Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

Politics nd

Egypt | Abandoned by Europe

In North Africa, government critics are under pressure. The prominent Egyptian journalist Lina Attalah is currently having to stand trial.

Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English

Lina Attalah, editor-in-chief of the court-ordered news website Mada Masr, one of Egypt's last independent news media, gives an interview to the Associated Press at her home in Cairo, Egypt. Photo: dpa Thanks to a thoughtless statement by a police officer, Lina Attalah already knew in the summer that the Egyptian justice system had targeted her. After a trip to the Red Sea, the journalist and friends were caught in a traffic stop. The officer asked for the group's identification and ran a check on the names in the police system. “You were sentenced to a year in prison and are still free?” the officer wondered and let them drive on.

The founder of the independent media platform "Mada Masr", like many journalists critical of the government in Egypt, has experienced a lot: state spies who have been on her and her six-person team since the founding of "Mada Masr", bureaucratic hurdles and massive threats after the publication of articles. But now the last independent media platform is apparently to be closed forever. Despite the risk of being arrested at any time, the 43-year-old Egyptian stayed in Cairo and continued to work.

It has been clear for two months that the authorities are not just targeting Mada Masr, but all remaining critical voices in the country. At the end of September, six reporters from the investigative platform “Matsadaash” were arrested. Five of them disappeared for several days until they reported from prison. Amnesty International reports that the journalists were tortured and pressured to admit their guilt on camera.

On November 10, a prosecutor extended the 15-day pretrial detention for a third time. Even if the details of the charges are not yet public, as in many other cases, the charges boil down to the same charges: “supporting a terrorist organization,” “spreading false reports,” and “operating an illegal media platform.” Critical journalists are generally assumed to have an ideological affinity with the Muslim Brotherhood, whose leadership is in prison after the military coup in 2013 and which has been banned by the courts.

The public prosecutor's office also accuses Lina Attalah of operating the "Mada Masr" website without authorization. At the end of October, a court ordered the closure of the website, which is particularly popular among young Egyptians. Previously, on October 21, Attalah was interrogated for several hours and released on bail of the equivalent of 2,000 euros. On the 27th, the journalist was taken away in handcuffs and spent another seven hours in a courthouse. A fine of the equivalent of almost 50,000 euros has now been imposed for distributing texts on “Mada Masr” without permission. After a spontaneous call for donations among readers and supporters, she was able to pay the fine and has been waiting ever since for her hearing in the trial.

It has been clear for two months that the authorities are not just targeting Mada Masr, but all remaining critical voices in the country.

The current campaign against the remaining independent media could end with long prison sentences, civil society representatives with whom “nd” spoke fear. They do not want to comment publicly at the moment. "The Egyptian leadership is under enormous pressure because of the constantly rising food prices, the situation in the Gaza Strip and falling revenues from the Suez Canal," says an activist who is friends with Attalah. "There is probably an enormous fear of a new protest movement." 18 journalists are currently in prison. The organization Reporters Without Borders ranks Egypt in 169th place (out of 180 countries) on its current press freedom index.

The temporary end of “Mada Masr” fits in with the actions of the authorities in other North African countries. In Tunisia, the entire leadership of the Muslim Brotherhood-affiliated Ennahda party is in prison. Critical media such as “Inkyfada” and “Nawaat” have been temporarily closed or are under pressure because of donations from European foundations. Four journalists are in prison, and 20 others have been or are being investigated. TV commentator Sonia Dahmani was sentenced to several years in prison for allegedly spreading false information. In a talk show, she ironically commented on the living conditions of Tunisian youth and migrants from sub-Saharan Africa in the country.

In Libya, Hassan Bakir of the Lana news agency was kidnapped from his office in Misrata on October 20 and tortured. He had written about the embezzlement of public funds and corruption in the port city.

In Morocco, many civil society representatives and journalists have logged off social media. Even a slightly critical comment on Tiktok or Instagram can lead to an investigation. Many offices of AMDH, the largest and oldest human rights organization in the country, are currently operating without an official license. The activists emphasize that this was requested, similar to what “Mada Masr” had done again and again in Cairo.

The fact that North Africa's increasingly autocratic governments still adhere to formalities in their actions against critics, at least externally, also has to do with their Western donors. The migration agreements with Egypt, Morocco, Libya and Tunisia would be at risk if more journalists like Libyan Hassan Bakir were punished for their mafia-style work. Civil society in North Africa feels betrayed by Europe.

So far there has been little criticism of the proceedings against Lina Attallah and her colleagues from the EU - even though she received the Franco-German Prize for Human Rights in 2022. On Wednesday afternoon, the ninth chamber of the New Cairo District Court decided to suspend the ongoing trial against Attalah until a decision is made on her lawyers' complaints about a 2024 verdict.

Lina Attalah, co-founder and editor-in-chief of the independent Egyptian news website “Mada Masr” received the Press Freedom Prize from Reporters Without Borders in Paris in 2022. Photo: IMAGO/Abacapress Back then, too, the journalist was sentenced to one year in prison and a fine of two million pounds for spreading false reports and not having a license - without knowing it. She only found out because of the police officer's carelessness during the traffic stop. On November 25th, a court in Cairo North will examine the lawyers' complaints. The current proceedings could then be restarted – with the same charges. A reprieve that gives the EU diplomats time to speak up loudly and clearly for “Mada Masr”.

This article cost you nothing. Us: research, production and technology. We saved on office rent as well as printing and distribution. And we gave up salary. Nevertheless, the calculation doesn't work without you. We need 300,000 euros by the end of the year. You pay what you can, in return we keep writing.

No paywall, no small print, just one goal: that nd stays.

Originally published bynd
Read the original