Germany nd
Biopic “Being Heumann” | Rebellion on wheels
The biopic “Being Heumann” by director Siân Heder tells the inspiring true story of US disability rights activist Judy Heumann.
Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English
Everyone risked a lot: Ruth Madeley as activist Judith Heumann Photo: Apple TV When a hundred activists with physical disabilities occupied a federal building in San Francisco in April 1977 to finally demand the years overdue entry into force of Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, no one could have imagined that it could become the longest occupation of an administrative building in US history. Now director Siân Heder, who won the Oscar for best screenplay in 2022 with the coming-of-age drama “Coda” about a young person from a deaf family, has taken on this extraordinary movement-political event in her new film “Being Heumann” and turned it into a fascinating film. At its center is the titular activist Judith Heumann (Ruth Madeley), who was one of the heads of the cast at the time. The “504 Sit-In,” as the almost four-week-long occupation is called in American history books, was a tough fight that demanded a maximum from everyone involved. For some people with restrictions, the occupation and the break with routine daily routines were not entirely safe for medical reasons. Everyone risked a lot. And the federal authorities tried to starve the occupiers and occasionally sent officers to harass the activists.
The media-effective protest was addressed to Health, Education and Welfare Minister Joseph Califano, who in the Carter era was responsible for signing and implementing Section 504, which banned discrimination in state-funded institutions and, among other things, stipulated accessibility and should actually have come into force long ago. The government was playing for time and tried to delay the costly legislation. The main focus was on the question of whether children with disabilities can attend schools. 50 years ago, a lack of accessibility meant that children with disabilities were often excluded from attending school. The film, which is sometimes staged a little too much as a feel-good movie and strives to have a focus that is as pointed as it is sensitive, is largely based on the biography of the same title by Judith Heumann, who died in 2023. Director Heder was in contact with Heumann shortly before her death, but also spoke to numerous other people who took part in the protest at the time. The film not only reflects the external impact of the campaign, it is also about internal discussions, which were sometimes heated. Because needs vary depending on the restriction. Deaf, blind and wheelchair users fight to hierarchize their needs and sometimes shout angrily at each other in the plenary session. The “504 Sit-In” brought together many different actors.
The problem is not the person in the wheelchair, but the stairs!
In addition to people with different physical limitations, queer activists were there. The food supply, which was initially difficult, was managed by the Black Panthers. San Francisco's then-progressive mayor George Moscone (who was assassinated a year later along with LGBTQ+ activist Harvey Milk) provided the occupiers with mattresses and portable showers. The film captures the inspiring but not always easy chaos of this occupation, which also included a sex tent for people with disabilities and associated workshops, as an empowering story. When the federal authorities shut down the phones, the activists communicated with the help of deaf people who stood at the window using sign language to exchange information with the outside world. Parallel occupations in New York and other cities are quickly evacuated, but in San Francisco there are always supporters on site outside the building. Finally, Judith Heumann travels to Washington with some activists and camps out for several days singing songs in front of Minister Califano's house, who then, to everyone's surprise, signs the law.
Heder's film only stars people with disabilities, more than ever in any other production, which is why the US trade press is already speculating that "Being Heumann" is a hot contender for the Oscar for casting, which was added this year. The end credits of the film offer a lot of historical photographic material that shows how close this film is visually to the real events. This extends to the spontaneous kiss that an activist in a wheelchair placed on the mouth of a puzzled police officer as she victoriously left the building after almost four weeks. It still took quite some time before the signed law finally led to accessibility. “It's not the person in the wheelchair that's the problem, it's the stairs!” it says several times in the film, which at the end shows Judith Heumann standing in a wheelchair in front of the steep stairs that lead up to the Capitol, followed by images of people with disabilities crawling and chanting over these stairs during a protest in 1990.
With us, no one has to pay to be informed. Sounds like a bad business model? It is too. But independent journalism and participation for everyone are more important to us than profit. Journalism still costs money: research, printing and all the people who do it. That's why we depend on you. We need 300,000 euros by the end of the year.
Donate once or regularly, every amount counts. So that nd remains.