Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

Germany taz

BSW election complaint rejected: Mere speculation is not enough

The BSW was unable to achieve a recount of the last federal election. The Federal Constitutional Court decided unanimously, the BSW complained. more...

Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English

The Federal Constitutional Court has unanimously rejected the BSW's election audit complaint against the 2025 federal election. There will therefore be no recount of the federal election. According to the judges, the BSW did nothing more than make assumptions and speculations.

In the federal election in February 2025, the BSW (then “Alliance Sahra Wagenknecht”, now “Alliance for Social Justice and Economic Reason”) was the tragic loser. The BSW received 4.981 percent of the votes and thus narrowly failed to pass the 5 percent hurdle. Ultimately, only 9,529 votes were missing for entry into the Bundestag. The consequences were significant for federal politics: only because the BSW did not enter the Bundestag, the CDU/CSU and SPD together had a majority in parliament and were able to form the government.

The BSW did not call for a new election, but for a recount of the federal election. After the election, the party and several voters initially lodged an objection with the Bundestag, but this was rejected in December with the votes of almost all factions (except the AfD).

Four voters – including party founder Sahra Wagenknecht – lodged a complaint with the Federal Constitutional Court. The BSW pointed out numerous possible sources of error and extrapolated abnormalities in individual voting districts to the federal territory. It is likely that the BSW received significantly more than the additional 9,529 votes required, the plaintiffs argued.

The Second Senate under Vice President Ann-Katrin Kaufhold has now rejected the election audit complaint. Mere guesses and speculations are not enough to question the outcome of an election. Even if the election result is close, concrete evidence of election errors relevant to the mandate must be presented.

The correction of election errors between the provisional and official final results is evidence of the functioning of control mechanisms. The opposite cannot be concluded from this: that there must have been many more (similar) voting errors.

According to the court, it was also not a plausible source of error that, in addition to the BSW, the (right-wing) “Alliance of Germany” was also on the ballot paper. The fact that the word “alliance” appears in both party names is not enough to assume that there was a lot of confusion here.

It also didn't help the BSW that it submitted 146 declarations from voters to the Constitutional Court that they had voted for BSW with their second vote in the 2025 federal election, but not a single BSW second vote had been registered in their voting district. On the one hand, the declarations came too late; they should have been presented when the objection was raised in the Bundestag, according to the court. On the other hand, that wasn't important because 146 additional votes wouldn't have helped the BSW get over the 5 percent hurdle.

Mohamed Ali also saw the “credibility of the Federal Constitutional Court” shaken. Wagenknecht even accused the constitutional judges of being partial: “The judges of the Federal Constitutional Court were brought into office by parties whose power and mandates they secured with this ruling.” Representatives of the CDU/CSU, SPD and the Left, however, welcomed the Karlsruhe decision.

In Germany, the BSW no longer has any legal recourse. The only option is to appeal to the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) in Strasbourg. (Ref.: 2 BvC 4/26)

Originally published bytaz
Read the original