Germany taz
Prosperity in Capitalism: A Voracious Creature
VW slips into the billions because Porsche is worth less. It's all about future expectations. The case says a lot about capitalism. more...
Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English
Germany must become a growth engine again," demands Chancellor Friedrich Merz. Because without growth, our prosperity is in danger. But why should this prosperity be threatened just because it is not increasing? An answer to this question is currently provided by the crisis at the heart of the German economy: Volkswagen.
The Volkswagen Group suffered a heavy loss in the third quarter of 2026: 5.82 billion euros after taxes. The reason for the loss was not that Volkswagen spent a lot of money and earned much less. But so-called special effects, especially a write-down on the stake in Porsche of 6.4 billion euros. In other words: In the VW group books, the Porsche share was devalued by 6.4 billion euros, which means a loss in assets. For management, the deep red balance sheet is the reason for the planned closure of plants and the reduction of tens of thousands of jobs.
However, Luigi Pantisano, leader of the Left Party, sees this loss as “above all an accounting trick”. Although the Porsche devaluation means a loss of 6.4 billion, according to Pantisano, "not a single euro leaves the till here. Without special effects, VW earned 8.8 billion euros from operations in the first nine months. The cash flow in the car business has more than doubled, to 4.4 billion euros. ... This is not how a company looks like it is on the brink of the abyss." What's wrong with this criticism?
Among other things, he works as a freelance author for the weekly edition of “nd”. He has been working as a business journalist for 25 years, formerly for the Frankfurter Rundschau and the Berliner Zeitung. He studied business and economics in Berlin and Paris.
It's true that the Porsche write-off doesn't mean any real outflow of money for Volkswagen; the group did not spend 6.4 billion euros that it is now missing. Without the Porsche depreciation, his net profit would have been significantly better - probably even positive. The depreciation is purely a book loss.
Yet he is real. It arises because Porsche's business prospects are assessed as worse. Falling demand for luxury cars, US tariffs and competitive pressure in China will probably mean that Porsche will deliver less profit to Volkswagen. And since Porsche's current value depends on this future profit, this value will be revised downwards - meaning Volkswagen will lose 6.4 billion euros.
The fact that the value of a company is measured by whether and to what extent it makes a profit is not something that is unique to Volkswagen, but rather a capitalist norm. From the perspective of investors, the more returns a company brings or promises to bring in, the more valuable it is. The higher the expected profit, the higher the price that justifies a purchase - and a company that is unlikely to bring any profit or even losses is worth exactly nothing.
Thinking about it on a larger scale: the financial and productive wealth of society stands or falls under capitalism with whether this wealth is a means of increasing the net worth of the owners - in business administration terms. That is why the shareholders of real estate companies also complain about “expropriation” when rent regulation jeopardizes their freedom to increase rents and thus their returns and their investment thereby loses value.
Value and prosperity are therefore not a question of the quality of the goods produced, nor a question of innovation, technological status or the “scarcity” of a thing. All of this only counts in one way, namely how it helps the return. Anything that is not suitable for this purpose is worthless from an investor’s perspective.
The taz is an independent, left-wing and opinionated daily newspaper. We have been arguing in our comments, essays and debate texts since the taz was founded in 1979. We often cannot and do not want to agree on an opinion. That's why you'll find some completely opposing positions here - all part of the very broad left-wing spectrum of opinions.
Therefore, prosperity is threatened under capitalism if it does not grow permanently. Or more precisely: it is threatened if its growth threatens to fall short of expectations. Because only the future counts here. Prosperity under capitalism is speculative and therefore prone to fluctuations, as the example of Volkswagen/Porsche shows: Since the current value of the company depends on future earnings, an expected decline in earnings in the future will already lead to a balance sheet loss today - even though the company itself is intact.
The valued company is essentially dependent on its speculative valuation. It is based on this key figure that his financiers – banks, funds, shareholders – decide whether they will grant him loans or equity capital for his further growth and at what price. That's why a company's share price is an important key figure for investors because it reflects or should reflect the expected profitability.
The research department of management consultancy McKinsey estimated the world's wealth, i.e. global assets in the form of companies and financial assets, at around $1,800 trillion in 2025 - a record value. But McKinsey has doubts that this assessment is “healthy”. It can only be “temporarily seen as a sign of confidence in future economic growth”.
Whether this trust and thus the assets are justified depends on whether expected returns are achieved: “Only an acceleration of productivity,” explains McKinsey, “ensures real economic growth that justifies the valuations and thus protects assets.”
The wealth of the world in the form of accumulated wealth is, on the one hand, the wealth that is available. But its height rises and falls with its increase, which is measured by the return. Ensuring this growth remains the task of governments, societies and the population. “Our prosperity” (Merz), i.e. the speculatively extrapolated stock, bond, company and real estate values, is above all one thing: a demand on the population to maintain and increase the values through permanent increase, i.e. to always be industrious and cost-effective. Wealth under capitalism has a voracious nature.