spread images of fear, knowing full well that the connections are rarely as dramatic as they portray them.
The “Spiegel” magazine recently provided a particularly blatant example: “Who is the man that Elif Eralp is afraid of?” it asked on its cover after internal notes on an interview were incorrectly sent to the authors from the left-wing politician’s office. In it, Eralp spoke of her "fear of these people" and was referring to pro-Palestinian activists in Berlin who are accused of having sympathies with terrorist organizations.
The fact that Eralp shows himself to be influenced by a media fear campaign in a private message may be newsworthy. But – not unlike the Remmo case – here too, an Arab man, the German-Palestinian Ibrahim Ibrahim, who has lived in Berlin since the 1970s, was portrayed as a great danger. He is also not proven to have committed any crimes. His biggest offenses appear to be registering weekly peaceful protests against the destruction of the Gaza Strip, as well as past statements showing sympathy for the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP). First of all, this is the largest left-wing party in Palestine. Like almost all other parties operating under the Israeli military occupation, including the Western-backed Fatah, the PFLP has an armed wing that is also active in Gaza and has taken part in armed actions and even war crimes. Nobody accuses Ibrahim of having contacts with such military groups.
The logic behind the “Spiegel” article, which is difficult to understand, is this: We should be afraid of a mayor who seems to believe in our fear-mongering about Berlin. In an article worth reading, Georg Diez, who was an author and columnist at “Spiegel” for many years, reflected on how fear is the “basic journalistic gesture” of his former magazine. Fear is not only “the medium through which the ‘Spiegel’ negotiates the world,” but also a “means of policy shift.” The magazine's reporting in recent months has made this abundantly clear.
Germany is not alone in fear campaigns against left-wing cities. Similarly, numerous media and politicians warned of the downfall of New York City following the election victory of the Muslim socialist Zohran Mamdani. They spoke of impending pogroms against fellow Jews and the flight of billion-dollar companies from the city. None of this happened; and Mamdani, after almost a year in office, is seen – even by many former opponents – as a great success.
If there is a lesson for Berlin from this, it is that left-wing politicians should not only take the fears of the most diverse groups seriously, but also always question who is spreading which fears - and with what (possibly cynical) intention. Because as Ali already knew: Fear is the greatest enemy of a love that ventures beyond the boundaries of origin and religion.
Other media have corporations or billionaires behind them. We have the nd.Genossenschaft and readers like you. That makes us independent and that’s exactly how we want to remain. But it also means: without you the calculation won't work. We need 300,000 euros by the end of the year.
You can donate directly here, one-time or regularly, so that nd stays.