Politics nd
New EU law | A true circular economy does not start at the recycling center
Instead of just making our waste management more efficient, we need to reduce our consumption of resources. Because it is not compatible with planetary boundaries, our columnist knows.
Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English
Photo: AFP/THOMAS SAMSON The EU Commission will present a proposal for a new Circular Economy Act (CEA) at the beginning of December. The new law is more than a waste policy instrument. It is a decision about how Europe will produce, consume and do business in the future.
EU resource consumption is incompatible with planetary boundaries. Instead of making the best possible use of existing resources, the environment and people around the world are being exploited, entire regions are becoming sacrifice zones - areas in which life is only possible to a limited extent, if at all.
Inside Europe is the joint monthly column by »nd« and the European platform die-zukunft.eu. Activists, MPs, representatives of NGOs, scientists and other people interested in Europe take a critical look at the EU and developments in Europe.
The Circular Economy Act opens up an important opportunity to realign EU resource policy. But this opportunity threatens to be lost if the law primarily facilitates trade in secondary raw materials, simplifies the cross-border shipment of waste and increases recycling rates. Such a policy would treat the symptoms without adequately addressing the causes. It would make waste management more efficient, but would not necessarily reduce our consumption of resources.
A true circular economy does not start at the recycling center. It begins with the question of how many resources we actually use - and why we keep producing so many products from scratch even though we could use existing ones for longer. This puts it in contradiction to the current capitalist model, in which the sale of new goods has the highest priority.
The new law would have to anchor the waste hierarchy in a binding manner: prevention before reuse and repair, recycling only afterwards. The aim should be to use products for longer, to make them repairable and to conserve resources.
To achieve this, Europe needs binding and verifiable targets to reduce resource consumption and the material and consumption footprint. If targets are missed, corrective measures must be taken. It is crucial to bring Europe's resource consumption into line with planetary boundaries.
A sustainable economy also starts with product design. Products should be durable, repairable and reusable. Spare parts and repair information must be accessible and truly efficient structures for repairs have yet to be created.
The destruction of usable goods is not compatible with a serious circular economy. There needs to be a comprehensive ban on disposing of unsold and returned products that are fully functional. Sales, donation, reuse and refurbishment must take priority.
Anyone who puts products on the market must also take responsibility for their end of life instead of passing the costs on to municipalities and public budgets. Manufacturers must co-finance collection and treatment. Their taxes should be based more closely on the environmental impact of their products.
The use of the taxes is also crucial: in addition to collection and recycling, they must also finance prevention, repairs, reuse and refurbishment.
Manufacturer responsibility must be extended to other product groups. In the construction industry, mandatory tests are required before demolition and renovation as well as concrete reuse goals for components. In addition to the recovery of raw materials, longer use, repair and reuse of electrical appliances must also be promoted more strongly. The same applies to furniture, mattresses and carpets.
A true circular economy must reduce the absolute consumption of resources instead of legitimizing ever-growing consumption under the guise of sustainability. We need an economy that prioritizes frugality and community well-being over endless consumption - to protect our planet and those communities whose livelihoods and lives fall victim to resource extraction.
This article cost you nothing. Us: research, production and technology. We saved on office rent as well as printing and distribution. And we gave up salary. Nevertheless, the calculation doesn't work without you. We need 300,000 euros by the end of the year. You pay what you can, in return we keep writing.
No paywall, no small print, just one goal: that nd stays.