Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

Germany Tagesschau

Overpriced lenses - Have ophthalmologists overcharged hundreds of millions?

According to research by NDR, large eye doctor chains in particular are pushing for the purchase of overpriced special lenses for cataract operations. Ophthalmologists are estimated to have hundreds of millions of euros too much

Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English

Exclusive Overpriced special lenses Have ophthalmologists overcharged hundreds of millions? As of: November 17, 2026 • 5:01 p.m

According to research by NDR, large eye doctor chains in particular are pushing for the purchase of overpriced special lenses for cataract operations. Ophthalmologists are estimated to have collected hundreds of millions of euros too much from their patients.

Detlef Jurzok leans over the bill he received from the eye clinic. He paid 799 euros out of his own pocket for a special lens that he had inserted during a cataract operation at the beginning of the year. Jurzok says he thought that for his eyes "you just take the best" - even if it is expensive.

But did it really have to cost that much? Jurzok has become skeptical. He turned to NDR after the broadcaster reported in May 2026 that many patients had paid hundreds of euros privately for special lenses - even though the health insurance companies actually cover them.

Many people now feel like Jurzok. Well over a thousand patients have written to NDR. Many have sent concrete cost estimates, treatment contracts and invoices. The NDR analyzed these for months and had them evaluated by experts.

According to NDR research, many ophthalmologists collect a lot of money for alleged “premium lenses” during cataract operations. more

The analysis of the documents shows that “boundaries are being exceeded in many ways,” says medical lawyer Andreas Spickhoff from the Ludwig Maximilian University in an interview with the ARD political magazine Panorama. He took an anonymous look at some exemplary invoices available to NDR. He criticizes that unacceptable flat-rate fees are being charged. According to the fee schedule, patients must receive a precise breakdown of the medical services provided.

Detlef Jurzok also only found one amount in the invoice for his lens: the 799 euros as an additional charge. A lot of money, because the health insurance companies actually pay for the entire operation including the cost of a standard lens. However, Jurzok had decided on a special lens that was supposed to correct his astigmatism. A certain surcharge for this is therefore justified. But the large sum seemed questionable to him after the NDR reporting in May.

That's why Jurzok subsequently asked the clinic to send a detailed breakdown of the costs. And it reveals that the lens only cost 71.90 euros more than the standard health insurance company pays for a lens. The additional additional costs that were charged to Jurzok are allegedly necessary preliminary examinations for the use of the "premium lens" - more than 20 items in total, some of which are duplicates. The eye clinic did not respond to questions from NDR.

Many other bills from patients also show similar patterns - and, according to experts, are unreasonably high. Jan Tode from the Hannover Medical School (MHH) also looked at exemplary, anonymized invoices for NDR. He criticizes the fact that money is being “taken out of people’s pockets”.

Because he considers many of the examinations that were billed to be unnecessary. “Things are being done that are completely incomprehensible,” says Tode. Examinations that can actually only be charged once - for both eyes together - are often billed twice. And in some cases, "individual examinations that are standard are written in at a completely overpriced price - knowingly that the patients don't understand this and simply dismiss it."

Many large eye doctor chains obviously systematically charge excessive costs. For certain lenses that are actually completely covered by health insurance, they often charge significantly more than 500 euros. For other special lenses, some even charge more than 2,000 euros. The actual lenses themselves are much cheaper.

Christian Baars, NDR, with details about fraud by ophthalmologists during cataract surgery tagesschau24, November 17th, 2026 • 6:00 p.m. Circular to all health insurance companies The Federal Office for Social Security (BAS) sent a circular to all health insurance companies at the end of October, also in response to the NDR reporting in May. It called on them to better inform their insured persons about the legal situation. Among other things, it is important to clarify which lenses the insured person does not have to pay for.

But current NDR research shows that many practices, including large chains, obviously ignore this legal situation. They've charged a lot of money for these lenses for years, and many still do. Patients report that despite requests, they were refused surgery with such lenses at no extra charge. The justification is often that expensive preliminary examinations are necessary, but experts believe this is not the case.

The eye doctor mafia - How they systematically rip off patients The eye doctor mafia - How they systematically rip off patients, Panorama 3, NDR television, November 17th, 2026 • 9:15 p.m. Special laser treatment offered In addition to the special lenses, many patients are offered a special laser, including Detlef Jurzok. It was advertised as “gentler and more precise,” he says, “and of course a little more expensive.” In his case: 1,350 euros. Otherwise it usually costs between 1,200 and 1,600 euros.

But the benefit is questionable. “People used to hope that this would allow for gentler surgery, more precise surgery, and that it would therefore be better for the eye,” explains Tode. "But this has not been proven in any study." A large analysis of several studies clearly showed: "You can use the laser, but it has no advantage."

The laser operations also show that in recent years some large chains have continued to bill in a way that the Federal Court of Justice had already declared inadmissible in a case in 2021. According to medical lawyer Andreas Spickhoff, such billing is “clearly no longer possible according to the case law of the Federal Court of Justice.”

Some chains and practices have therefore apparently started to include expensive diagnostic services in the invoice that are said to have been carried out with the laser. In other cases, according to the billing, the laser was used for an operation that was supposedly carried out at the same time to correct a refractive error, although this was not told to the patients according to their presentation. There are also legal doubts about such calculations.

Financial investors have bought hundreds of ophthalmological practices in Germany, resulting in monopoly-like structures. more

Spickhoff sees many invoices as signs of a “fraudulent approach,” for example when patients’ ignorance is taken advantage of. If, for example, measures that are not medically necessary are billed again and again, "almost as a matter of course", then it is a case of "billing fraud, and one in a particularly serious case, because it can be viewed as commercial."

The total amount involved can only be estimated. Overall, ophthalmologists may have overpaid several hundred million euros in recent years. Up to a million cataract operations are carried out in Germany every year. And the number of special lenses used has increased significantly over the past five years. This is shown by an evaluation by the Bavarian Association of Statutory Health Insurance Physicians for the NDR. According to this data, more than a quarter of all patients now pay extra costs for a special lens. In large chains that are owned by financial investors, the ratio is significantly higher.

The NDR has evaluated billing for hundreds of eye surgeries: Apparently, eye doctor chains in particular collect too much from their patients. ndr

Detlef Jurzok was also in such a practice. It belongs to Sanoptis, the largest eye doctor chain in Germany. The NDR sent the company questions about its case and general billing practices, but did not receive any substantive answers.

When asked by NDR about the allegedly overpriced bills, the Federal Association of Ophthalmologists only stated in general terms that the respective legal and fee regulations apply. And the association assumes that these will also be adhered to. He cannot examine specific individual cases himself; he does not have the authority to do so. The Association of Eye Surgeons (DOCG) declared itself not responsible for such questions.

At NDR's request, the Federal Ministry of Health refers, among other things, to the letter from the Federal Office for Social Security to the health insurance companies. In view of this, it “currently sees no immediate need for legislative regulation, but will closely monitor further developments”.

This topic in the program: The First | Daily news | 11/17/2026 | 5:00 p.m., tagesschau.de | Ophthalmologists - overcharged by hundreds of millions | 11/17/2026 | 5:00 p.m

Originally published byTagesschau
Read the original