Germany Tagesschau
Criticism in Germany of plans for a deportation center in Rwanda
The plans by Germany and four other EU states to bring rejected asylum seekers to Rwanda continue to attract criticism - including from churches and human rights activists. Also within the Bu
Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English
Criticism of deportation plans to Rwanda "Dignity does not end when an asylum application is rejected" As of: November 17, 2026 • 10:37 a.m
The plans by Germany and four other EU states to bring rejected asylum seekers to Rwanda continue to attract criticism - including from churches and human rights activists. The project is also controversial within the federal government.
Rejected asylum seekers who cannot be returned to their countries of origin will be able to be deported to the East African country of Rwanda as early as next year. On Monday, Germany, Austria, the Netherlands, Denmark and Greece presented plans for a deportation center. Criticism of this comes not only from churches and human rights activists. The SPD also expressed its rejection of the considerations, which were primarily being pushed forward by Federal Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt.
The Federal Government Commissioner for Human Rights Policy and Humanitarian Aid, Lars Castellucci, directly attacked the CSU politician Dobrindt: Dobrindt had failed to link the negotiations about return centers to "improvements in the human rights situation" in Rwanda. "Rwanda has achieved remarkable development after the horrors of the genocide in the 1990s," wrote the SPD politician Castellucci on X. "At the same time, human rights are eroding. Surveillance, a lack of freedom of assembly and freedom of expression determine everyday life."
In addition, the country is “involved in the conflict in neighboring Congo in violation of international law.” With offers for a deportation center, "President Kagame wants to be ennobled by the West despite this situation," said the human rights officer. "This is a shameful game."
Georg Restle, ARD Nairobi, on the planned cooperation with Rwanda for a deportation center tagesschau24, November 16, 2026 • 6:00 p.m. "The attempt to simulate hardship and ability to act" Other SPD politicians also do not seem to be convinced of the coalition partner's plans. The foreign policy spokesman for the SPD parliamentary group, Adis Ahmetovic, said, "Dobrindt's Rwanda plans are short-sighted in terms of foreign policy and damage Germany's credibility."
Development Minister Reem Alabali Radovan told the Frankfurter Rundschau that she was fundamentally critical of the “Return Hubs” concept. There are still many open questions. SPD member of the Bundestag Hakan Demir said: "To be honest, we don't understand why people should be deported to countries with which they have no contact at all. And that country should also be Rwanda. We know that Rwanda does not comply with human rights standards as we would like."
Green Party leader Felix Banaszak believes the whole thing is incompatible with human rights: "This is Alexander Dobrindt's attempt to simulate toughness and the ability to act. At the expense of those at stake, at the expense of European values and also at the expense of budgets."
Rejected asylum seekers should be able to be brought to Rwanda in the future - even if they have no connection to the country. more
Churches and church organizations also criticize: The representative for refugee issues of the Evangelical Church in Germany, Bishop Christian Stäblein, said: "A person's dignity and rights do not end even if their asylum application is rejected." The EU also imposes an “enormous challenge” on poorer countries, explained Stäblein. "In this way, the EU risks destabilizing already fragile states and, on top of that, makes itself politically dependent or even vulnerable to blackmail from questionable partners."
The migration expert from the Protestant aid organization Bread for the World, Andreas Grünewald, spoke of a “serious political mistake by the federal government”. Return centers are “a farewell to a responsible and rights-based migration policy”.
Germany and other EU countries plan to send certain rejected asylum seekers to East Africa. more
The aid and human rights organization medico international draws a comparison with Donald Trump's US government: "What the five EU states are planning here is reminiscent of the ICE's deportation practice in the USA," said Valeria Hänsel, consultant for the European border regime, in a statement.
"The EU is adopting a practice in which people are treated like mass transferables. They are torn from their social environment and taken to countries where they have neither protection nor prospects." According to the medico representative, the EU states are shirking their responsibility.
medico international and Bread for the World have also signed a joint declaration by 45 organizations from 15 countries calling on the EU to "protect rights rather than outsource responsibility for their compliance". The announcement marks “a new phase of harmful externalization policies,” note the organizations, which also include PRO ASYL, the Jesuit Refugee Service Germany, Sea-Watch and Terre des Hommes.
There are hardly any partner states for the legally controversial deportation centers in third countries. more
The planned deportation center, which the EU states call the "Return Hub", is intended to accommodate people who are required to leave the country and who cannot be returned to their country of origin - for example because their home country refuses to take them back. People in ongoing asylum procedures are not affected. Interior Minister Dobrindt said that this option was needed because there were limits when it came to enforcing the obligation to leave the country.
He receives support from other Union politicians. "If around a quarter of a million people are legally obliged to leave the country but remain in the country permanently, this significantly undermines trust in our constitutional state. We can no longer accept these enforcement deficits," said the deputy chairman of the Union parliamentary group, Günter Krings.
Baden-Württemberg's Interior Minister Manuel Hagel (CDU) wrote on
There was also encouragement from AfD domestic politician Christian Wirth. Anything that helps “repatriate” migrants who have no right of residence out of the EU is a step in the right direction.
With information from Eva Huber and Alena Lagmöller, ARD capital studio
This topic in the program: The First | daily news | 11/16/2026 | 8:00 p.m.NDR Info | News | 11/17/2026 | 06:21 AMBR24 Radio | News | 11/17/2026 | 8:08 a.m