Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

Germany taz

Tightening of criminal law: The absurd desire to punish

Criminal law should be tightened. But more punishments do not lead to less violence. What is more problematic is the jurisprudence. more...

Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English

The black-red coalition loves to change criminal law and regularly comes up with new tightening of the law or a new criminal offense. The argument is more protection: more protection for train attendants and doctors – through harsher punishments for those who attack them. More protection for citizens and, above all, more protection for women. In order to achieve this, a new criminal offense will be introduced against the spread of sexualized deepfakes and against “catcalling”.

Not always, but again and again, politicians tighten the punishment range or plan a new law that would not be necessary from a legal perspective because the offense in question has long been punishable. Federal Justice Minister Stefanie Hubig (SPD) is planning to introduce a separate femicide offense, even though femicide can already be condemned as murder and punished with life imprisonment. Nevertheless, there is a need for action.

All too often, judges only conclude that the crime is manslaughter instead of murder. The fact that this is the case is not due to the existing laws, but rather to the judges, for whom violence against women or other marginalized groups was practically not an issue during their law studies and who dispense justice in a patriarchal world. There are characteristics of murder that objectively relate to the execution of the crime, for example if the execution is particularly cruel.

The taz is an independent, left-wing and opinionated daily newspaper. We have been arguing in our comments, essays and debate texts since the taz was founded in 1979. We often cannot and do not want to agree on an opinion. That's why you'll find some completely opposing positions here - all part of the very broad left-wing spectrum of opinions.

And there are characteristics of murder that subjectively relate to a particularly reprehensible motive of the perpetrator. Femicides occur out of misogyny, possessiveness or power attitudes. All of this can be included under the murder characteristic of “base motives”. So there is a murder here. A femicide only becomes a femicide because of the subjective motives of the perpetrator. The court is faced with the challenge of proving “base motives”.

What often happens in the course of the trials is that misogyny is reinterpreted as love or possessiveness - which is more understandable for the court - as jealousy. In 2019, the Lübeck regional court rejected base motives and thus murder because, in addition to jealousy and anger, the defendant also felt despair over the separation from his ex-partner. The BGH later overturned this ruling. The problem lies with the judges’ ratings.

This would not change if there were a separate femicide offense, as the defendant would also have to be proven to have his subjective motivation. Justice Minister Hubig should also be aware of this. In an interview with Bild am Sonntag, she explained that femicide can already be condemned as murder. Nevertheless, she would like “clarification” through her own offense and suggests that this would allow femicide to be convicted more often than murder.

But if a new criminal offense is not necessary at all - then why should it come? The answer is as simple as it is sobering: Tightening criminal law is a quick and easy way to make citizens believe that politicians have recognized a problem and are seriously tackling it. This is easier than spending money, which is currently in short supply, on prevention. Penal populism, some also call it penal populism, works.

The promise to finally take tougher action against criminals already leads to “calming the public and bringing about approval,” writes criminologist Helmut Kury in his book “Crime Prevention through Tougher Sanctions?” It is a myth that laws lead to more protection because the deterrent effect of punishment is low.

Not only have numerous criminological studies come to this conclusion, but politicians have also stated this in their second periodic security report 20 years ago: “For the area of ​​mild to moderate crime, the basic rule is that the amount and severity of the punishment have no measurable significance.” But because punitive populism can win votes, politics tightens up.

The fears of the population are being exploited. There was a prominent example in Hesse in 2008, when the then CDU Prime Minister Roland Koch used a series of burglaries to stir up sentiment against young people and migrants. He called for faster deportations, an increase in the maximum sentence for murder for adolescents and the application of adult criminal law to juveniles. In the election campaign, the CDU lost 12 percentage points and thus the absolute majority.

Young voters in particular were put off by the populist demands. Deportation regulations have now been tightened, 18 to 21 year olds can be sentenced for murder with 15 years instead of a maximum of 10 years and CDU politicians are still standing up and calling for the youth criminal law to be abolished. This is what happened after the Islamist terrorist attack on the sidelines of the Berlin CSD last July.

At the same time, the tone in politics against leftists and migrants is becoming more intense. Ex-BGH judge Thomas Fischer writes in his book "On Punishment" that only certain areas of crime are selected, "mostly crime committed by strangers and outsiders, preferably migrants; crime with an external impact and on the population's spontaneous feeling of security." It is therefore not surprising that criminal laws are being called for to be tightened, particularly when it comes to emotional issues.

Right-wing populist politicians like to resort to this when they push their racist agenda. However, the right-wing and conservatives do not have a monopoly on criminal justice populist demands, which also come from the progressive corner. Politicians use the issue areas that they stand for politically. In the left and green ranks, a separate regulation for femicides is advocated. There are also calls in the media for criminal law to be tightened.

After actress Collien Fernandes made it public that she had experienced digital sexual violence at the hands of her ex-husband Christian Ulmen, numerous celebrities expressed their solidarity with her and made a number of demands, including a femicide offense of their own. Analysis and criticism responded with a title: “Criminal feminism does not free us”. Ulla Scharfenberg correctly states in the magazine: “A feminist movement that takes itself seriously directs its anger against the repressive state instead of making common ground with it, and shows solidarity with those who experience violence in this system.”

The criticism of criminal law as a repressive instrument of power on the one hand and the demand for criminal protection for marginalized people on the other are actually a dilemma that one also gets into if, as a feminist, one initially looks critically at tightening of criminal law. The only way to get out of the dilemma is to continually ask yourself whether tightening criminal law will really have the desired effect. An offense against the spread of sexualized deepfakes makes sense because there is a gap in criminal liability.

So far, the judiciary can only deal with other criminal offenses, such as violating someone's personal sphere of life, stalking or insults. However, these are not designed for sexualized deepfakes. It is important that criminal law responds to new technical developments. The federal government recently decided on its own offense for “catcalling”. The situation here is similar to that with femicides: the problem lies more on the jurisprudence side than with the laws.

The BGH was once of the opinion that a 65-year-old who wanted to “grab her pussy” of an 11-year-old would not have demeaned her with this statement. A strange view, to put it cautiously, that the BGH represents here. Of course, the judges could also have accepted an insult. Must. The new offense requires that the statement “is capable of intimidating or harassing the other person” – here too, the judge’s assessment may fail.

“The level of civilization of a society can be judged by the condition of its prisoners.” A phrase attributed to the Russian writer Fyodor Dostoyevsky and often quoted in criminal law scholarship. The ongoing tightening of criminal law and the calls for it are a symptom of the state no longer responding to citizens' concerns with good social policy and money for prevention.

We have moved more and more away from the idea of ​​resocialization in criminal law: in neoliberalism, criminal law is supposed to solve social problems. What we should be aware of is that a court can only judge the specific case, the specific defendant. Apart from the lack of capacity: more than 1.1 million open criminal cases are piling up in the German public prosecutor's office. This is a new record.

It goes without saying that a lack of time can be potentially detrimental to careful prosecution. Criminological studies show that the probability of being discovered and convicted is more important than the amount of the punishment. So we shouldn't fall for the punitive populism of politicians, we shouldn't make it so easy for them, we should instead demand real solutions against crime and violence.

Originally published bytaz
Read the original