Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

Labour Tribune

Zack Polanski: Milburn is Wrong. Here’s How We Solve the Youth Crisis

The Green leader on why the government’s plan to get young people into work — by slashing benefits and funding low-wage jobs — will end in failure, and what a real alternative would look like.

English (original) ·Read in Deutsch ⇄

A million young people out of work and education is a sign of economic rot, a crisis of finances and also of fulfillment, joy and wellbeing, for those who are locked out of opportunity. Now, instead of grasping the roots of the problem and offering genuine solutions, Alan Milburn’s review reflects the deep flaws in this Labour government’s approach.

Andy Burnham came in on a platform of hope. But after only a few months in power, he seems to be telling us two things: that the best we can hope for is tweaks around the edges of our fundamentally unfair economy; and that ordinary people must be pitted against one another, rather than uniting to take on the powerful.

The Milburn review is a case in point. It offers a weak, inadequate response to youth unemployment, and pays for it by slashing benefits for some of the most vulnerable.

Today we have an economy of the future to build, and a massive skills shortage in the workforce we need to build it. Burnham’s plan, which involves giving taxpayer money to private companies like Sainsbury’s in order to pay low wages to young people, won’t do anything to meaningfully address either of these problems. As important as work in retail and hospitality is — I should know, I spent many years in this type of work — it is precarious, short term, and often reliant on exploitative zero hour contracts.

So what’s the alternative? For a start, we know that forcing young people to make decisions about their future on the basis of what will pay their bills in the immediate term doesn’t lead to full and happy lives. It’s not how we’ll salvage a generation for whom everything is looking grim, and getting grimmer. Poverty wages won’t inspire participation or buy-in. Green MP Siân Berry’s work as co-chair for the All Party Parliamentary Group on Poverty and Inequality has shown that there’s a cyclical relationship between poverty and the ‘NEET’ status, and that we urgently need to break this link.

That’s why in October our Deputy Leader Mothin Ali announced our Youth Jobs Guarantee. Greens in government would roll out a comprehensive programme offering all 18–24 year olds — initially in areas most acutely affected by the crisis — a guaranteed job for two years with conditions in line with our Worker’s Charter. Proper pay, proper rights and jobs that are based on future industrialisation. In Mothin’s words, ‘Working-class kids should be able to dream. But more than dream, they should have a genuine chance of making those dreams a reality.’

We’re not going to address climate, housing and the spiralling cost of living without proper investment — for example in a street-by-street programme of home insulation, lowering bills and creating skilled green jobs. As the government rolls out the age-old mantra of ‘tough choices’, let’s talk about the real tough choices we need to face. Let’s talk about the fact we tax wealth at a lower rate than we do work, giving tens of billions of relief to the wealthiest in society. Let’s talk about the fossil fuel subsidies that are costing us over £17 billion a year.

Let’s talk about the corporate tax rates set at a lower rate than income tax, meaning international conglomerates can pay out buckets in shareholder bonuses while working people foot the bill. Gordon Brown paid for Labour’s New Deal in the 1990s with a windfall tax on privatised utilities. The correct approach. Burnham wants to pay for his new policies on the back of welfare cuts for people with disabilities.

Tackling the inequality and stagnation that has taken root in our economy requires us to take on vested power and interests, which Labour seem unwilling to do. We can’t just let the wealth hoarding of landlords, billionaires and the private sector keep on growing unchecked while young people are shut out from stability and security.

We should be giving support not just to those who are struggling the most, but to everyone by putting a bit more money in their pocket. Means-testing leads to misery for those on the sharpest edges — especially the disabled, who are yet again dealing with the prospect of cuts. Equally, if young people want to spend some time figuring out their career and life plans, learning about themselves and exploring options, that’s a good thing for them and it’s a good thing for the country.

The Youth Jobs Guarantee that the Greens have put forward — delivering meaningful, socially valuable and well-compensated work — would be a good start. To seriously invest in the future of our country and our young people, we need to think about universalising, not means-testing, support.

We need rent controls to stop asset hoarding from unscrupulous landlords and we need a higher minimum wage (equalised for people of all ages) to properly reward hard work. We need to reverse the austerity that has decimated our high streets and our communities — isolating us all from each other and from the spirit of collectivism that once made this country great.

Alan Milburn’s review is just more of the same trickle-down economics from a Blairite whose biggest achievement as Health Minister was, in his own words, that he ‘got the private sector into the NHS.’ It doesn’t dare question big chains and the uber-wealthy receiving limitless government support, but it wants to shakedown the people getting 76 quid a week. Our young people deserve better. We all deserve better.

Originally published byTribune
Read the original