Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

Migration Tribune

Neil Duncan-Jordan: Why I’m Rebelling Against the Government’s Plans for Migrant Workers

Labour must stand by the people who keep our country moving.

English (original) ·Read in Deutsch ⇄

It was personally moving for me to march up to Labour Party Conference in Liverpool shoulder to shoulder with hundreds of social care workers. Seeing so many organised and enthused trade unionists coming together in a sector where the unfairness of our economy is perhaps most pronounced was inspiring. These are people who give so much to provide dignity and care to our loved ones yet receive so little in return.

It was the easiest opening to a speech I have ever had to deliver: “This is what solidarity looks like”.

I pay tribute to those UNISON members because it was their campaign, and the leadership of Andrea Egan which brought the Government to the table to secure a major row back on its so-called “Earned Settlement” proposals to double the qualifying period for indefinite leave to remain for migrant workers deemed “low-skilled”. It was workers power that chiselled a limited carve-out for care workers and some others.

I have tabled an amendment, to be debated in Parliament this evening, which would protect the settlement rights of all skilled workers already here and prevent the retrospective application of the Government’s immigration policy, which will still affect thousands of other workers. I think if you played by the rules of the visa our Government gave you and held up your end of the bargain, you should not see your life turned upside down.

I challenged Keir Starmer directly when his Government first announced these proposals because they ran so clearly against our sense of British fair play. The public believe that you should get out what you put in, and that people who contribute to our society should not to have their lives turned upside down.

There is no doubt that the proposals have improved since then, but if implemented, they would still move the goalposts unfairly for migrant families, including my constituents. That includes people just days or weeks away from qualifying for indefinite leave to remain, who now face years of additional uncertainty. The way I see it, what is unfair and un-British for one group of workers is unfair and un-British for others too. 

This is the unfairness my amendment aims to correct.

One of my constituents expressed a powerful sense of injustice at the proposals: “In October 2023, my husband, my eight-year-old son, and I, holding a skilled worker visa, arrived in the UK believing that it would be a fair, equitable, democratic place where we could feel safer. As immigrants, we are making an extraordinary effort as a family to adapt to a new country and add value to it by paying our taxes from the first day we arrived.”

I have urged Ministers to pause for thought and recognise that our new leadership must grasp the opportunity to learn from the mistakes of the past two years. A party founded by trade unions to represent workers and rebalance our country in their favour should not find itself arguing that those who earn the most deserve preferential treatment and a shorter route to settled status, while lower-paid workers have the rug pulled from under them.

The approach of our movement has always been to organise workers to get what they’re worth; not to punish those earning less. That is why it is no surprise that ten trade unions expressed support for my amendment. 

UNISON General Secretary Andrea Egan said of her support: “Neil Duncan-Jordan’s amendment would help hold the government to the rules that were in place when these workers were granted their visas. That is a matter of basic fairness and justice. Every MP should vote for it.”

It is important that we never reduce these conversations to crude economic calculations. These are not just numbers on a screen; they are our neighbours and friends. I represent families who have built their lives in Poole, in some cases with children who know no other home than the one they have here. The “Office for Budget Responsibility” cannot quantify the hurt these proposals have caused or forecast the damage they risk inflicting on the fabric of our communities.

But this policy fails even on the Government’s own terms. According to the Migration Advisory Committee, individuals on the Skilled Worker visa, excluding the Health and Care visa, are projected to make a net positive fiscal contribution over their lifetimes, with a total impact of £5.9 billion on our public finances. This figure includes adult dependants.

None of this should surprise any member of the Labour Party who shares our values. We have always known that it is workers who create the wealth in our society. We need a major rethink of this flawed approach, recognising not only the contribution migrant workers make to our society but also what we stand to lose if we force them to leave.

Our Labour Government must understand that it is workers – not billionaires or bankers – who keep our country moving. That is what solidarity looks like.

Originally published byTribune
Read the original