Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

Germany nd

Deportation center in Rwanda | Agreement on deportation center in Rwanda: people as general cargo

Germany and four other EU countries want to send rejected asylum seekers to the East African country on a blanket basis. SPD politicians have concerns.

Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English

Refugees in the “transit center” in Gashora, Rwanda. They were brought there from Libya. Dobrindt and others want it to be expanded into a “return hub”. Photo: Imago/Xinhua/Cyril Ndegeya Every step towards even more deportations without mercy and without considering the individual case is a top priority for the German Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt. He also shows this through expensive events he organizes himself, such as the migration summit on Germany's highest mountain, the Zugspitze in 2025.

He is currently in Vienna at a meeting with representatives from four other EU states about finding a non-European “return hub”. The participants there officially announced on Monday that they had agreed to create such a deportation center for rejected asylum seekers in Rwanda. A corresponding migration agreement with the landlocked East African country is in the works. Dobrindt assured on Monday afternoon in Vienna that the plans would be implemented "in accordance with human rights." The aim is to enforce departure obligations even in cases in which countries of origin or rejected asylum seekers do not cooperate sufficiently.

The other participants in the “Vienna Migration Conference” were government members from Denmark, the Netherlands, Austria and Greece. The host was the infamous International Center for Migration Policy Development (ICMPD).

"This model in Rwanda with a dictator who rules the country raises a lot of questions."

The creation of deportation centers outside the EU is part of the new EU return regulation passed by the EU Parliament in June with the votes of the extreme right-wing parties. People are to be “repatriated” there whose applications have been rejected in the EU but who cannot be deported to their countries of origin. The prerequisite is an agreement between one or more EU countries and a third country that sets up one or more such centers.

If the plans are implemented, it involves deportations to a country to which the vast majority of those affected have no personal connection at all. According to the regulation, those affected must never have been there and must not have any relatives there. In bureaucratic language, this personal connection is called a “connecting element.” The coalition agreement between the Union and the SPD already states that they want to delete this from the EU guidelines. According to the new EU regulation, a partner country in which such centers are set up must “respect international human rights standards and principles in accordance with international law”.

Human rights organizations and church associations sharply criticized the plans. It seems as if the EU regulation normalizes the “use of detention in prison-like facilities outside EU territory,” complained Marta Welander from the International Rescue Committee (IRC). Bread for the World explained that the decision in favor of Rwanda was “highly problematic.” Deportees would be “left helpless in a state with massive constitutional deficits.”

Valeria Hänsel, consultant for the EU border regime at the aid organization Medico International, called the Rwanda plan a "new level of escalation in the disenfranchisement of those seeking protection." By creating return hubs, the EU would be adopting a practice “in which people are treated like moving masses.” Hansel continues: "The EU states are trying to get rid of not only people, but also their own responsibility for their rights and safety."

"The EU states are trying to get rid of not only people, but also their own responsibility for their rights and safety."

The new EU return regulation creates the legal basis for people to be deported “possibly after years in Europe, without family or social networks in the destination country,” said Hänsel. In addition, the Austrian asylum authority in Rwanda documented “torture in custody, arbitrary arrests and impunity within the security organs.” Experiences with the previous Israeli deportation model to Rwanda and Uganda have also shown that, despite promises of protection, people there are forced to make dangerous journeys and end up in the hands of human traffickers.

The left-wing MEP Özlem Alev Demirel recalled that “refugees from Rwanda receive protection in the EU”. Now “the same country should serve as a deportation site,” she explained on Monday. The plans represent "a European isolation policy that makes human rights a bargaining chip." What is needed instead is “safe escape routes, constitutional asylum procedures and a policy that combats the causes of flight rather than the people who are fleeing from them.”

»People must not be reduced to mere objects of state action. But that is the case when they are deported to states that are completely foreign to them. This is nothing more than a state kidnapping.”

For Demirel's comrade in the Bundestag, Clara Bünger, deportations to Rwanda would be "nothing more than a state kidnapping." "Not even families with children should be exempt from this - a clear violation of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child," the left-wing politician made clear. “Ultimate brutality and deterrence” are “not an unwanted side effect of the project, but rather an essential goal of the measure.” This is neither compatible with the human dignity principle of the Basic Law nor with the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights. It is “absurd to expect that refugees deported from Europe” will have access to legal procedures in Rwanda, said Bünger, who recently traveled to the country.

There were also objections to the Rwanda plan from the coalition partner SPD. The SPD domestic politician Sebastian Fiedler told the Politico portal that he could not support the project “unconditionally”. “This model in Rwanda with a dictator who rules the country raises a lot of questions.” The SPD MPs Rasha Nasr and Hakan Demir called for the plans to be stopped in the “Tagesspiegel”. Returns would generally have to take place to the countries of origin or to other countries to which the people concerned have a connection. Deportees in Rwanda are threatened with “arbitrary imprisonment, torture, mistreatment and further deportations to unsafe states.” The project has not been agreed upon in the coalition.

At the beginning of 2025, the SPD-led Federal Development Ministry canceled planned government consultations with Rwanda. The background was the M23 militia's push, supported by the country, to conquer the city of Goma in the Democratic Republic of Congo. Acting department head Reem Alabali Radovan also reminded us of this on Monday. “I am fundamentally critical of the concept of return hubs,” said Alabali Radovan to the “Frankfurter Rundschau”.

On behalf of the Union parties, Alexander Throm (CDU) rejected the criticism from the SPD and recalled the agreements in the coalition agreement. The obligation to leave the country means “nothing other than an unlawful stay, regardless of whether it is tolerated or not,” the domestic policy spokesman for the Union parliamentary group told the AFP news agency and added. "In the overall system of asylum policy, return hubs can become a game changer due to their signaling effect: the blockades of individual countries on returns could finally be broken through this innovative system."

Meanwhile, SPD man Fiedler also pointed out the high costs of German participation in the deportation center: “It costs a lot of money. 20 million euros for 40 places for the whole of Germany. A spokesman for the Ministry of the Interior explained that the sum was not intended solely for return hubs. It is also about migration and repatriation agreements as well as “projects” in third countries.

While Italy is considered a pioneer with deportation centers in Albania, other EU states such as France are not planning such facilities. "I believe that this is neither effective nor in accordance with our principles," said French President Emmanuel Macron in June.

In Great Britain, the government of then Labor Prime Minister Keir Starmer scrapped a similar regulation in 2024 after it was rejected as illegal by the Supreme Court. In 2022, the government of Conservative Prime Minister Boris Johnson reached an agreement with Rwanda to accept undocumented migrants who had come to Great Britain via the English Channel. However, this involved deportations before those affected could even submit and justify asylum applications. Starmer's successor Andy Burnham said he was following the initiative of the five EU countries "with interest."

The Rwandan government confirmed in August that there were discussions with representatives of Germany and other European countries about setting up deportation centers. Among other things, the transit center in Gashora, about 60 kilometers from the capital Kigali, is under discussion. Since 2019, refugees who had previously arrived in Libya and were, for example, prevented from traveling on to the EU have been accepted there.

The opening of the first “Return Hub” is planned for next year. According to information from negotiating circles, the five EU states initially want to start with a small pilot project and bring around 20 people to Rwanda each. The planned facility should not be a closed detention center.

Other media have corporations or billionaires behind them. We have the nd.Genossenschaft and readers like you. That makes us independent and that’s exactly how we want to remain. But it also means: without you the calculation won't work. We need 300,000 euros by the end of the year.

You can donate directly here, one-time or regularly, so that nd stays.

Originally published bynd
Read the original