Germany taz
Deportation camp in Rwanda: SPD MPs oppose plans for “return hubs”
Federal Interior Minister Dobrindt (CSU) is pushing ahead with plans for deportation centers outside the EU in Vienna. One location should be Rwanda. The SPD criticizes this. more...
Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English
afp/epd | The establishment of a deportation center in Rwanda, which Germany and four other EU countries are apparently aiming for, is meeting resistance from the SPD. He could not support the project unconditionally, “because I have far too many question marks about it and I also hear a lot of criticism about it from my group,” said SPD domestic politician Sebastian Fiedler to the Politico portal.
Federal Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt (CSU) will meet in Vienna on Monday with a group of countries that want to deport rejected asylum seekers to so-called return hubs outside the EU. According to diplomats, the countries have already agreed to open the first location for such deportation centers in Rwanda, Africa.
SPD MPs Rasha Nasr and Hakan Demir sharply criticized the plan to deport rejected asylum seekers to Rwanda, regardless of their origin. “We have to stop Dobrindt’s plans,” they told the Tagesspiegel. The Interior Minister's plans have not been coordinated with the SPD. Nasr and Demir emphasized that returns must generally take place to the countries of origin or to other countries to which the affected people have a connection.
What happens to the people after they are deported to Rwanda is completely unclear. “What job opportunities are there in Rwanda for people who have never been there and have just been deported from Germany?” asked the two MPs. The deportees were also threatened with “arbitrary imprisonment, torture, mistreatment and further deportations to unsafe states”.
Fiedler is also critical of the possible partner country Rwanda. “This model in Rwanda with a dictator ruling the country raises a lot of unanswered questions,” he said. It is also unclear whether the plans would hold up in court.
The 2027 federal budget earmarks 20 million euros for the model project. The project is not only morally questionable, but also expensive and ineffective, criticized Nasr and Demir. Fiedler also questioned the costs. "It costs a lot of money. 20 million euros for 40 places for the whole of Germany," he said. Last year, 24,000 people were taken out of the country. “The fact that we now want to spend so much money on 40 people is convincing and does not solve the basic problem.”
Germany is pushing ahead with the establishment of deportation centers outside the EU together with Denmark, Austria, the Netherlands and Greece. Asylum seekers whose applications have been rejected in the EU but who cannot be deported to their countries of origin can be brought to the so-called “return hubs”. The prerequisite for this is an agreement with the third country.
The International Organization for Migration (IOM) should also be involved in the talks between the countries. According to its spokesman, the IOM has many years of experience in supporting migrants in transit situations, even under difficult conditions. However, the organization is neither a party nor a negotiating partner in intergovernmental agreements on returns, the IOM spokesman told Welt am Sonntag. Rather, it provides care and support for migrants regardless of the respective context.
As Die Welt am Sonntag learned from coalition circles, the IOM could play a role in providing care and support on site. Meanwhile, within the federal government made up of the CDU, CSU and SPD, the Social Democratic Ministry of Justice also reported a need for discussion on the topic: “There are still numerous legal, practical and political questions that need to be clarified within the federal government,” it said. So far, the Federal Ministry of Justice has not been “formally” involved in the negotiations, Die Welt quotes ministry circles.
According to Justice Minister Stefanie Hubig (SPD), a possible agreement would have to be carefully examined to see whether it falls within international and European law requirements and takes sufficient account of the situation in the third country. Deportations of people who are obliged to leave the country to a “return hub” could “if at all only be considered under very strict conditions”.
According to the report, Left-wing Bundestag member Clara Bünger expects “that there will be a deal with Rwanda”. According to Welt am Sonntag, the group's refugee policy spokeswoman was recently in the East African country. She considers a possible agreement with Rwanda to be illegal: If those affected “do not have access to legal representation, then that is not constitutional,” said Bünger.
Several EU countries have already announced that they will set up “return hubs” in Rwanda: rejected asylum seekers who cannot be deported directly to their countries of origin will be accommodated in deportation centers in the East African country.
For years, Rwanda has been home to centers run by the UN refugee agency UNHCR, where refugees wait to be accepted in countries such as Canada or Germany. The human rights situation in the country is critical. According to Amnesty International, civil society's scope for action is severely limited.