Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

World Tribune

Letter to Shabana Mahmood: Hackney Will Not Suppress Free Speech

Following revelations that the Home Office tried to shut down Tribune’s autumn launch event, the Mayor of Hackney writes to Shabana Mahmood to demand accountability.

English (original) ·Read in Deutsch ⇄

Dear Secretary of State,

I am writing regarding recent attempts by Home Office officials to cancel an event hosted by Tribune magazine on Wednesday, 4 November, at a community arts venue owned by Hackney Council. As Mayor of Hackney, I am shocked by these actions and the precedent they set. Encouraging the cancellation of lawful public events represents an assault on the right to free speech and under no circumstance will I be complicit in it.

I understand that Home Office officials raised concerns with my council over the platforming of Huda Ammori, co-founder of Palestine Action, and Andreas Malm, a Swedish climate scholar at a launch held by Tribune magazine. Mr. Malm was prevented from travelling to the UK to speak in person in Hackney — a decision condemned by over 900 academics — leading the organisers to arrange for remote participation. Despite initial Home Office assessments indicating that the event was ‘unlikely to meet the threshold for disruption’, pressure was applied to Council staff to intervene with the operator and cancel the booking.

I am appalled by this attempt to influence decisions made locally here in Hackney and to suppress peaceful assembly and discussion in my borough. This action sits within the broader context of your government’s increasing erosion of our rights in relation to free speech and protest, condemned by the United Nations and human rights organisations such as Amnesty International and Liberty. These organisations warned that the proscription would be a slippery slope to further censorship of political speech and protest, and your department’s intervention in my borough has seen those fears become a reality.

The consequent chilling effect is not just on protest, but on cultural expression, academic freedom, and intellectual debate, with the effective ban on Sally Rooney’s books, bans on scholars entering the country, and now this attempt to cancel a lawful and legitimate political discussion.

Residents from our community have been among the over 4,000 people arrested under counter-terror laws for sitting at peaceful vigils, holding seven word cardboard signs, and now the Home Office has sought to interfere with their right to take part in discussion about this authoritarian ban on Palestine Action - discussion which is entirely lawful.

Let there be no doubt: I believe in the right to think and speak freely, the right to protest against the things we know to be perversely wrong — such as genocide — and the ability to come together to campaign for a better world, a world where governments do not stand idly by whilst the lives of millions are shattered through the violence of climate breakdown, war and occupation.

I am shocked that Council officers were given the impression by the Home Office that they should prevent Ms Ammori from speaking, who had been represented in the Supreme Court that very same day, and prevent the audience hearing from Mr Malm, whose books are available in shops across this country, who regularly appears on the BBC and addresses universities from Oxford and Cambridge to SOAS and King’s College.

Hackney Council has a clear duty under the Human Rights Act to uphold our residents’ right to free speech and free assembly in our decision making. I will do everything within my power to protect these rights against regressive and disproportionate state measures.

To address these concerns, I would like to understand the following:

● On what legal, regulatory, or statutory grounds did Home Office officials contact Hackney Council and venue managers regarding the booking at the Rose Lipman Building, and what specific risk assessment criteria were applied?

● Given that Home Office communications on 13 October stated the event was “unlikely to meet the threshold for disruption,” and police confirmed there was no indication of local disorder, what specific intelligence or altered assessment prompted the escalation on 2 and 3 November?

● Why was pressure exerted on local council officers to consider cancelling or vetoing speakers, and how does the Home Office reconcile these actions with local authorities’ statutory obligations to uphold free speech and peaceful assembly under the Human Rights Act?

● Since 2023, how many public or community events in Hackney concerning climate action, civil liberties, or international policy has the Home Office monitored, gathered intelligence on, or sought to intervene in?

I am immensely proud of our borough’s rich history of protest and community activism. Hackney residents bravely fought back against fascism on Ridley Road in the 1930s, built housing campaigns from Kingsland Road across the borough through the 1960s onward, and led vital anti-racist movements through the 1980s and 1990s — pursuing justice for our Black communities despite heavy surveillance and infiltration by undercover police officers.

Today, our community continues this tradition, including through many residents who have protested against the proscription of Palestine Action. For this, our residents have my deepest admiration and gratitude — they make Hackney a borough I am glad to be a part of. I look forward to hearing from you,

Kind regards,

Zoë Garbett

Originally published byTribune
Read the original