Politics Labour Hub
Cutting benefits won’t help young people
Ahead of the launch of the Milburn Review today, Andrew Fisher warns what the Government should not do. The Milburn Review looks set to recommend quite significant cuts in social security for young pe
English (original) ·Read in Deutsch ⇄
Ahead of the launch of the Milburn Review today, Andrew Fisher warns what the Government should not do.
The Milburn Review looks set to recommend quite significant cuts in social security for young people out of work or suffering ill-health.
That will massively undermine some of the good things proposed in the Milburn Review and will not improve youth outcomes.
Milburn’s interim report recognised the NEETs [Not in Education, Employment, or Training] crisis is driven by failures in education, health and the labour market
Cutting benefits does not solve any of those fundamental issues. It will simply push young people further away from the labour market and be more likely damage mental and physical health.
Around 25 percent of PIP [Personal Independence Payment] claimants are in work. It’s not an out of work benefit, but compensation for the increased cost of living with disability.
Working people on PIP have told me they could not work without the support their PIP payments provide. If young people in work lose their PIP, does that help?
The UK already has some of the lowest rates of benefits. Young people are not NEET because of the generosity of our social security system.
Where Milburn is right is that we underinvest in further education, healthcare and employment support.
Let’s take education for a start: funding for Further Education is 8 percent lower today than it was in 2010. We don’t invest in vocational training for those who don’t go to university.
And UK universities are suffering massive cuts and closures of courses (in part because racist immigration policies have reduced the numbers of foreign students who cross-subsidise UK students).
On health: It’s no surprise the NEET rate has increased post-pandemic (though still currently below the 25-year average).
NHS waiting lists have risen from 2.5m in 2010 to 7 million today. Anyone who has interacted with CAMHS [Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services] knows how slow it can be to get treatment -and how this cohort of 16-24 year-olds suffered during the pandemic.
On employment support, too many of the programmes (Work Programme, ReStart, etc) have been outsourced and proved woefully ineffective.
Jobcentre Plus lacks investment. The National Audit Office found in 2024 that there were at least 2,000 too few work coaches, and unemployment has increased since then. Some work coaches have caseloads of 100-200 claimants.
So while the Milburn review may recommend significantly increased investment in further education, the NHS and Jobcentre Plus, the Government won’t be delivering that anytime soon on the back of last month’s Budget
But it will recommend cutting benefits – which will do nothing to help young people.
Andrew Fisher was the Labour Party’s Director of Policy from 2015 to 2019.
Image: Alan Milburn. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Alan_Milburn_2014.jpg Source: Flickr. Author: NHS Confederation, licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license.