Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

Politics labournet.de

[Right to demonstrate] The civil service between courage and duty Conflict situations for civil servants when giving instructions from an authoritarian-populist house leadership

"In the next few weeks there will be local elections in various federal states, and in September there will be state elections in Brandenburg, Saxony and Thuringia. What options or even obligations to respond exist

Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English

"In the next few weeks there will be local elections in various federal states, and state elections in Brandenburg, Saxony and Thuringia in September. What options or even obligations do civil servants have to respond if officials of an authoritarian-populist party reach the highest administrative positions and subsequently issue legally questionable orders while on duty? As the civil service laws show, civil servants in such constellations can find themselves in legal and emotional situations of uncertainty and conflict advice that should not be underestimated…”Article by Andreas Nitschke from May 24, 2024 in the Constitution Blog externer Linkand more about it:

  • Authorities in Saxony-Anhalt: When the employer turns blueNew
    “The AfD could rule in Saxony-Anhalt in a month. How are police officers, teachers and government employees doing with this?
    There are 37 questions and answers that are intended to ensure the “survival” of teachers in Saxony-Anhalt. For example: Can a teacher be required to sing the national anthem every morning at school? No. Or: Can a history teacher still talk about National Socialism if future curricula are supposed to focus on the period between 1813 and 1871? Yes. The answers come from the education union GEW. In mid-September, shortly after the state elections, sheSurvival guide“externer Linkpublished for teachers in Saxony-Anhalt.(…)
    Nobody wants to talk openly. But if you ask around among teachers, police officers and public service employees, you will find a lot of uncertainty. “Many people are wondering whether they will still be at work in January,” says one person. “Everyone is waiting to see what’s coming.”
    And then the question arises: what to do? On the one hand, says an employee of a ministry, the administration is solely committed to the free democratic basic order and not to any party. But what if an AfD minister made obviously unconstitutional decisions? “I can't imagine that many administrative employees would support this and thus become accomplices of AfD politics,” she says and is determined to keep her job, regardless of the minister. "If I leave, then maybe a candidate close to the AfD will take over. I don't want to allow that."
    An employee of another ministry sees it differently. Some of his colleagues have just taken out legal protection insurance in order to be prepared for possible labor law proceedings. He himself is looking for jobs in other federal states. (…)
    Ulrich Stock, state chairman of the Civil Service Association, speaks of a “tense silence” in the administration. But also that he hardly sees any civil servants giving up their jobs now. However: “We have never had so many inquiries about protesting.” The term means the obligation for officials to refuse illegal instructions. Employees in public authorities, on the other hand, are not obliged to do this.
    The Civil Service Association is currently bringing its member unions up to speed in this regard, reports Stock. However, he worries whether the judiciary can decide quickly enough if legal disputes arise over AfD instructions. In an emergency, the administrative courts in Halle or Magdeburg would come into play. These are already heavily overloaded, especially with asylum applications. Some ministries began making their subject areas democratic-proof some time ago. (…)
    And in the Ministry of the Interior and the security authorities there are concrete considerations as to how sensitive security data and employees of the State Office for the Protection of the Constitution can be protected - for example by outsourcing them to federal authorities. The AfD could also not hire like-minded people as civil servants at will: because they have to pass a constitutional test. And so far, activities by organizations classified as right-wing extremists have been considered an obstacle, in Saxony-Anhalt explicitly also by the AfD or the Identitarians. (…)
    However, an AfD government could withdraw such decrees and change the laws again. She still wouldn't be able to reach every classroom
    …”Article by Anne Fromm, David Muschenich, Konrad Litschko and Christian Rath from November 15, 2026 in the taz online externer Link

