Politics Unicorn Riot
Two Palestine Solidarity Activists Refuse to Testify Before a Grand Jury
Nearly three years after a protest at an Israeli arms manufacturer’s U.S. facility, Sophie Ross and Bridget Shergalis were ordered to appear before a grand jury. Neither plan to comply. The post Two P
English (original) ·Read in Deutsch ⇄
Merrimack County, NH — In November 2023, Sophie Ross and Bridget Shergalis approached a large industrial building in Merrimack, New Hampshire. The structure houses Elbit Systems of America, the domestic branch of an Israeli weapons manufacturer that’s a key supplier of drones and ground equipment used in the country’s ongoing genocide in Palestine.
The two were participating in an action organized by Palestine Action U.S. Some blockaded the road leading to the facility while Shergalis and Ross, along with others, continued to the building.
A few protesters stayed on the ground and sprayed the facade with red paint, sealed doors shut with a bike lock, and broke windows. Shergalis and Ross made their ways to the building’s roof and lit flares to announce their presence while attempting to damage the building’s HVAC system.
Both women were arrested that day, along with Calla Walsh. Paige Belanger, another participant, was arrested days later. All four were charged with multiple felonies that could have brought decades in prison if convicted. After a legal battle, and a series of victories, Shergalis, Ross, Belanger and Walsh were sentenced to 60 days jail time for misdemeanor convictions.
Nearly three years after that action, Shergalis and Ross have been subpoenaed to testify in front of a federal grand jury. The reason for the subpoena isn’t clear, but one thing is: both women are refusing to cooperate.
On October 5, Bridget woke up to strangers knocking on her window. When her partner answered, he found people dressed in unassuming clothes. Only after he asked what they wanted did the couple realize what was happening. The strangers were FBI agents there to serve her a subpoena to testify before a grand jury.
She told the agents to leave their contact info and expect to hear from her attorney, Kira Kelly. Ross was spared the door knock after agents delivered a subpoena to Kelly, the attorney representing both of the women.
The document simply ordered both women, individually, to appear in the U.S. District Court in Concord, New Hampshire on October 21, only 16 days out from the delivery of the subpoena.
No other details that clarify the target or goals of the investigation appear in the subpoena, and both Shergalis and Ross, along with their lawyer, are unclear about the reason behind the order. While Kelly told Unicorn Riot an assistant U.S. attorney told them it’s in relation to the 2023 action, no more information was made available to them, leaving everyone but prosecutors to speculate about the motivation behind the investigation.
While details are sparse, reporting from the time of the action and recent developments suggest the grand jury may be related to the Cox Media heir and controversial left-wing benefactor James Cox “Fergie” Chambers Jr.
Chambers participated in the November 2023 Elbit protest where Shergalis and Ross were arrested. In a 2024 profile in Rolling Stone, Chambers told a reporter he had fled the country after the action for fear that he may be implicated in a racketeering case for his involvement. Chambers insisted in that interview that he wasn’t doing anything wrong by moving to Tunisia, but that he was scared of facing RICO charges.
In July, Chambers was arrested in Ibiza, Spain and he’s been held in the country since while awaiting the outcome of an extradition order under consideration by the Spanish government. The U.S. has asked authorities in Spain to send Chambers back to this country to face charges on a still-sealed indictment.
More important to Shergalis and Ross than the who or why of the grand jury’s convening, though, is the principle behind the practice and the pair’s moral objection to the process. The thought of betraying a political movement both say they’re committed to is unacceptable to them.
“I would like to be able to, like, look other people in the eye and sleep at night and all of that good stuff,” Shergalis told Unicorn Riot. “And that’s, that isn’t possible with testifying. It just isn’t, it wouldn’t be.”
By openly opposing the subpoena from the start, both hope to establish that they cannot be coerced into testifying. That’s a key distinction in how things may play out.
Under the law, people who refuse to testify after being subpoenaed to a grand jury might be sentenced to jail time for being in civil contempt of court. They can be held there for the length of the grand jury, though not longer than 18 months, but only in an effort to coerce their testimony.
