Germany nd
SPD | Heil wants to become party chairman
Former Labor Minister Hubertus Heil wants to become SPD party leader. Meanwhile, Klingbeil defends his dual role. It is unclear who will still compete.
Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English
Hubertus Heil wants to become party leader of the SPD. Photo: Kay Nietfeld/dpa The power struggle for the SPD chairmanship is becoming more heated. After former Federal Labor Minister Hubertus Heil announced his candidacy for party leadership, pressure is growing on the previous incumbent, Lars Klingbeil. The Finance Minister and Vice Chancellor defended his dual role as a member of the government and party leader at the weekend - but has not yet announced whether he will run again. However, several working groups and the Jusos want to expressly prevent this at the federal party conference in January. Meanwhile, the Social Democrats' attention is focused on Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania's Prime Minister Manuela Schwesig. How the race for party leadership develops could depend on her decision, as she would be the most prominent candidate for the dual leadership.
Heil declared his candidacy for the federal party conference on January 16th and 17th in Bremen in a three-page letter to the state associations and the party executive committee on Saturday. The 54-year-old wrote that he wanted to “dedicate all my strength to becoming a party chairman.” At the head of a people's party, high commitment and full attention are required. The formulation can also be understood as a swipe at Klingbeil, who, in addition to being the party chairman, heads the Ministry of Finance and acts as Vice Chancellor.
If elected, Heil does not want to take up government office. Klingbeil should remain finance minister and vice chancellor, he said on Sunday evening on ARD. He himself wants to remain a directly elected member of the Bundestag and devote himself entirely to party work. On the one hand, the SPD must stand by its government responsibility, but on the other hand, it must make it clear what it stands for politically. “Twelve percent should not be the last word in history,” said Heil, referring to his party’s poor poll numbers.
Klingbeil continues to leave it open whether he will run for chairmanship again. However, at a dialogue event with around 120 members of the Brandenburg SPD in Potsdam, he defended the connection between party leadership and government office. He considers close coordination between the SPD as a party and the SPD in the government to be important. The Social Democrats must “act synchronously,” he said. There should be no different personnel camps.
The criticism of his dual role is not a new debate, said Klingbeil. At the event he received both support and opposition. Some members had expressly asked whether the responsibility in the party and government could be managed at the same time. The party leadership wants to present a personnel proposal by December 16th at the latest.
The fact that Klingbeil has not yet ruled out running again makes the power struggle explosive. Heil is the first official applicant, but by no means the last. The incumbent chairman can also imagine another term in office. At the same time, reservations about his leadership have increased in parts of the party in recent months.
The personnel debate is closely linked to the SPD's political crisis. Due to several defeats in state elections and persistently poor poll numbers, there is growing concern in the party that it is losing its own profile in the black-red federal government. The Social Democrats support numerous reform projects that are met with resistance among their base. The party leadership was repeatedly accused of not adequately preventing social cuts and not sufficiently asserting its own political positions against the Union.
The criticism ranges from the planned new regulation of working hours to the pension and care reform to changes in the welfare state. Sub-districts, regional associations and working groups had already called for a change of course in the summer. In September, the Working Group for Employment (AfA), the SPD women, the Jusos and the AG 60plus called for binding red lines in pension, labor market and social reforms. The central demand was that there should be no social cuts with the votes of the SPD.
Against this background, dissatisfaction is directed not only against individual decisions, but increasingly against the party leadership itself. Critics see the connection between government and party office as a structural problem: anyone who is both a minister and party leader can hardly criticize government policy independently. In addition, there is not enough time for organizational and programmatic work in the party.
The demand for a separation of offices is now supported by a broad alliance. The working group for work, the SPD women, the AG 60+, the working group for migration and diversity, the working group for education and the SPD queer working group support a corresponding application for the party conference. The Jusos also want to prevent the federal presidency from being linked to a ministerial office again. They go even further and expressly advocate for a female individual leadership, which, in addition to the feminist core, is clearly related to Klingbeil.
For Heil, this dissatisfaction offers an opportunity to position himself as an alternative to Klingbeil. The Lower Saxony was Federal Labor Minister for seven years and previously held several leading party and parliamentary positions. After the end of the traffic light coalition, however, he received neither a position in the new federal government nor in the parliamentary group. Since then he has sat as a member of the Foreign Affairs Committee. His candidacy therefore amounts to a return to the front row. The relationship with Klingbeil is considered tense.