  • The judiciary should defend itself: After the AfD victory, the judges' association warns against political abuse of the judiciary, Federal Justice Minister Hubig calls on officials to resist
    • After AfD success in Saxony-Anhalt: Hubig calls on officials to resist
      “Federal Justice Minister Stefanie Hubig (SPD) has called on officials in Saxony-Anhalt to resist illegal instructions from a possible AfD state government. “Civil servants swear an oath to the constitution,” Hubig told the newspapers of the Funke media group. "You must abide by the law and the law. If an official feels that they are being given unlawful instructions, they must clearly express the concerns internally." An officer cannot rely on “just doing what he was told,” she added. At the same time, Hubig showed understanding for the uncertainty of many citizens: “I can very well understand that many people are very worried about an AfD government.” (…)
      Justice should defend itself
      “I am sure that the judiciary would block any attempt to exert influence,” said the minister. In the case of public prosecutors, the legal framework is different because, as part of the executive branch, they are subject to ministerial authority. However, this is limited. Hubig expressed “no doubt that public prosecutors would also resist illegal instructions.” The minister also referred to federal funds against possible legal violations by an AfD-led state government. “The states are just as bound to the requirements of the Basic Law. And there is the principle of federal loyalty,” said Hubig. If a federal state violates its legal obligations, the federal government can appeal to the Federal Constitutional Court
      .”Agency report from September 12, 2026 on t-online externer Link
    • Right to give instructions to ministries of justice: After the AfD victory, the judges' association warns against political abuse of the judiciary
      “After the AfD victory in Saxony-Anhalt, the judges' association is concerned about party-political abuse of the public prosecutor's office. The judiciary must be better protected. (…)
      The priority now is to prevent such abuse of public prosecutors in Germany, Federal Managing Director Sven Rebehn told the Kölner Stadt-Anzeiger. It must be ruled out by law that extremists in a government can steer criminal investigations in one direction or the other through instructions. So far, the law has given ministries of justice the opportunity to "influence individual criminal proceedings," warned Rebehn. It is high time for the federal government to take the initiative and delete the “delicate right to issue instructions” of the justice ministries from federal law. There is a political tradition of self-restraint when giving instructions to public prosecutors, said Rebehn. However, this can be abandoned at any time and does not offer effective protection
      …”Agency report from September 13, 2026 in Zeit online externer Link- atGerman Association of Judges externer Linknothing found
  • Obligation to remonstrate: Civil servants bear responsibility - ver.di stands by the civil servants and all employees in Saxony-Anhalt
    "The AfD became by far the strongest force in the state elections in Saxony-Anhalt. (...) The party has announced a personnel exchange deep into the public service in order to break down possible resistance and be able to govern through. In addition, a massive austerity dictate is planned in its program (...)Officials must examine the legal and factual situation and make a reasoned decision based on this, taking all the circumstances into account. If there are concerns about legality, the civil servant is then obliged to protest (Section 63 Paragraph 2 BBG or Section 36 Paragraph 2 and Sentence 3 of the BeamtStG for state or local civil servants). “I can’t stay silent or look away.” Not to be confused with: “I won’t do that.” Civil servants do not have this right because they generally have to follow instructions. Personal opinion, which may be different, does not relieve civil servants of their obligation to implement the measure.
    Process of the remonstration:
