Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

War & Militarism taz

Debate about conscription and the Bundeswehr: A fart in the Adlon

At the Nobel Hotel Adlon in Berlin, the NATO front line meets to discuss compulsory military service. The unpleasant questions are ignored. more...

Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English

T he world of defense policy is full of incarnations of clichés, and that hurts. So I recently sat in on a discussion about “the young generation” and its relationship to conscription and the Bundeswehr. The article “they” was actually repeatedly emphasized as if there was exactly one young generation and as if they had exactly one attitude towards the Bundeswehr: somehow skeptical about compulsory military service, but somehow still socially committed and, above all, somehow open to the idea that Germany needs a very strong military.

It was a discussion of the German Atlantic Society (aka NATO Vorfeld), more precisely its youth organization, which I didn't know before. The audience seemed as if extremely ambitious political science students had been put in a room with pensioners from the Bonn Republic who read the Institute for the Study of War's update every morning about the latest front lines in Ukraine. So we got along well!

The fact that the room in which they sat together was the ballroom of the Berlin Hotel Adlon certainly helped matters. As an ambitious political science student, I too would have attacked the buffet if I had managed to sneak into the event.

This time, however, I was interested in the last panel discussion, which was about how the “Generation Turning Point” views the Bundeswehr. It wasn't clear until the end whether the play on words - Generation Wende, Gen Z - was perhaps an oversight. Because the discussion only marginally touched on the protests, which were primarily directed against possible conscription plans.

Instead, the panel agreed that the Bundeswehr urgently needs more of everything: people, weapons, money. Or, as moderator Fabian Frenger from the “young” Atlantic Society put it: “The establishment of a war-worthy Bundeswehr is the order of the day.”

Neither the former general secretary of the Federal Student Conference, Quentin Gärtner, nor the CDU MP Vivian Tauschwitz or the scientist Friedrich Opitz from the German Society for Foreign Policy wanted to contradict this on the podium. They simply discussed the best way to achieve this.

The minimum demand to at least include young people when it comes to their concerns (military service) was the maximum demand on the podium. Both Tauschwitz and Gärtner spoke out in favor of a compulsory social year for young men and women in which they would not have to, but could, join the Bundeswehr.

The discussion became entertaining when Gärtner made an effort to loosen up the stiff Adlon audience a little, probably with a view to his following on social media. “Conscription, in our fathers' stories, had something to do with alcoholism and farting in lighters,” he said. I laughed! But I'm not sure whether the Bonn political veterans sitting behind me really registered the joke because it was so pleasantly out of place in this place.

Originally published bytaz
Read the original