Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

Politics Middle East Eye

ICC judges order end to investigation into alleged crimes by US forces in Afghanistan

ICC judges order end to investigation into alleged crimes by US forces in Afghanistan Submitted by Sondos Asem on Mon, 11/16/2026 - 10:56 The decision, signalled in an order first reported by MEE in A

English (original) ·Read in Deutsch ⇄

ICC judges order end to investigation into alleged crimes by US forces in Afghanistan

Submitted by Sondos Asem on Mon, 11/16/2026 - 10:56 The decision, signalled in an order first reported by MEE in August, raises questions over whether the court is seeking to ease US pressure following sanctions Rosario Salvatore Aitala, now presiding judge of the ICC’s Pre-Trial Chamber II, at his swearing-in ceremony in The Hague on 9 March 2018 (ICC/Flikr) Rosario Salvatore Aitala, now presiding judge of the ICC’s Pre-Trial Chamber II, at his swearing-in ceremony in The Hague on 9 March 2018 (ICC/Flikr) Off

Judges at the International Criminal Court (ICC) have ordered the closure of the court’s Afghanistan investigation that covered alleged war crimes by US forces, despite ongoing attempts by prosecutors to appeal the decision.

Ending the investigation into alleged US crimes addresses one of Washington’s longstanding objections to the ICC and one of the reasons behind the sanctions on the court and its officials.  

The move is therefore likely to raise questions about whether the court is seeking to ease tensions with Washington by signalling that it will no longer pursue allegations against US forces and their allies. 

The Afghanistan situation at the ICC dates back to November 2017, when then-prosecutor Fatou Bensouda first requested authorisation to investigate alleged crimes committed since 2003, including by Afghan and US forces as well as the Taliban and the IS-K group. 

That request was initially rejected by a differently composed pre-trial chamber in 2019, before the appeals chamber overturned the decision in March 2020 and authorised the investigation to proceed.

Bensouda was sanctioned by the US government a few months later over alleged attempts to subject Americans to the court's jurisdiction. Members of the appeals chamber that authorised the decision were also later sanctioned.

Afghanistan II launched

In November 2024, six states - Chile, Costa Rica, Spain, France, Luxembourg and Mexico - jointly referred allegations of crimes against women and girls committed since the Taliban's return to power in August 2021, asking prosecutors to fold them into the existing Afghanistan investigation. 

The latest decision, dated 12 November, closes the strand of the Afghanistan probe that covered the conduct of US forces and the Islamic State-Khorasan Province group, known as IS-K.

However, it leaves open the part of the inquiry that prosecutes the Taliban for crimes against humanity allegedly committed against women and other groups while acting as the de facto government of Afghanistan. 

ICC confirms Middle East Eye reporting on Afghanistan arrest warrants Read More »

The Taliban inquiry is now part of a situation titled Afghanistan II, launched by judges on 20 October. Judges have also ordered relevant records, including four Taliban arrest warrants, transferred to that investigation.

The move echoes previous reporting by Middle East Eye, which exclusively reported over three months ago that judges had ordered prosecutors to separate the Taliban investigation from the broader Afghanistan inquiry. 

The judges argued that the post-2021 conduct by the Taliban is "materially different" from the armed conflict-related violence that defined the original investigation authorised in 2020. 

MEE also reported at the time that judges pointed prosecutors towards a newly introduced procedure for closing the original investigation, the one that nominally covers alleged crimes by all parties, because it sat dormant for years.

Sources familiar with the Afghanistan inquiry previously told MEE that the Office of the Prosecutor (OTP) had appealed two of the chamber’s previous decisions: the order to open a separate Taliban investigation and the order transferring court records to it. 

Those appeals are still pending before the appeals chamber.

The OTP has also appealed the latest closure decision.

Dialogue with the US

MEE reported in December that diplomats at the ICC's annual Assembly of States Parties (ASP) meeting in The Hague said the Trump administration had pressed the court to drop its investigations into Afghanistan and Palestine as a condition for lifting sanctions. 

It also demanded that states amend the ICC’s founding treaty - the Rome Statute - to prevent the prosecution of nationals from countries that aren’t members of the court, such as the US and Israel. 

Netherlands denies active talks with US over curbing ICC powers to lift sanctions Read More »

Last week, Dutch Foreign Minister Tom Berendsen declined to rule out the suggestion that discussions were taking place with Washington over sweeping restrictions on the ICC. 

A Dutch foreign ministry spokesperson subsequently told MEE there were “no direct negotiations with the US” on amending the Rome Statute or closing any investigations.

The spokesperson said the government was exploring the scope for dialogue with non-member states, but that a US-states parties dialogue had yet to take shape. 

The idea of dialogue with the US was floated in last year’s ASP in December after an EU diplomat presented the US demands for discussion.

MEE revealed at the time that member states disagreed on what such a dialogue would entail, and by the end of the conference agreed that any dialogue should aim at ensuring the independence and effectiveness of the court.

The court’s member states are due to meet in The Hague from 30 November to 7 December.

Grace period for new sanctions

Washington on 9 October imposed institutional sanctions on the ICC, while granting the court a six-month grace period to take measures that would address US demands. 

Once fully in effect, the measures could stop the court from transacting in US dollars and potentially cripple its operations.

The pre-trial chamber's decision in July to split the Afghanistan investigation came days after US Secretary of State Marco Rubio threatened to “dismantle the ICC, brick by brick”, in remarks referencing the court's 2020 decision authorising an investigation into alleged crimes committed in Afghanistan.

Since February 2025, the US has imposed retaliatory financial and visa sanctions on court officials in connection with the Afghanistan and Palestine investigations, citing efforts to prosecute nationals or allies of the US, in particular Israel. 

​​The first target was Karim Khan, the former prosecutor of the ICC, who was controversially removed by member states in July after an 18-month-long misconduct probe. 

Also targeted were nine judges, three of whom - Kimberly Prost, Solomy Bossa and Luz Ibanez - were members of the 2020 Appeals Chamber that authorised the Afghanistan investigation.

The sanctions came despite the decision by Khan in 2021 to deprioritise the probe concerning US military and CIA personnel, as well as former Afghan government forces, in order to focus the investigation on the Taliban and the Islamic State-Khorasan Province. 

International law News Post Date Override 0 Update Date Mon, 05/04/2020 - 21:19 Update Date Override 0
Originally published byMiddle East Eye
Read the original