    1. Counter-statements, remonstrations, must always be addressed to your immediate superiors. (…)
    2. The form is not prescribed. (…)
    3. The person immediately in charge must then check the instructions based on the objections made. (…)
    4. If the immediate superior decides that the instruction should be maintained, then there are two options: a. The official carries out the instruction or b. goes up a level in the authority hierarchy and reiterates his concerns there. The final decision will then be made on how to deal with it. (…) The remonstration process ends here. (…)
    What consequences does a remonstrance have for civil servants?
    The remonstration process was completed in its entirety and all doubts were pointed out. Then there is no liability for the individual civil servant. There can also be no disciplinary measures because there is an obligation to protest. Subsequent claims for recourse against the civil servant are excluded. It is important that the instructions must then be implemented; this does not violate the individual's official duty. However, there is the following further restriction: If the ordered behavior is criminal or unlawful and the criminal liability and administrative offense is recognizable or if human dignity would be violated as a result, the execution of the order must still be refused. If it is carried out anyway, personal responsibility remains in full.” Legal information from ver.di from September 7, 2026 externer Link
  • [Duty to demonstrate] Resistance in the apparatus in Saxony-Anhalt: civil servants and administrative staff are preparing for right-wing governments.
    “…On September 1st, the “School Shows Attitude” alliance, which includes the Education and Science Union (GEW), among others, handed over a petition with over 250,000 signatures to the Conference of Ministers of Education and Cultural Affairs. The petition calls for clear support for teachers who work against discrimination and intimidation in schools. The alliance criticizes the fact that authoritarian forces deliberately abuse the state's neutrality requirement to make political engagement and democracy building more difficult, for example through reporting portals or threats. In order to strengthen teachers in their democratic educational mission, the alliance calls for guidelines that expressly require advocacy for the Basic Law and human rights. There is also a need for transparent advice and assistance, practical support such as further training and more resources for democratic school development.
    In addition, the alliance has published the brochure “The Myth of Neutrality,” which is intended to give teachers and educational staff practical guidance on conflicts in everyday school life. The brochure aims to encourage teachers to “take a democratic, human rights-oriented stance – objective, well-founded and in line with the state’s educational mandate.” One of the co-authors of the brochure is Paul Anton König from the “Administration for Democracy” association.
    The association, which was only founded in 2025, sees the administration as a target of anti-democratic attacks and misses a discussion about how the administration can fulfill its duty to faithfulness to the constitution without raising doubts about its party-political neutrality. Administration is a “critical infrastructure of democracy” that must be strengthened and protected. In order to strengthen administrative staff, the association published a “Democracy First Aid Kit” last year.
    This includes explanations of the Whistleblower Protection Act and the duty to remonstrate, as well as checklists on terms such as duty of neutrality and loyalty to the constitution and what they mean in everyday life for administrative employees. The association is currently collecting attacks on the administration and wants to document, analyze and legally evaluate them. The long-term goal of “Administration for Democracy” is to build a network of democracy protectors from all administrative units and levels
    .”Article by Sebastian Weiermann from September 3rd, 2026 in ND online externer Linkto:

