World Africa Is a Country
The names on the ice
On Mount Kenya, the ice is disappearing, but the colonial names are staying. Whose histories will the mountain remember?
English (original) ·Read in Deutsch ⇄
Mount Kenya’s glaciers carry names such as Lewis, Gregory, Tyndall, Darwin, Forel and Heim. Within a few years, the ice carrying those names may be gone. Two of the less famous glaciers, Cesar and Josef, tell the story better.
In 1899, Halford Mackinder set out to make the first recorded ascent of Batian with six Europeans, 66 Swahilis, two Maasai guides and 96 Kikuyu. Among the Europeans were César Ollier and Joseph Brocherel, Alpine guides from Courmayeur in Italy. Brocherel was also listed as a porter. Both men left their names on the mountain: Cesar Glacier and Josef Glacier.
The 96 Kikuyu did not.
That discrepancy invites an easy story about Europeans overwriting an African map. The mountain is less tidy. Lower down, African names persist: Kikami, from the Kikuyu word for hyrax; Mbairunyi, “Place of Fighting”; Gacheno, “Place of Danger”; Kethimbui, “Place of Rest.” They record animals, conflict, fear and respite rather than distant scientists and explorers. The pattern is not absence but altitude. The higher the map goes, the whiter it gets.
Even the summit area complicates that pattern. Mackinder adopted Batian, Nelion and Lenana, names of Maasai figures, on the suggestion of Sidney Langford Hinde, a British colonial officer in Maasailand. Africans appear throughout the mountain’s nomenclature — as guides and porters, as informants and sources of names. Europeans were usually the people deciding which names entered the map, and which endured.
At the ice line, the contrast becomes harder to miss. Lewis is named for a geologist; Darwin for Charles Darwin. The ice became an index of European science, honoring men with no particular connection to Mount Kenya. Tyndall is the sharpest case. His experiments established that gases including carbon dioxide and water vapor absorb radiant heat. The glacier bearing his name is disappearing in a changing climate.
There is a second imbalance. The industrialized countries from which many of those explorers and scientists came account for a disproportionate share of the emissions changing the planet’s climate. From 1850 to 2019, the IPCC calculates, developed countries produced 57% of cumulative fossil fuel and industrial carbon dioxide emissions; Africa, just 3%. The names were assigned here; most of the carbon was emitted elsewhere.
Nor was every European name an act of personal vanity. When J.W. Gregory surveyed Mount Kenya, he named glaciers after Forel and Heim for a practical reason: glaciers needed names if they were to be described and mapped.
Useful to whom is a small question, but not an empty one.
The Mountain Club of Kenya’s guide records that in 1924 porters insisted they had seen a lion beside a tarn; Melhuish and Dutton called it Simba Tarn. The porters’ observation survived on the map; their names did not. The same men named another tarn after Gitchini, Melhuish’s personal servant, who accompanied him on mountain journeys.
Another name connects Mount Kenya with Kilimanjaro. The missionary Johannes Rebmann joined Johann Ludwig Krapf in Mombasa in 1846. In 1848, Rebmann reported snow on Kilimanjaro. On December 3, 1849, Krapf sighted Mount Kenya, whose name he recorded as Kenia or Kegnia after hearing it from Kamba people. The precise etymology is disputed, but an African name entered the European written record and eventually named the country.
Krapf got a glacier too.
There is precedent for reconsidering what mountains record. At Tanganyika’s independence in 1961, Kilimanjaro’s Kaiser-Wilhelm-Spitze became Uhuru Peak. The summit proclaimed freedom; the ice retained a different history. Rebmann Glacier was not renamed. Kenya became independent two years later, and Krapf Glacier kept its name too.
In 1963, twelve of Mount Kenya’s named glaciers still survived: Northey, Krapf, Gregory, Lewis, Melhuish, Diamond, Darwin, Forel, Heim, Tyndall, Cesar and Josef. Their names did not change. Kenya nonetheless renamed Lake Rudolf as Lake Turkana in 1975. The machinery existed. It simply never reached the ice.
Lewis Glacier lost 90 % of its volume between 1934 and 2010. Prinz and colleagues found Lewis Glacier’s mass balance most sensitive to atmospheric moisture, through snowfall, cloud cover, and surface reflectivity. Their model showed that increased snow accumulation could produce net gains in ice without significant cooling. Satellite mapping from 2021 and 2022 found just 0.069 square kilometres of glacier ice left on Mount Kenya, about 4.2% of its area around 1900. The World Meteorological Organization projects that the glaciers could disappear by 2030. The exact year may shift. The direction does not.
Would renaming a disappearing glacier be vanity? Not if it changed who gets to decide what the map remembers. It would not save the ice, and changing the labels by decree while excluding the communities whose knowledge shaped the mountain would repeat the old method. The names we retain are choices about whose contributions deserve to be remembered.
And then there is Gitchini. Melhuish had two names on the mountain, a point and a glacier. The glacier had disappeared by 1987; he still has the point. Gitchini had one. The tarn is still there, but it is now called Hanging Tarn.
The glaciers are doing the reverse: the ice is disappearing, and the names are staying.