Labour Tribune
The Labour Government Is Anti-Worker
John Healey claims that investing in AI will facilitate a ‘productivity revolution’. The technology, however, will destroy jobs and further shift wealth towards capital.
English (original) ·Read in Deutsch ⇄
In an article for The Times last week, Chancellor John Healey promised us a ‘productivity revolution’ through massive investment in AI and data centres, creating jobs, bolstering wage growth and ushering us into the land of milk and honey. Declaring that resisting the technology would be futile, Healey wrote: ‘It is coming, whether we like it or not.’
The government, of course, likes AI very much. Its enthusiasm for artificial intelligence reflects the desperation of politicians for some form of economic growth, following years of stagnation brought on by the 2008 financial crash. But what sort of growth, and for whom? Who will enjoy the benefits, should they materialise, and perhaps more crucially, who will pay the price for the boom?
Healey’s argument rests on the claim that AI-powered productivity gains will translate into higher workers for ordinary workers. There is precious little reason to believe this. The whole point of investing in labour-saving tech like AI, for capital, is so it can spend less on wages — creating a reserve army of labour and forcing those still in employment to do more for less. It tilts the whole playing field even further in favour of employers.
There is a longer-term contradiction, too: if AI-driven automation destroys jobs on a sufficiently large scale, as it threatens to do, the technology risks undermining the consumer purchasing power on which capitalism ultimately depends. Individual capitalists, however, rarely think this far ahead, concerned as they generally are with their own immediate, short-term profitability.
So, will workers really reap the rewards of higher productivity? Even a cursory look at the historical record gives good reason for scepticism. Research from the London School of Economics found that between 1981 and 2019, UK productivity increased by 87 percent, while median wages rose by just 62 percent. Organised labour’s weakened bargaining position, after a four-decade assault on trade union rights, is central to this divergence.
This is precisely why capital has bet the house on AI. Businesses see an opportunity to automate tasks previously performed by people, thereby weakening labour’s bargaining power further and boosting their profit margins. It is that simple. Healey’s rhetoric about the so-called ‘productivity revolution’ merely puts a gloss on another enormous transfer of wealth and power from labour to capital. It is a euphemism for job destruction.
The assumption seems to be that because previous waves of technological innovation eventually generated new industries and jobs, this one will be no different. But AI threatens employment across an extraordinary range of occupations — bear in mind, unemployed people already outnumber job vacancies by 1.7 million to 691,000 — with no guarantee that new jobs will emerge in anything like sufficient quantities to replace those eliminated.
What’s also absent from Healey’s boosterism is any acknowledgment of the potential environmental costs. According to a study from BloombergNEF, data centre developers across the UK, Ireland and Europe are planning up to 181GW of on-site gas-fired power generation, nearly four times Britain’s total peak demand for electricity. Healey has already opened the door to temporary on-site generation for data centres awaiting grid connections.
Data centres’ massive demand for energy also threatens to hit people directly in the wallet. Research from Global Action Plan estimates that data centre development could add as much as £2.6 billion to British household electricity bills by 2035, having already increased wholesale energy prices by an estimated £574 million between 2021 and 2025.
Alongside this, the government is hitching its growth strategy to a highly precarious investment boom. The recent volatility in tech stocks ought to serve as a warning: more than $3.2 trillion (£2.4 trillion) was wiped off the value of US shares in a single day of trading on 5th November, amid renewed fears that the AI bubble might be bursting. Building an entire country’s plans around an industry so reliant on investor exuberance and media hype is inherently fraught with risk.
At the same time as cheerleading for AI, the government is pursuing hefty cutbacks to social security. The new Milburn review proposes kicking under-25s off Personal Independence Payment — as if disabilities magically disappear between the ages of 18 and 24 — to cajole them into work, while the government simultaneously promotes technologies whose principal attraction to employers is that they eliminate the need for human labour.
This is the pincer movement of zombie Blairism, the fundamentally anti-worker creed that refuses to die, contrary to Andy Burnham’s promises of breaking with neoliberalism: the government is promoting AI (destroying jobs) while pushing benefit cuts on the other to force more people on to the labour market (regardless of whether they are fit to work), crushing wages even further.
Ultimately, the likes of Alan Milburn and Healey won’t be losing sleep over their future job prospects. There will always be sinecures and corporate consultancies awaiting them. But there is one occupation that could be automated away, entirely painlessly. Given the widespread incuriosity and indifference towards ordinary people’s lives, most politicians could be replaced by AI — and few of us would notice any difference.