World taz
Negotiations in the Ukraine War: Summit versus Summit
On Thursday, the coalition of the willing will meet in the Chancellery and want to demonstrate strength. In Brussels they are relying on a booking trick for Ukraine aid. more...
Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English
Will it be a fateful day for Ukraine? Provide a breakthrough for a real step towards peace or at least negotiations to end the war? This Thursday the world will look to Shenzhen. Where US President Donald Trump, Russian leader Vladimir Putin and China's head of state Xi Jinping want to meet. The three-party summit seems like whether Putin, Trump and Xi want to divide the world. More power-bearing behavior is hardly possible. Those who will also look at China with excitement, if not concern, are the so-called coalition of the willing.
On Thursday afternoon there will be a state of emergency in the Chancellery. At the invitation of Germany, France and Great Britain, representatives from 37 countries will travel to Berlin, as well as NATO chief Mark Rutte and the heads of the EU committees. They come to send a strong signal of solidarity with Ukraine and to secure military and financial aid before the fifth winter of war begins.
The timing of the summit in Shenzhen has probably been carefully considered. If there is also a bilateral conversation between Trump and Putin, then the results of this meeting are likely to be decisive as to how the Ukraine war continues in the coming months. Unsurprisingly, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky is also expected in Berlin. What is surprising, however, is that US negotiators Jared Kushner and Steve Wittkoff are also scheduled to appear in the capital.
The parallelism of events shows the tension in the current situation. At least the European countries were able to score something like an agreement at an informal EU summit in Dublin at the end of last week. There has been a long struggle over who should represent the EU countries, or more correctly Europe, if there should be a round of negotiations. It was agreed on the so-called E5 round made up of Germany, France, Great Britain, Italy and Poland - two representatives of the EU leaders should also be there.
In Berlin it will be a matter of not being taken for a ride when the conditions for an end to the war come from Trump and Putin. They want to discuss the question of security guarantees that should come into force after a ceasefire. A joint maneuver by the coalition of the willing in Poland, which is now coming to an end after weeks, shows that people are ready to defend themselves.
But above all it's about money. Well-orchestrated, the EU Commission made a clear proposal on Wednesday, one day before the mammoth meeting in Berlin. A few months after an initial 90 billion euro aid loan for Ukraine, Brussels now wants to help Kyiv again with 45 billion euros. The money is earmarked for 2027 and is intended to secure defense in the war with Russia.
The second loan should also be financed through new European debt, said EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen. Third countries such as Great Britain are expected to raise a further 25 billion euros. Zelenskyj had reported a total need for aid totaling 70 billion euros. With her proposal, the German European politician is responding to the enormous pressure from Berlin. Chancellor Merz had threatened to block the ongoing negotiations on the future EU budget if all 27 member states did not participate in aid to Ukraine.
The Czech Republic, Slovakia, Hungary and Bulgaria have left the country - they no longer want to be responsible for Kyiv. The Slovakian Prime Minister Robert Fico spoke of “blackmail” to which he would not submit. Hungarian Prime Minister Peter Magyar also said no. Von der Leyen wants to break the resistance with an accounting trick: 20 billion euros from the new loan should be reserved for civilian purposes in the Ukrainian state budget, the rest will go to the military. No EU country has yet categorically ruled out civil aid.
However, it is uncertain whether the trick will work. The first EU loan, which had not yet been fully paid out, was split into a civilian and a military part. Nevertheless, Hungary, Slovakia and the Czech Republic do not support it. The same thing could happen again now. In addition, the entire new loan – including military aid – is to be secured through the current EU budget. So the unwilling would be on board. It is questionable whether they will give the green light at the next EU summit at the end of November, as Merz demands. The decision must be unanimous, even one naysayer can block everything.
The shaky financing also causes uncertainty. The EU budget, which is intended to serve as security for the loan, expires in 2027. The next budget for 2028-2034 has not yet been determined and is highly controversial. So far, another 100 billion have been planned for Ukraine, but that is unlikely to be enough either. Things will be particularly difficult if the EU also reimburses Ukraine for its loan interest. According to Economic Commissioner Valdis Dombrovskis, it is unclear whether Brussels will provide additional money for this. In this case, the EU would incur new costs – in addition to the loans granted. Critics speak of up to 50 billion euros.
Is the EU embarking on a financial adventure for Ukraine? The EU Commission rejects this, saying that interest costs only make up a fraction of EU spending and that everything is fully financed. But the cost calculations only go up to 2027; they expire with the current financial framework. What happens next is unclear. “The situation is very unstable,” admitted an EU official. We don't know how long the war will last (until now, the EU expected it to end quickly), nor how interest rates will develop. The EU will need many years to pay off debts and interest, said the expert. “It will take decades, I will be retired long ago.”
For von der Leyen, this is no reason to refuse new help. “We support Ukraine in war and peace,” she said. After all, it's about Europe's security. And part of the money would also flow back into the German and European arms industry. Merz couldn't have said it better.