Germany taz
Controversy surrounding ex-“organic pope” Urs Niggli: Bioland counters criticism of organic farming
Agricultural researcher Niggli denies that organic food can feed the world. The industry is opposing this – and at the same time has to worry about EU subsidies for organic farms. more...
Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English
Bioland boss Jan Plagge defended organic farming against criticism from agricultural scientist Urs Niggli. “Agroecology is successfully put into practice in organic farming,” writes the president of Germany’s largest organic farmers’ association in response to a taz interview with Niggli. He denied that organic alone could feed the world and advocated agroecology - a mixture of conventional and organic farming.
“For decades, organic farms have shown how agriculture can be aligned with ecological relationships,” added Plagge. This included diverse crop rotations, varieties adapted to the location, building up soil fertility and modern technology. Instead of relying on mineral nitrogen fertilizers and chemical-synthetic pesticides, which often put a strain on biodiversity, they used natural processes and strengthened operational cycles.
Niggli, who headed the Research Institute for Organic Agriculture for a long time, pointed out in the interview that organic food is on average 20 to 50 percent more expensive. The yields are on average 25 to 30 percent lower. That is why, even after more than 100 years, organic farming has only become established on a very small area worldwide.
Plagge counters that high yields alone are not a sufficient benchmark. “Of course, returns are important,” he writes. However, it must also be taken into account how much energy, mineral nitrogen fertilizer and other external resources are required for production and what ecological follow-up costs would arise. “A high yield is worth little if its requirements depend on imported fossil energy and global supply chains that can falter at any time.”
Niggli calls for binding minimum requirements for agroecology, which should largely be based on the EU Organic Regulation. Unlike organic farming, however, it should not exclude new genetic engineering, for example, according to the researcher who was previously referred to as the “organic pope”.
Plagge, however, emphasizes that organic farming is science-based agriculture. “That doesn’t mean implementing every technical innovation as quickly as possible.” It is important to weigh up the benefits and risks. "Especially with new genetic engineering processes, possible consequences for ecosystems, freedom of breeding and the dependence on patented seeds must be carefully examined. Anyone who asks these questions is not acting ideologically, but rather responsibly."
Meanwhile, the organic industry is fighting for the EU to continue subsidizing organic farming. At the end of October, the Council of Member States removed binding organic funding from its negotiating position on the reform of EU agricultural policy from 2028. In the future, the member states should be able to decide for themselves whether they want to financially support organic farms in converting and maintaining their farming methods.
“The French example shows what it means when the state no longer adequately rewards organic farming,” said the industry umbrella organization Bölw and the French national organic farming association. After France abolished the retention bonus for organic farms in 2018, the number of newly converted hectares fell by around 60 percent by 2025. The organizations called on the EU Parliament to support mandatory support for organic farming.
As a precaution, the farming associations Bioland, Naturland, Demeter and Biokreis called on parliamentarians to reject the planned reform of the common agricultural policy and instead to continue the existing legal framework until 2034. The reform proposals currently being discussed threaten to significantly deteriorate agri-environmental measures, organic farming and the development of rural areas.