The law prevents jailing people as a punitive measure for civil contempt, though in some instances a court may hold someone in criminal contempt for failure to testify before a grand jury. In some cases the court may jail someone who refuses to testify before a grand jury under civil contempt, then sentence them either concurrently or consecutively with criminal contempt, according to the Civil Liberties Defense Center.
While the distinction may seem like not much of a distinction at all – being imprisoned is itself a form of punishment – it’s an important one. If the two can make it clear that they will not be coerced to testify, the court has little justification to sentence them other than as a punitive measure.
By maintaining their commitment to not testify, Shergalis and Ross aim to take jail time off the table.
Ross says that even if the strategy isn’t ultimately successful, the thought of testifying against other movement participants is more unbearable than the threat of jail time. And while she recognizes it as a possibility, she says she feels more prepared than many to confront it.
“One element that I found pretty valuable is I think the threat of jail is […] a lot scarier if you haven’t been through it before. And Bridget and I, along with our two co-defendants, we did do jail time for that [2023] action,” Ross said when weighing the possibility of being imprisoned for her non-cooperation.
For both of the grand jury resistors, the choice was obvious from the start. Ross emphasized that engaging in political activism comes with, in her words, the baseline agreement to not testify against others engaged in that same work.
“It’s our duty and it’s not a heroic thing that we’re doing. It’s just the responsibility that we’ve taken on.”
And in going public with their refusal to comply, both hope to make it clear that they remain committed to that principal now and into the future.
As part of that commitment, Bridget and Sophie said they’ve signed on to the NSPM-7 Defendants Union pledge, which lays out a set of agreed upon principles that people facing repression under the Trump administration’s policies will stick to.
Signing an agreement rejecting federal repression of movements makes sense for the pair — the movement they aligned with in 2023 has been targeted by the federal government using now-familiar tactics. On August 26, the Trump Administration sanctioned the British branch of Palestine Action under Executive Order 13224, accusing it of material support for terrorism, in the same order that targeted the Italian collective Autistici/Inventati (A/I), the hosts of the NoBlogs website network. The American branch renamed itself as Unity of Fields in 2024 and panelists at a Congressional Homeland Security hearing criticized the group in 2025.
Signing onto that pledge may provide the two with more support in the form of network building and resource sharing. But more than garnering support, Shergalis and Ross hope to communicate to the movement which the grand jury would ask them to inform on that they won’t betray their principles or their friends engaged in similar work.
“We’ve asked so many people for support and people have given us support without asking at all, and I think that the only reasonable thing to do is […] to make a promise to them that they can trust us and that we’re going to follow through on our responsibilities to them,” Ross said.
While grand jury resistance isn’t new, Shergalis and Ross are hoping that they may be able to set an example for people in the future. Throughout the process both Shergalis and Ross have looked to historical examples of grand jury resistance – some recent, some from years ago – and gained insight into the strategies that worked.
By stepping out publicly as grand jury resistors, they hope to offer another example of how it can look and what may work. Part of that is an out-and-out rejection of the process, despite it seeming contrary to the typical legal strategy of avoiding media and public comment amid ongoing cases.
“I think for us, the most functional response is the one that keeps us […] safe, it keeps the person that the jury is targeting safe. And it also helps prepare the movement around us,” Ross said when asked about why she felt going public was the best response.
No one else has publicly stated that they’ve been subpoenaed to testify in this case, but it’s unclear if other subpoenas have been delivered.
As for the process itself, Kelly, the staff attorney at the Climate Defense Project who’s representing the pair, says the vagueness of the subpoena and the time pressure is par for the course when it comes to grand jury proceedings.
“This level of secrecy and contrived urgency is typical for grand jury investigations,” they told Unicorn Riot.
And while there’s no indication that either of Kelly’s clients are the subject of the investigation and neither have received target letters, they can’t be sure until it commences.
The original appearance, set for October 21, was delayed until November 18. A press conference will be held on Wednesday morning with Shergalis and Ross set to address the public.
Follow us on X (aka Twitter), Facebook, YouTube, Vimeo, Instagram, Mastodon, Threads, BlueSky and Patreon.
Please consider a tax-deductible donation to help sustain our horizontally-organized, non-profit media organization: