Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

Politics Morning Star

On joblessness and Brexit, Burnham’s solutions prop up a broken system

WHAT do Andy Burnham’s pitch for a new deal with the European Union and his government’s plans for jobless youth have in common? Both are sticking-plaster solutions when the cause of the ailments — we

English (original) ·Read in Deutsch ⇄

Editorial / 15 November 2026 A generation that has been cast aside could usher in social change 15 November 2026 Editorial / 13 November 2026 The answer to unemployment is reindustrialisation, not cutting benefits 13 November 2026 Editorial / 12 November 2026 Sedwill threats will lead to annihilation 12 November 2026 Editorial / 11 November 2026 So much Palestine needs, so much Britain could do 11 November 2026 Editorial / 10 November 2026 Socialist advance in US has global significance 10 November 2026 Editorial / 9 November 2026 Thames Water’s creditor drama shames a Labour Party pledged to reverse Thatcherism 9 November 2026 Editorial / 8 November 2026 War, law and Remembrance Sunday 8 November 2026 WHAT do Andy Burnham’s pitch for a new deal with the European Union and his government’s plans for jobless youth have in common?

Both are sticking-plaster solutions when the cause of the ailments — weak exports and mass unemployment, respectively — requires major surgery.

They are not the “quick fixes” Burnham hyped up in his first weeks as PM — a lower cap on bus fares, removing VAT on electricity bills — because they will not deliver results quickly.

Whether they will end up passing his cannily coined “Makerfield test” — delivering tangible improvements in people’s lives — will be harder to judge and easier to fudge.

They might. British farmers and manufacturers would benefit, all else being equal, from fewer EU regulations on their exports to the bloc’s member states. Young people participating in the government-funded “jobs guarantee,” whereby private businesses such as Lidl and Leonardo Hotels take people on six-month work placements with the public paying their (minimum) wages, may learn skills and discipline that will help them find and keep jobs in the future.

These are not irrelevant considerations. But while longer-term in scope, these plans are not more ambitious than lowering the cap on bus fares.

They take too much about Britain’s dysfunctional status quo for granted, belying the vision with which Burnham enthused a tired Labour Party and movement in July, of a bold plan to reverse 40 years of neoliberalism, the privatisation of economic power and the centralisation of political power.

If this country has a handout culture, it is the owners of private capital and land who have got used to living off handouts, from the incompetent outsourcing firms leeching off the public purse to the landlords whose extortionate rents force up housing benefit.

The Jobs Guarantee Scheme repeats this model, effectively giving participating employers free labour at the public’s expense.

While they are supposed to create roles for it, bringing in long-term unemployed youth, these may simply replace vacancies the employer would have advertised anyway, and a clause saying they must not “displace existing employees, workers, apprentices or contractors” will be hard to police given the number of reasons an employer can give for terminating staff, low union density in most sectors of the workforce and the absence of any requirement for participating employers to recognise unions.

Subsidising jobs in this way is another variation on a familiar theme, the public absorbing liabilities so business can make profits with reduced risk.

Some training of workers may be a by-product, but the scheme does nothing to address the root causes of mass unemployment and low-wage employment, blights on the British economy stemming from deindustrialisation and underinvestment by the state and private capital. This does not reverse neoliberalism but props it up.

We should apply the same test to Burnham’s proposals to revisit Brexit terms.

He says we did not “take back control” by leaving the European Union.

This is true — but it is true because the freedom from EU requirements on competition in public services or state aid has not been used, as governments have remained wedded to market solutions that have palpably failed.

“Buy British” procurement rules would do more for manufacturing and agriculture than a renegotiated EU treaty. Nationalising what were once called the “commanding heights” of the economy — energy, water, transport, steel — would enable a planned rebuilding of Britain’s industrial capacity, which would do more for exports and more for jobs than anything the government is currently considering.

Some will say there is no point in holding Burnham up to his “reverse neoliberalism” rhetoric: either he never meant it or Labour is too compromised a party to allow it.

But the administration should be held to its promises. Its policies must be judged against them — and if, as here, they are found wanting, we have a job to popularise the alternatives we need.

Editorial / 13 November 2026 The answer to unemployment is reindustrialisation, not cutting benefits 13 November 2026 Europe / 22 September 2026 Burnham warned against rejoining EU 22 September 2026 Editorial / 18 August 2026 Disabled bus passes – a small reform, but a welcome change of approach 18 August 2026 Editorial / 22 July 2026 Burnham’s quick wins don’t indicate a plan for real reform 22 July 2026 Waiting for the grander vision to emerge

Originally published byMorning Star
Read the original