Germany taz
Hanging match around Vanessa Emde: The seeds of doubt have been sown
Regardless of whether the left-wing MP Emde is kicked out of the Left Party faction next week or not: the damage has already been done. Not just in Berlin. more...
Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English
One would like to concentrate on the coalition negotiations in Berlin. The Left, SPD and Greens are fighting for the best for the city and show: red-green-red could be a great idea. Instead, it's just about one: Vanessa Emde. She has been leading the party for weeks, questioning Israel's right to exist. The new Berlin state government depends on their exclusion from the parliamentary group: the parliamentary group executive committee submitted a motion on Tuesday, and the vote will be taken in a week. It remains unclear whether the necessary two-thirds majority will be achieved. But one thing is clear: the doubt that Emde sowed has long been in the world.
The fact that the left is delaying the process and not finding clear words may be clever in order to wear down the Emde-solidarist Neukölln district association. Perhaps she also fears that clear words could scare off the many new, young members. The youth association is already complaining about too many compromises on the part of the Berlin Left. Emde has long been a symbol of pure left-wing doctrine and an anti-Israel stance that is missing from the coalition talks.
Emde is also a welcome distraction for opponents of left-wing majorities. This means they don't have to deal with fundamental questions such as ownership or assets. Instead, they watch as Emde himself declares them finished. According to the Berliner Tagesspiegel, she said at a congress that redistribution could only be done by the federal government and that a Berlin government would not change anything. In Neukölln they didn't advertise anything about affordability. Bad news for everyone who bought an affordability campaign from the left.
The taz is an independent, left-wing and opinionated daily newspaper. We have been arguing in our comments, essays and debate texts since the taz was founded in 1979. We often cannot and do not want to agree on an opinion. That's why you'll find some completely opposing positions here - all part of the very broad left-wing spectrum of opinions.
Voters and possible coalition partners are now asking themselves: How many Emdes are there in the Left Party? Probably few, most want to govern and shape things locally. But Berlin shows that one backbencher is enough to question everything. Even if Emde is kicked out, the impression remains: Voting for the Left brings drama.