Politics Perspektive Online
Secret service reform decided: The Office for the Protection of the Constitution is allowed to secretly monitor therapy sessions
In the future, the Office for the Protection of the Constitution will be able to gain covert access to practice and clinic rooms. Unlike lawyers or clergy, doctors and psychotherapists are not fundamentally
Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English
In the future, the Office for the Protection of the Constitution will be able to gain covert access to practice and clinic rooms. Unlike lawyers or clergy, doctors and psychotherapists are not fundamentally protected from surveillance measures. Trade associations sharply criticize the new law.
Last Friday, the Bundestag approved the reform of the Intelligence Service Act with 308 yes votesdecided. With the law coming into force on December 31, 2026, this will also have an impact on psychotherapy and other forms of medical treatment.
The reform not only enables the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution to listen to and record non-public words. According to Section 16 Paragraph 6 BVerfSchG-E, the service may enter buildings and rooms that are not apartments to prepare and carry out intelligence measures, even without the knowledge of the owner - for example to prepare or carry out technical surveillance measures. This generally also applies to practice and clinic rooms.
License to intervene: Bundestag is upgrading the secret services
There are also new powers to access information technology systems. Computers and smartphones, practice management systems and digital patient records could be affected. TheFederal Medical Associationwarns of the consequences of access to medical IT systems and electronic patient files.
The hurdle is lower for practice rooms
In the future, the powers will give the secret service the opportunity to gain covert access to a protected professional space. Higher legal hurdles apply to apartments. They may only be entered without the knowledge of the person concerned if there is a specific threat to particularly important legal interests and on the basis of a special order. The secret technical surveillance of living spaces is also subject to additional requirements. For practice and business premises, however, Section 16 Paragraph 6 does not provide for this special threshold for apartments.
The respective measures are subject to legal intervention thresholds and control requirements. However, doctors and psychotherapists are not generally exempt from them. According to the law, they are only considered relatively protected by professional secrecy - in contrast to lawyers and clergy, who are absolutely protected.
At the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, therapy discussions are not generally exempt from intelligence measures. This is what doctors and psychotherapists seeLawonly stipulates that the public interest in their tasks and the interest in the secrecy of entrusted facts must be “particularly taken into account”.
After the arrest of the ex-BND chief: US secret services check cooperation
The German Medical Association already demanded in the summer: “The doctor-patient relationship must be absolutely protected from measures by the intelligence services.” AAmendmentof the Greens, which was supposed to provide absolute protection for all those keeping professional secrecy, was rejected on November 13th with 313 votes to 257 and 2 abstentions.
Trade associations warn of a loss of trust
Also the specialist societies DGPPN, DGKJP and DGPMcriticizedShortly after the draft was presented, the protection of doctors and psychotherapists and thus their patients was “lower than that of other professional secrecy holders”. However, treatment can only be effective if there is trust in confidentiality. Anyone who fears surveillance can avoid necessary treatment or withhold important information.
The Federal Association of Contract Psychotherapists (bvvp)emphasized, Patients should also be able to talk about violent fantasies, aggressive impulses, radicalization, addictions and criminally relevant experiences without this being automatically viewed as actual danger.
The Union and the SPD only partially changed the draft after the criticism. For the Federal Intelligence Service, the Interior Committee expressly included doctors, dentists, psychotherapists, pharmacists and midwives in the protection of confidentiality relationships.Exceptionsare subject to special requirements and an independent prior check. This equality with other professional groups was not adopted for the Office for the Protection of the Constitution.
Upgrading externally and internally
The coalition justifies the reform by saying that the intelligence services need more operational options in the face of hybrid threats. In thefinal meetingexplained Sonja Eichwede (SPD): “We will have real defense services in the future.” Alexander Throm (CDU/CSU) spoke of a “quantum leap for our intelligence services”. Konstantin von Notz (Greens) also emphasized that the BND law was a “good day for the security of the Federal Republic” and that the reform was overdue.
Police, military and surveillance: Baden-Württemberg wants to learn from Israel
With regard to the protection of the constitution, however, he criticized, among other things, biometric internet comparisons and the use of minors as confidants. The government lacks “any sensitivity to civil rights,” said von Notz. Clara Bünger (Left Party) spoke of “comprehensive AI mass surveillance” and a “new German secret police”.
The postSecret service reform decided: The Office for the Protection of the Constitution is allowed to secretly monitor therapy sessionsappeared firstperspective.