    • First aid kit democracy for administrative employees (version 1)
      “The first aid kit serves as an orientation aid for administrative employees who, in their work, are confronted with instructions, a work environment or developments that question applicable law or basic democratic principles. These situations can be unsettling and stressful. Possibly trigger a feeling of pressure, isolation and also worries about your own career and therefore livelihood. All of this is understandable. If in doubt, you are not the only one who feels this way. That's why our advice and credo of the association is: Don't stay alone, create spaces of trust with others and encourage each other…”https://verwaltung-fuer-demokratie.de/erste-hilfe-kit-demokratie/ externer Link
    • Andhttps://www.schule-shows-keeping.org/ externer Link
  • Obligation to demonstrate: After the deputy head of the GdP, Berlin's GEW state chairwoman is also calling for resistance to instructions from AfD heads
    • “We will not help to dismantle democratic principles”
      “In an interview, GEW state chairman Gökhan Akgün calls for resistance to instructions from AfD officials.
      [The vice-chairman of the police union has called on its members in Saxony-Anhalt not to follow illegal orders from a possible AfD interior minister. The AfD is also fighting for the top places in Berlin. What does this mean for teachers?]
      The AfD will most likely not be involved in a state government in Berlin, but it may well happen that the AfD will appoint district councilors after the election. The positions are allocated on a proportional basis. Then there is also the risk that AfD politicians will assume responsibility for schools and young people. All I can say is: Fascist and racist politics must never become normal in the public service. Anyone who believes that employees can be forced to implement a policy of exclusion, discrimination and intimidation will meet our resistance. My appeal to our members is: Be vigilant, show solidarity! Disagree! Get organized! If attempts are made to combat anti-fascist commitment or to push back democratic educational work, then no one should remain silent. This particularly affects our staff councils. They are the protective shield for our employees. These must be the ones who document processes, use the participation rights and take legal action if boundaries are exceeded. We work with children, young people and families. We defend the dignity of every human being and will not help dismantle democratic principles.
      [What does that mean specifically?]
      Resistance can mean publicly objecting, involving staff councils, organizing union legal protection, calling staff meetings and creating political publicity. But also to protest, i.e. to contradict illegal instructions and to oppose them using the means of the rule of law. When we say “Not an inch from racism,” then this also applies to our administrations, schools and youth facilities. Our story shows what happens when people just do their jobs. Democracy needs people who contradict
      ….”Interview by Marten Brehmer from August 19, 2026 in ND online externer Link. Since November 2024, Gökhan Akgün has been chairman of the Berlin regional association of the Education and Science Union, which represents teachers, educators and scientists. The qualified educator was previously a member of the general staff council of general schools in Berlin. See background:
    • Obligation to demonstrate: Is there enough Antifa in the police?
      “The debate about how police officers deal with an AfD government shows the willingness among civil servants to defend democracy (…)
      That's why it's all the more remarkable that the deputy head of the police union (GdP) externer Linkof his oath to protect the constitution, on the contrary,” says Hüber’s text. The obligation to demonstrate should ensure that a "role of the police like that of 1933-1945 can never be repeated again." Anyone who takes their oath of service seriously cannot vote for, support or join the AfD. The GDP deputy leader positions himself clearly and is not afraid to align the AfD with the NSDAP.
      The GdP is now considered a social democratic police union, in contrast to the “German Police Union”, which is positioned much further to the right. In statements, GdP officials repeatedly express their fundamental opposition to racism, anti-Semitism and anti-queer sentiment. However, a statement as clear and accompanied by recommendations for action as Sven Hüber's text is more than unusual. This shows that the threat posed by the AfD to democracy is now being taken seriously in parts of the much-vaunted middle of society. A positive signal, especially because officials from the security apparatus have tended to lean to the right in the past. Hüber might have been able to give undecided police officers some food for thought.
      However, the debate that the text has triggered also suggests that only a few police officers share the offensive position against the AfD. After the "Bild" and right-wing media reported on the article and repeatedly emphasized that Hüber was trained in the GDR, district groups and regional associations of the GdP from all over Germany were forced to comment on the text…”Article by Sebastian Weiermann from August 19, 2026 in ND online externer Link, see also:

