Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

Germany nd

Coalition | Coalition committee becomes a stress test for Merz

Merz promises a reduction in electricity taxes, but the SPD is demanding counter-financing. Dissatisfaction with coalition partners and the chancellor is growing in the CDU.

Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English

Chancellor Friedrich Merz is calling for a reduction in electricity taxes. However, Markus Söder does not want to sacrifice the mother's pension for this. Photo: AFP/ALEXANDRA BEIER It's about five billion euros, but it's no longer just about a tax. When the leaders of the Union and SPD meet for the coalition committee in the Chancellery on Tuesday evening, the focus will be on the reduction in electricity taxes for everyone promised by Chancellor Friedrich Merz (CDU). The Chancellor is under enormous pressure within his own ranks and has once again prematurely announced an agreement, although the counter-financing remains unclear. For Merz, it is again about his credibility. Above all, the dispute over the electricity tax has developed into a conflict over the political direction of the Union: Which relief measures should have priority, who should pay for them and how much should budget consolidation cost the welfare state?

On Monday, after a meeting with the CSU board, Merz confirmed that the electricity tax should fall to the European minimum in 2027. "We'll come to an agreement tomorrow," he announced. But the Ministry of Finance, of all places, seems to know little about the announced solution. When asked what the announced solution would look like, people in the company said: "We would like to know that too." The budget is currently missing around five billion euros per year to extend the reduction. The Union and SPD budgets did not find any counter-financing. The promise is not taken into account in the budget for 2027 with a volume of around 561 billion euros.

According to calculations by the comparison portal Verivox, a three-person household with 4,000 kilowatt hours of annual consumption would save around 90 euros a year after the tax cut. Marcel Fratzscher, President of the German Institute for Economic Research (DIW), considers the measure to be socially unbalanced. Families with low incomes in particular hardly benefited.

For the Union, the electricity tax is now a question of political ability to act. The Union and SPD had agreed on the reduction in the coalition agreement. So far, however, it has only been implemented for the manufacturing industry as well as agriculture and forestry. The fact that private households and other sectors of the economy were left empty-handed is causing considerable dissatisfaction.

The anger about this erupted last week at a special meeting of the Union faction. “There was a real bang there,” reported CDU financial politician Mathias Middelberg on Deutschlandfunk. “Pretty much everyone expressed their opinion yesterday.” The CDU/CSU’s debate lasted significantly longer than that of the SPD.

Middelberg himself, who is part of the economic wing, questioned the government's priorities. He thinks it makes more sense to reduce the electricity tax than to implement the third stage of the mother's pension. The business wing expects the electricity tax reduction to bring about economic growth - precisely because this would also affect all other companies. In doing so, however, he touches on a conflict that has been simmering within the Union for a long time: The CSU had pushed through the expansion of the mother's pension to parents of children born before 1992 - it is its core project. "The mother's pension has been decided, it is not up for discussion," explained CSU regional group leader Alexander Hoffmann. Markus Söder also refuses to question the pension benefit in favor of the electricity tax reduction, but also supports the plans to reduce electricity tax.

North Rhine-Westphalia's Prime Minister Hendrik Wüst (CDU) unambiguously calls for a reduction in electricity taxes for everyone. “This has to happen now,” he said at a small party conference of the Lower Saxony CDU. The relief, which was initially limited to individual sectors, was a mistake.

The reduction in electricity tax is supported by large parts of the Union, but there is internal debate about its financing and prioritization compared to other projects. At the beginning of November, the chairmen of the CDU and CSU state parliamentary groups jointly called for the electricity tax to be reduced to the European minimum. The CDU employee wing is also calling for the reduction in order to get the cost of living under control.

Meanwhile, Pascal Reddig, chairman of the Young Group of the Union faction, criticizes the Chancellor's communication. "We shouldn't pursue an announcement policy," he said on N-TV. An issue should not be given such public attention if the counter-financing is unclear. The debate triggered an “extreme crisis of credibility”. Reddig also held his own party responsible: After all, it was not possible to mobilize five billion euros in a budget of more than 550 billion euros.

The criticism in the Großbeeren local association in Brandenburg is even harsher. At a general meeting, he unanimously called for Merz to resign as chancellor and CDU chairman. Association boss Adrian Hepp justified this with the lack of a reduction in electricity taxes. Merz broke a central election promise and let the SPD "lead him through the ring on the ring." Incidentally, Hepp's personal preferred candidate for successor is Markus Söder. The fact that the electricity tax of all things is the reason for a demand for resignation shows how much frustration has built up in the Union and how much is being projected onto this dispute.

Behind the dispute are different ideas about how scarce resources should be distributed. The Union is relying on tax cuts and at the same time calling for subsidies and government spending to be reduced. Middelberg announced that in view of the low economic growth, greater cuts would have to be made in support programs, financial aid and social spending. "There's no other way," he said. The CDU and CSU state parliamentary group leaders also see a “need for reform” in pensions, health and care.

However, the SPD is resisting further cuts in social benefits and is relying on redistribution. She can imagine higher corporate or withholding tax on capital gains. The Union rejects this again.

The German Social Association is now warning against playing off mothers' pensions and electricity tax cuts against each other. “Tasks for society as a whole must be reliably financed from tax revenue,” said SoVD boss Michaela Engelmeier.

In addition to taxes, there are other conflicts on the agenda. When it comes to pension reform, Merz wants to clarify open points of contention on Tuesday and agree on a timetable. Above all, the possible abolition of the pension without deductions after 45 years of contributions is controversial - the SPD and eastern regional associations of the CDU are against it. A cabinet decision before the Christmas break is still the goal.

The SPD also wants to address Economics Minister Katherina Reiche's (CDU) fuel price cap. Your draft only provides for a maximum price when petrol and diesel are significantly above the EU average for three weeks. The SPD considers this to be ineffective and instead demands actual maximum prices and limited margins. Klingbeil also demands a commitment to the excess profits tax, the Union rejects it nationally.

The chairwoman of the Die Linke party, Ines Schwerdtner, explained that with this tax the five billion euros for the electricity tax reduction could be quickly raised: "The federal government just has to finally trust the excess profits of the oil companies." This means that 6.7 billion euros could be skimmed off in Germany.

It remains to be seen whether the coalition committee can agree on financing the electricity tax reduction. Merz has put himself under pressure to act with his promise. An agreement without viable counter-financing would only postpone the dispute. If he fails again, discontent within his own faction is likely to grow. The question of his leadership would also arise again. With agencies.

Other media have corporations or billionaires behind them. We have the nd.Genossenschaft and readers like you. That makes us independent and that’s exactly how we want to remain. But it also means: without you the calculation won't work. We need 300,000 euros by the end of the year.

You can donate directly here, one-time or regularly, so that nd stays.

Originally published bynd
Read the original