Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

Germany Tagesschau

No recount: BSW fails with election audit complaint

Too few votes and evidence: The Federal Constitutional Court rejects a lawsuit by the BSW to recount the votes in the federal election. The Union is now considering reforming election verification. By Max B

Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English

BSW fails in Karlsruhe There are still 9,529 federal election votes too few As of: November 18, 2026 • 12:55 p.m

Too few votes and evidence: The Federal Constitutional Court rejects a lawsuit by the BSW to recount the votes in the federal election. The Union is now considering reforming election verification.

4.981 percent of the vote for the BSW was the official final result in the 2025 federal election. However, five percent would have been necessary for the alliance to enter the Bundestag. Never before has a party failed so close to the five percent hurdle.

Sahra Wagenknecht doubts this result. She thinks her party should actually have 35 seats in parliament. The will of the voters must be reflected in the Bundestag, said Wagenknecht: "And if a coalition of SPD and CDU does not have a majority, then it should not govern either."

However, according to the official final result, the coalition has a majority in the Bundestag. The BSW did not become the political tipping point. Sahra Wagenknecht's alliance was 9,529 votes short.

The BSW had narrowly failed in the federal election and wanted a new count. more

But these votes are only missing because there were errors in the counting, says the co-chair of the BSW, Amira Mohamed Ali: "BSW votes were incorrectly assigned to another party. This most often affects the 'Alliance Germany' party but also other parties."

The smallest party "Alliance Germany" was on the ballot papers in almost all federal states directly above the "Alliance Sarah Wagenknecht" or "Alliance Social Justice and Economic Reason", as it is called today - this was a source of confusion, so that votes for the BSW ended up mistakenly with the "Alliance Germany".

According to Amira Mohamed Ali, a second error in the counting was: "Valid BSW votes were overlooked during the counting due to the unfortunate placement of the BSW at the bottom of the ballot paper."

The third mistake, according to the party, was that election workers rated votes for the BSW as invalid because BSW voters only cast their second vote, i.e. only made a cross in the second column of the ballot paper. But that is permissible, which many people don't know. The background is that the BSW only ran with direct candidates in a few constituencies. BSW voters therefore often did not want to cast their first vote.

Frank Braut, ARD legal editor, on the failure of the BSW's constitutional complaint tagesschau24, November 18, 2026 • 10:00 a.m. recount demanded All of these errors would have cost the BSW the necessary votes. Samples have shown that there were an above-average number of corrections in favor of the BSW in individual recounts. If the count were to be re-counted throughout Germany, the BSW would clearly exceed the five percent hurdle. The alliance called for such a recount.

As stated in the Basic Law, the Bundestag's Election Audit Committee initially dealt with the BSW's objection. However, the party was not successful there. The Bundestag did not see any significant errors that could have had an impact on the distribution of mandates.

The Sahra Wagenknecht alliance no longer exists. The abbreviation BSW remains with a different meaning. more

The Federal Constitutional Court has now decided on the BSW's election audit complaint. And Karlsruhe says very clearly: the BSW's election audit complaint is inadmissible.

The judges stated: The BSW simply made unsubstantiated assumptions that there were election errors. However, simply suggesting the possibility of voting errors is not enough. Even if many such possibilities were mentioned. Rather, a specific situation must be described from which clear election errors arise. The BSW would not have met these requirements.

The fact that the election result was so close and the BSW was only a few thousand votes short of entering the Bundestag does not change that. A party must always give good reasons for the fact that there were electoral errors. And from the fact that the BSW received significantly fewer votes in some electoral districts than the national average, one could not simply conclude that there were voting errors.

Three weeks after the election, the AfD is looking for a majority in Magdeburg. The BSW is courting her. more

The BSW criticizes the decision. For party founder Wagenknecht, this shows that Germany has the “electoral test of a banana republic”. After this decision, "in the future, no party will have a real chance of getting a review in the event of close results and obvious irregularities," explained Wagenknecht.

The Union is suggesting a reform of election verification. “Regardless of the decision, there is a fundamental need for reform in the election audit,” said the Union faction’s general counsel, Martin Plum, to the Rheinische Post. The process takes too long and is too cumbersome.

The chairman of the election verification committee in the Bundestag, Macit Karaahmetoğlu (SPD), welcomes the decision. “It is good that there is now clarity on the issue of the recount.”

Who won where? How were candidates, parties and issues assessed? more

This topic in the program: The First | daily news | 11/18/2026 | 09:50 a.m. Tagesschau24 | News | 11/18/2026 | 10:00 a.m.NDR Info | News | 11/18/2026 | 10:00 a.m.The First | daily news | 11/18/2026 | 8:00 p.m

Originally published byTagesschau
Read the original