Germany taz
Deportation agreement with Rwanda: Point of no return has been passed
Several EU states, including Germany, have decided on a deportation agreement with Rwanda. The so-called return hubs are scheduled to go into operation in 2027. more...
Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English
They weren't quite finished with the negotiations, but they all wanted to announce the news. Six interior ministers and two heads of government gathered in Vienna on Monday to usher in the “historic paradigm shift,” as Austria’s Chancellor Christian Stocker (ÖVP) said. Denmark’s Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen spoke of a “real game changer”. Five EU states, including Germany, want to conclude an agreement with the East African state of Rwanda for the first new EU deportation camp, called Return Hub. Commissioning is planned for July 2027.
“We are reaching limits where rejected asylum seekers do not cooperate or countries of origin do not cooperate,” said Federal Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt (CSU). That's why the return hubs are necessary. There, rejected asylum seekers could “find a perspective for those who have no prospects here”.
With return hubs, people are deported to a country that they do not come from and to which they generally have no connection. Officially, the time should be bridged there until a return to the country of origin is possible. But that is uncertain.
There had been rumors for weeks that the deal was dry, but the amount of the payments to Rwanda in particular was still unclear. At the joint meeting with the Europeans, Rwanda's Interior Minister Vincent Biruta called migration a "global challenge for which we need collective solutions". Migrants must be “treated with dignity at every level”. His country is “part of the solution because we offer people a second chance.”
Anyone who cannot be sent back to their country of origin after a rejected asylum application from the EU can travel from Rwanda to their own country or to another third country, said Biruta. But they could also stay in Rwanda and receive support if they wanted to start training.
Germany should initially get 40 places in the model - and contribute 20 million euros to the costs, it was said on Monday from Bundestag circles. Overall, Rwanda is likely to provide the EU with a low three-digit number of places in the new deportation camp.
There are currently around 260,000 people living in Germany without a secure residence status. Around 20 percent of them are obliged to leave the country immediately, meaning they are at acute risk of deportation. The other 80 percent have a toleration permit, meaning they cannot yet be deported, for example because of illness or a lack of cooperation from their country of origin. The latter obstacle would be avoided with the deportation centers: Anyone who cannot be deported to their country of origin could then end up in Rwanda in the future.
The participating states Germany, the Netherlands, Greece, Austria and Denmark have so far refused to disclose whether the people should be detained in the return hubs, how long they have to stay there and what happens if a transfer to the country of origin is not successful even after a long period of time. Above all, it is unclear what level of responsibility the EU intends to assume for the people in the return hubs - and where, for example, they can complain against the internment or their treatment. It is also unclear which criteria will be used to decide which people required to leave the country will be sent to a return hub.
Rwanda had targeted a similar deportation deal with Great Britain in 2022. Unlike the return hubs, London wanted to send arriving refugees directly to Kigali without first allowing them to undergo a British asylum procedure. Great Britain spent 715 million pounds, around 850 million euros, on the project. But first the courts stopped the deportations, then the Labor government gave up.
In Europe, it was Italy that created facts regarding deportations to third countries in the spring. In 2023, the government of Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni agreed to set up asylum camps in Albania. Actually, people were supposed to be accommodated there who were brought by the Italian coast guard on the high seas of the Mediterranean towards Italy. You should then go through an Italian asylum procedure in Albania. However, Italian courts banned this planned approach several times.
Therefore, from February 2026, the government in Rome began to bring foreigners from Italy who had already been rejected from leaving the country to Gjadër in northern Albania. From there they should then, if possible, be deported to their countries of origin. This meant that Italy effectively put the first of the EU “return hubs” into operation. However, Albania has so far prohibited the accommodation of foreigners from other EU states who are required to leave the country.
The black-red federal government is determined to see Rwanda through. The Federal Ministry of the Interior apparently assumes that the agreement falls exclusively under the jurisdiction of the executive branch, so the Bundestag does not have to agree. But a report from the Bundestag's scientific service last week raises doubts about this. Accordingly, it depends on the content of the deal whether a contract law is necessary - and the deeper the fundamental rights of those affected are encroached upon, the sooner the approval of MPs is necessary.
That could actually be a problem, because the plan met with massive criticism on Monday, at least from parts of the SPD. “We have to stop Dobrindt’s plans,” said SPD MPs Hakan Demir and Rasha Nasr in the Tagesspiegel. The Interior Minister's plans had not been coordinated with the SPD, they said. However, it has been known for months that there are negotiations with Rwanda, without this having caused any objection from Dobrindt's SPD colleagues.
Green Party leader Felix Banaszak criticized the plans particularly sharply on Monday. "Dobrindt buys the appearance of hardship for a lot of money, but only creates misery and irresponsibility. Return hubs are modern indulgences," he told the taz. “These inhumane deportation camps will become places with a complete lack of prospects.” And the Left's domestic policy spokeswoman, Clara Bünger, spoke of "extreme brutality and deterrence" and said: "This is nothing other than a state kidnapping."