Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

Germany taz

Federal presidential election 2027: A castle for everyone

Ilse Aigner as the first female Federal President would not be progressive, but rather a clique. What is needed is a radical reinvention of the office. more...

Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English

There is nothing uplifting about the way the Union, the Social Democrats and the Greens have lobbied for their upcoming Federal President: On the contrary, the way in which a few people here presume to determine what is good for all of us is the spectacle of a shrinking democracy, a system of fear, a refusal to change, especially among those whose job it should be to constantly redefine what community and collective action is.

Ilse Aigner from the CSU, the “first woman in office”, may be this or that, it doesn't matter. Or as they say in their homeland: It doesn't matter. This is not what 2026, another year of democratic agony, is about. What it should and must be about is a joint effort to redefine the we.

is an author and journalist. He is an employee at the think tank ProjectTogether, a fellow at the Max Planck Institute for Religious and Ethnic Diversity in Göttingen and he writes the newsletter “Survival in the 21st Century” on Substack. Most recently published by Aufbau-Verlag: "Tipping Points. From the Promises of the Nineties to the Crises of the Present."

Is the office of Federal President suitable for this? Absolutely. But only if it is no longer seen as an office in which you sit like a hoopoe on a bowl full of chocolates. This picture doesn't make sense? Yes, just. The office also makes no sense, it is like a visual barrier to the complicated reality of a population and a time in massive change.

It was once well-intentioned, after the war, when the whole world was afraid of the Germans and the Germans were most afraid of themselves, according to the hypothesis of this democratic crutch construction - the highest office was removed from any direct democratic decision, as a gesture to show that the people of Germany should not be trusted under any circumstances.

The taz is an independent, left-wing and opinionated daily newspaper. We have been arguing in our comments, essays and debate texts since the taz was founded in 1979. We often cannot and do not want to agree on an opinion. That's why you'll find some completely opposing positions here - all part of the very broad left-wing spectrum of opinions.

I don't trust the Germans either. At that time they had just externally left fascism behind them, but internally, of course, they carried it with them for years and decades to come. And today, today this fascism is maturing in them again, the seeds are still fertile, they said many years ago, and there is something very true about that.

But the question is what to do with this analysis. At the moment it looks as if the parties that always like to talk about the dignity of the office are turning it into a joke. And the candidate may join in. In any case, this Sunday talk is starting again that there is somehow “stability” and “the middle” and that this is “important” - when all that is shown is the clique of people who assure each other of their centrality in their own offices and careers and laboriously create something like legitimacy from it.

It's not about Ilse Aigner preparing to bend the world into a horseshoe and treating the left like the AfD, that is, stigmatizing them. The point is that a fundamental conversation is needed about how democracy works in these times, how it is constructed, how trust can be established, and what an office actually is in a present in which rapid change is proving to be the only stable category.

One answer could, of course, be: Especially in these times, the reliability of garden gnomes is needed. So the manageability or the paternalism or in this case maternalism of a person in a castle, which is not supposed to be a noble residence, but rather a absurd symbol of democracy. But that is precisely the protective mechanism of this office that has worn thin over all the years and decades in which the rhetoric has remained the same.

What is needed today is a radical reinvention of this office or what office even means. What would speak against having a new person in this office every week, which, as they say, has primarily a representative effect? So why not represent it in a different sense, that is, show the entire breadth of what the country is, show visibility, give the population an image of themselves in the most beautiful sense - drawn from the entire breadth of what this country has to offer?

What a variation that would be, what energy and dynamics. All structures would change, a moving van would be parked at Bellevue Palace every Monday, there would be constant coming and going and a change of perspectives and arguments. Diversity of discourses instead of narrow ambassadorial focus on a person who, in these times when reality presents itself as a mosaic, is hopelessly overwhelmed, structurally and in terms of content, which leads to empty phrases and ultimately a lack of communication.

The castle, this place of “dignity”, would then become a place of warmth, openness, contemporary fluidity. How surprising it would be to see a new person here every week with a different personality, a different standard. How interesting and invigorating it would be to relate to this person in a new way every week, from a climate activist to a park ranger to a racist to a senior teacher to an immigrant to an 18-year-old.

But not only the location would change - the castle itself would ultimately become a social laboratory, a kind of permanent democratic makerspace, a civic space of possibility, unpredictable but real, true, transparent and full of variation.

True, it would be the image of a different democracy. That would be exactly the point: we need a place, a beginning, to experiment with new democratic forms. This is already happening at a local level, for example with the “Workshop of the Brave” this Wednesday and Thursday in Weimar, where several hundred local designers are gathering to work on the system for a new we.

But I also expect the same energy that is created below from above.

Originally published bytaz
Read the original