      • Resignation of Sven Hüber: police officer suddenly antifa. The deputy head of the police union is calling for resistance against a possible AfD state government. “Bild” started a campaign against him
        "Sven Hüber, deputy federal chairman of the police union (GdP), no longer wants to keep silent about the blue elephant in the room. Their members' magazine has made the topic the title of the August issue under the title "Is there an elephant in the room... say no correctly". It contains tips in which cases officers can, and indeed must, reject regulations. In technical jargon, the term for this is: remonstrate. Hüber has published a call to his colleagues in the magazine to resist, should they There will be an AfD state government. He derives the obligation to do so from the Basic Law: Article 20, Paragraph 4: All Germans have the right to resist anyone who attempts to eliminate the constitutional order of the state. Officials swear an oath to this basic law. “Anyone who takes their oath seriously cannot do otherwise: No-Go with the AfD!” But he doesn't just see it as an individual duty of all police officers not to vote for the AfD. He calls for them to prepare for a possible takeover of a state government by the AfD, as is feared in Saxony-Anhalt in the state elections in September (...) He says clearly: If an AfD state government violates the Basic Law, riot police officers from other federal states would have to be prepared to violate the constitutional order on the instructions of the Federal Ministry of the Interior To restore Saxony-Anhalt. (…) Hüber's contribution has not only caused criticism within the GdP. Right-wing media have been campaigning against the police unionist since it was published.“Bild” calls him a “sedition policeman,” and the right-wing portal “Apollo News” accuses him of equating the AfD with the NSDAP in his argument. (…) On Wednesday morning it was announced that Hüber had resigned from his position.” Article by Henrike Stier from August 26, 2026 in New Germany online externer Link
  • Civil service between courage and duty - conflict situations for civil servants when giving instructions from an authoritarian-populist top management
    Further out of theArticle by Andreas Nitschke from May 24, 2024 in the Constitution Blog externer Link:(…) Civil servants are subject to the so-called follow-up obligation in accordance with Section 62 Paragraph 1 Sentence 2 of the Federal Civil Service Act (BBG)/Section 35 Paragraph 1 Sentence 2 of the Civil Service Status Act (BeamtStG). They are then obliged to carry out the official orders issued by their respective superiors and to follow their general guidelines. Of course, this applies regardless of the political leanings of the superiors or, in general, the management staff of an authority. In the event that an authoritarian-populist party is able to fill the top positions of, for example, ministries or town halls with its party members after the elections, all civil servants would basically have to follow all of the instructions of this new leadership. (…) Although the civil service is bound by instructions in this respect, civil servants bear full personal responsibility for the legality of their official actions in accordance with Section 63 Paragraph 1 BBG/Section 36 Paragraph 1 BeamtStG. This also applies in the event that a corresponding instruction has previously been issued. As a civil servant, you shouldn't be able to simply rely on “blind obedience to orders”. In the case of unlawful instructions from superiors, the civil service laws therefore provide for the so-called remonstrance, i.e. the right - and, according to the prevailing opinion, also the official duty - of civil servants to raise concerns about the legality of official orders through official channels in the form of a counter-presentation (...). This means that any concerns must first be raised with the supervisor.If the instruction is upheld, one must contact the next higher superior authority (…) In practice, there is likely to be a major uncertainty factor: Due to the interpretation of vague legal terms, in borderline cases it is not clear whether or when exactly an instruction is really punishable, unlawful or violative of human dignity. (…) Against this background, as a civil servant, making a general claim that you are not a lawyer and/or criminal or human dignity specialist and therefore, to a certain extent, burying your head in the sand is unlikely to be a way out and is already not advisable in the light of Section 63 Paragraph 1 BBG/Section 36 Paragraph 1 BeamtStG. In view of the intensive discussion that has been taking place in the media for some time now about how to deal with authoritarian-populist parties and the potential dangers they pose to the free democratic basic order, a sensitized thinking on the part of the civil service committed to the democratic constitutional state must be expected, as well as an examination that does justice to the scenario indicated here, with the appropriate exertion of the respective individual abilities. In the event of obvious and serious violations of the law, civil servants are called upon to do so. (…) The radical decision of the Federal Constitutional Court from 1975, which is still repeatedly cited by the administrative courts today, states that the free democratic constitutional state is dependent on the civil service to take sides on its behalf, especially in times of crisis and in serious conflict situations.The state and citizens must “be able to rely on the fact that the civil servant is prepared to assume responsibility for this state, for ‘his’ state (…).” The future will show whether and in what way the instrument of remonstrance has to prove itself in the scenario shown here only in rough outline.”

Basic information:

  • The right or obligation to demonstrate arises from Section 36 BeamtStG (law regulating the status rights of civil servants in the federal states). It says, among other things: “Officials must raise concerns about the legality of official orders immediately through official channels.”See a call for this, for example in the dossier:Gendering with special characters is prohibited in schools in Saxony-Anhalt - other countries (want to) follow
  • Overview of the right to remonstrate for teachers
    “The right or obligation to demonstrate is an important legal instrument for civil servants, especially teachers, to defend themselves against unlawful or unlawful instructions from their superiors. It serves to protect the rule of law and safeguard democracy and fundamental rights.Civil servants, and especially teachers, have an obligation to uphold the constitution and laws and to prevent anti-democratic structures and practices from entering the state apparatus. It is therefore a tool that contributes to the active defense of fundamental rights and democracyWork in progress on google docks externer Link(without author)

The post[Right to demonstrate] The civil service between courage and duty - conflict situations for civil servants when giving instructions from an authoritarian-populist house leadershipappeared firstLabourNet Germany.

Originally published bylabournet.de
Read the original