Politics Tagesschau
The federal government's plans: Lawyers doubt the law against socialization
The federal government wants to make it more difficult for states to socialize large housing stocks. However, a report commissioned by the Left comes to the conclusion: The planned investment protection law can
Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English
The federal government's plans Lawyers doubt the law against socialization As of: November 16, 2026 • 6:03 a.m
The federal government wants to make it more difficult for states to socialize large housing stocks. However, a report commissioned by the Left comes to the conclusion: The planned investment protection law could fail in Karlsruhe.
It doesn't yet exist: a government in Berlin led by the left. And so there is still no law that makes the apartments of large real estate companies state-owned through socialization.
To prevent this from happening in the first place, the federal government wants to prevent it by law. But a report now comes to the conclusion that exactly that is unconstitutional. The paper is available exclusively to the ARD capital studio.
The federal government wants to forestall the Left Party in Berlin with a law. more
The author is the Würzburg law professor Isabell Feichtner, who was also a member of the Berlin Senate's “Socialization” expert commission. Led by the former Federal Minister of Justice Herta Däubler-Gmelin, this commission came to the conclusion that socialization regulated in Article 15 of the Basic Law can be used to deprive large real estate groups of apartments and transfer them to public ownership.
Together with two colleagues, Feichtner has now examined the key points of the so-called “Investment Protection Act” in a report on behalf of the Left. In doing so, the federal government wants to strictly limit socialization with uniform nationwide rules. “It is very clear that it is about prevention,” says Feichtner. The paper says, for example: "In order not to endanger private housing construction, federal law regulates that the nationalization of private housing stock through socialization at the state level is no longer possible."
The federal government doesn't want to shape things here, but rather just prevent something that the Basic Law expressly allows the states to do, said Feichtner. In their report, she and her colleagues point out that the Federal Constitutional Court does not recognize such a blocking effect of federal laws. So if laws “aim to exclude the state legislature from its own legislation without its own regulation of the content of the subject matter,” then that is unconstitutional.
The Left wants to socialize the holdings of large housing groups in Berlin. That's the legal situation. more
According to Feichtner, the federal government could only forestall Berlin's socialization plans if the planned investment protection law served to transfer private property into public property. But exactly the opposite is intended.
This is exactly what Federal Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt indirectly admitted two weeks ago. “We make it clear in the key points that you cannot socialize arbitrarily,” said the CSU politician. He had the points worked out. The SPD-led ministries for construction and justice are also involved. At the time, Dobrindt spoke of a left-wing “socialization fetish” that was incompatible with the Basic Law.
Similar criticism also comes from the Federal Chancellor. Already in July, Friedrich Merz said: "We will prevent the nationalization of private housing associations and rental apartments." It wasn't until two months later that Die Linke won the Berlin House of Representatives election.
The Left wants to tackle the housing problem in Berlin by corporatizing private companies. more
The key points for the Investment Protection Act state that socialization should only be possible as a “last option”. The necessity would therefore first have to be proven. To do this, it must be clear that there is no other measure that could also solve the problem. In addition, compensation should be prescribed in the amount of the market value, which must be paid in cash.
This goes far beyond what the Basic Law provides, says Feichtner. The amount of compensation is not regulated there. Instead, this must be assessed on a case-by-case basis.
Feichtner also has doubts that such a framework law is even necessary. “Even if the goal was not prevention, but rather the design of the requirements for compensation, then that would be problematic,” she says. Especially if the intention is not to actually transfer private property into public property.
Interior Minister Dobrindt is planning high hurdles for socialization. Cabinet colleague Hubig sees a lot of need for clarification. more
Criticism of Interior Minister Dobrindt's plans also comes from other lawyers. “The hurdles for socialization would be so high that socialization would actually be impossible,” says constitutional lawyer Joachim Wieland to the AFP news agency.
Above all, he is critical of the condition planned by Dobrindt, according to which socialization should only be possible if other means have been exhausted. "The federal government would thus establish a hierarchy and say that socialization is only possible as a very last measure. But that is not provided for in the Basic Law."
And there were also doubts about the legality of the project from the beginning in the federal SPD. Federal Minister of Justice Stefanie Hubig, for example, refers to Article 15 of the Basic Law. This clearly provides for the possibility of socialization.
“So it’s not that easy to say: It’s forbidden,” says Hubig. And Juso boss Philipp Türmer is sure that the law will never come. "I think it's unconstitutional to prohibit states from doing something that the constitution guarantees them," he says.
The report by Feichtner and her colleagues comes to the same conclusion. She is therefore certain that the planned “Investment Protection Act” would not stand up to scrutiny by the Federal Constitutional Court. The Left had already announced that they would file a lawsuit in Karlsruhe if the law were passed.
This topic in the program: tagesschau.de | According to the report, the Investment Protection Act is unconstitutional | 11/16/26 | 6 o'clock