Whether Heil represents a new political beginning is, however, controversial. After all, he was also part of the Social Democratic leadership for years and, as Labor Minister, was responsible for the course of the previous federal government. One of his central projects was the introduction of citizens' money. The subsequent criticism of the reform and the later tightening of social benefits also fell during his term of office. His opponents can therefore argue that Heil himself had sufficient opportunity to help shape the SPD's political direction.
He now receives support from various parts of the party. The SPD state chairman of Saxony-Anhalt, Andreas Schmidt, spoke out in favor of a dual leadership of Heil and Schwesig. Berlin's Senator for Economic Affairs, Franziska Giffey, also publicly campaigned for him. She described Heil as a politician who was close to the SPD and who could make the party accessible to broader sections of the population again.
Olaf Lies, chairman of the SPD Lower Saxony, probably the second most important SPD association after North Rhine-Westphalia, welcomes Heil's candidacy: "Competition is good for a vibrant party." Otherwise he remained reserved. He did not want to comment on who he supported and would wait for the party executive's proposal on December 16th. In mid-October, Lies had expressed "no doubt" that Klingbeil should continue to lead the SPD, preferably with Schwesig. What is particularly explosive is that both Heil, a founding member of the centrist Berlin network, and Klingbeil, a model member of the right wing of the party, are members of the Lower Saxony regional association.
For his part, Klingbeil can also point to prominent supporters. SPD parliamentary group leader Matthias Miersch still considers him to be a good party leader and warned against expecting a fundamental change from a single personnel decision. Federal Environment Minister Carsten Schneider, Defense Minister Boris Pistorius and Labor Minister Alexander Schweitzer also spoke out in favor of Klingbeil staying.
However, the decisive factor for the balance of power is whether Schwesig runs for party leadership. The Prime Minister of Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania is considered by many Social Democrats to be the most promising candidate. After her party's strong result in the state elections in September and the formation of a red-red-green coalition, she has gained additional weight within the SPD. On Monday she will stand for re-election as Prime Minister in the Schwerin state parliament.
Schwesig has not yet made a decision. She emphasizes that her government work in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania has priority. Heil also did not want to comment on whether he could imagine running for office together with her. He simply pointed out that Schwesig had shown in the past few weeks what she could achieve politically. Heil had suggested Schwesig as chairwoman in the past. The fact that they don't compete as a team could also be seen as a sign of weakness on Heil's part. Not competing as a team always has disadvantages if the opposing side plays as a team.
In the SPD, her name is still used in almost every conceivable constellation. A dual leadership with Heil or Klingbeil would be possible, but also a sole leadership by Schwesig. The Jusos in particular have brought such a variant into play with their demand for a female individual leader.
The question of who she would run with is also politically crucial. A dual leadership with Klingbeil could stabilize his position despite the criticism. Schwesig would represent the party as a popular representative of the states, while Klingbeil would retain his government positions. Collaboration with Heil would in turn strengthen criticism of the government's course.
Other names besides Schwesig are being traded, but so far their prospects are lower. Construction Minister Verena Hubertz and parliamentary group vice-presidents Wiebke Esdar and Siemtje Möller are considered possible candidates. Franziska Giffey also recently did not explicitly rule out her own candidacy, which could present her prominent support of Heil in a different light.
Meanwhile, Klingbeil tries to secure his own power base. North Rhine-Westphalia is particularly important. The largest SPD state association provides around a quarter of the delegates at the federal party conference. Criticism of the party chairman had recently become particularly clear there.
The Ruhr SPD had attested to a serious crisis of trust in the federal leadership and demanded a clearer social policy course. At a members' convention in Bochum at the beginning of November, Klingbeil had to face critical questions. Comrades criticized the dual role as party leader and finance minister. The 36 parliamentary group leaders of the Ruhr SPD had previously denounced the difficult municipal financial situation in a letter and called for 30 billion euros in start-up aid for the municipalities.
Klingbeil agreed to the request and was apparently able to improve the mood during his visit. This is politically important for a possible re-election. The alliance with the North Rhine-Westphalian top candidate Jochen Ott is also unlikely to be a coincidence. Klingbeil also faced the base in Potsdam. His dialogue tour not only serves to exchange political content, but also to seek support for a possible renewed candidacy.
How the balance of power develops will likely be decided in the coming weeks until December 16th, when the party leadership presents a personnel proposal. Until then it remains to be seen whether the SPD will confirm its current chairman, should he take office, or whether it would prefer to make a fresh start. With agencies.
This article cost you nothing. Us: research, production and technology. We saved on office rent as well as on printing and distribution. And we gave up salary. Nevertheless, the calculation doesn't work without you. We need 300,000 euros by the end of the year. You pay what you can, in return we keep writing.
No paywall, no small print, just one goal: that nd stays.