Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

Politics Red Pepper

The history Britain’s new law still ignores

New rules for museum repatriations will not help Oron's lost ancestors return home, explains Obongodu Paul Unanam The post The history Britain’s new law still ignores appeared first on Red Pepper .

English (original) ·Read in Deutsch ⇄

AboutSearchPoliticsSocietyEconomicsJusticeGlobalClimateCultureKey Words SearchSearch AboutSearchPoliticsSocietyEconomicsJusticeGlobalClimateCultureKey Words Partnerships

New rules for museum repatriations will not help Oron’s lost ancestors return home, explains Obongodu Paul Unanam

In November 2025 a change in the law made it easier for museums in England and Wales to return objects on moral grounds. One of the best known examples of these are Benin bronzes, looted from the Edo Kingdom by British troops in 1897. But the carved ancestors that left a museum at Oron, Nigeria, from 1967 on – under loan, British arms and forged papers – fall outside the new law’s reach. The documents show why.

In 1970 a wooden ancestor figure, just under four feet tall, stood in the museum at Oron, on the Cross River estuary in what is now Akwa Ibom State, Nigeria. Keith Nicklin’s catalogue of the collection lists it as number 326; it had survived the civil war of 1967-1970. By 1996 it was in a private collection in Zurich. In 2004, a Zurich gallery sold it to a collector in Massachusetts, with papers that appeared to come from Nigeria’s museums’ commission, and waived Nigeria’s rights to it. However, when the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston inherited the collector’s bequest it became apparent that the export had not been approved and that several of the documents were not authentic. In 2014 Boston sent the figure home. The museum’s own record indicates that nobody knows when, or how, it was taken from Oron.

That is one ekpu. I live in the state it came from, which puts me close to this story but gives me no claim on it, and I do not speak for the Oron people. What I can do is read the paper trail, and this tells a story that Britain’s restitution debate has no place for.

Ekpu are carved wooden memorials to ancestors, kept by Oron families and tied to burial and lineage. Kenneth Murray, a British art teacher who became Nigeria’s first Surveyor of Antiquities in 1943, surveyed the Oron villages in 1944 and listed 1,296 carvings. He gathered over 500 of them. They were not bought. The heads of families gave them ‘on loan to the museum’ and kept the right of regular access, and the Oron traditional rulers said they wanted a museum if the government would build one in Oron. For years the figures sat in an earth building with a thatched roof lent by the district officer. A permanent museum opened in December 1959, on the eve of independence. The British Museum’s record for an Oron figure given to it in 1956 carries William Fagg’s note from 1970 that nearly 600 figures had been lent to the new museum at Oron and that most could not be accounted for after the civil war.

A monthly dose of our best articles direct to your inbox

The colonial state had already tried once to hold such things in the country. In January 1939, after the Ife bronze heads were smuggled out, the government in Lagos barred the export of ‘antique African sculptural works of art’ without the governor’s permission and put a slip in the passport of every European entering the colony to tell them so. Rumours of large-scale looting soon showed the order was not holding, and the Colonial Secretary urged West African governors to do more. The first major theft at Oron came in 1958, before the permanent building was finished: up to 30 figures were taken from the temporary museum and offered to collectors in Europe and the United States. Interpol was called in and a dealer was convicted in Lagos of receiving stolen property.

Then came the civil war. In 1967 Oron lay inside Biafra. Biafran troops occupied the museum, built concrete gun emplacements and laid mines in its grounds. After Calabar fell to federal troops in October 1967 the museum was heavily bombarded. The collection, still largely intact, was moved to Government College, Umuahia. When Biafra surrendered, the college became a refugee camp and many of the figures were burnt as firewood. Of the collection, 116 remained; the loss was put at about 546. Murray’s photographs survive. The figures themselves went onto the market. The Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York bought an ekpu in 2007 whose record reads: ‘Circumstances of collection in Nigeria currently unknown, possibly during the Biafran War’.

That winter, the House of Lords was asking about arms. On 29 January 1968, Lord Shepherd, Minister of State for Commonwealth Affairs, told the Lords that Britain had supplied nearly all of Nigeria’s military equipment, that there was a legal Government in Nigeria and that ‘we are bound to support it’. On 11 March, he was asked what £2,317,626 worth of Crown Agents’ orders for Nigeria, in November and December 1967, had paid for. He answered that, except where British aid funds were involved, the government was ‘not concerned with the transactions of the Crown Agents’. In short, the federal side in the war, which emptied the Oron museum, fought with British weapons. That is Britain’s own record, not mine.

Half a century on, Britain has given its museums a legal route for giving things back; yet in Oron’s case, the law reaches none of it.

Britain’s new restitution powers (sections 15 and 16 of the Charities Act 2022) have been in force in England and Wales since 27 November 2025. Many British museums are charities, and until then their trustees needed permission from the Charity Commission, the courts or the Attorney General to return items. Now trustees may return property on moral, rather than legal, grounds, and for the largest charities a transfer worth up to £20,000 needs no approval. This is the closest British law has come to saying a museum may return an object because keeping it is wrong.

However, the regulations that brought these powers into force exclude the collections of 16 named national bodies, among them the British Museum and the Victoria and Albert Museum. The UK government said the implications ‘were not sufficiently clear to the government at the time when the act was debated and passed’. Lawyers at Bates Wells called the exclusion ‘a concerning overreach by the executive into the proper remit of Parliament’.

Britain has given its museums a legal route for giving things back; yet in Oron’s case, the law reaches none of it

Even if that fight is won, the law will not reach Oron. The law doesn’t ask how an object left, or under whose flag; it asks whether a charity’s trustees could reasonably be seen as morally bound to give back what they hold. Benin fits this argument, because British museums held what British troops took. The Oron losses I have traced do not. They came in three stages, and none look like a raid: a colonial officer gathered the figures on loan; a war that Britain armed scattered them; and dealers sold them on, one with papers that protected only the buyer. The figure from Zurich went home from Boston, not London; another is in New York. A law that only asks trustees in England and Wales about what they hold reaches none of those three stages.

What would? Three things the record already supplies. Provenance built from Murray’s photographs and Nicklin’s catalogue, which Boston’s record cites. A presumption that any Oron ekpu which surfaced abroad after 1967, without documents, left through the war. And a willingness to count a war Britain armed as part of Britain’s case to answer, rather than an internal matter for Lagos.

The families lent their ancestors to a museum. Nobody lent them to Zurich.

Obongodu Paul Unanam is a writer and law graduate in Uyo, Nigeria, writing on law and accountability

Share on Facebook Share on X Share on Bluesky Share on LinkedIn Email this Page Share on WhatsApp Related Content Zionist pogroms and shepherding outposts

Grace Byron on cultural criticism, transphobia and Trump

Facebook Twitter Bluesky Instagram LinkedIn Subscribe About usGet involvedContactPrivacy policyArchiveDonate

© Socialist Newspaper (Publications) Ltd (Reg. No. 02644973, VAT No. 577 5026 20). Print edition ISSN 1353-7024

Instagram Bluesky LinkedIn Facebook Twitter newsletter SIGN UP About usGet involvedContactPrivacy policyArchiveDonate

© Socialist Newspaper (Publications) Ltd (Reg. No. 02644973, VAT No. 577 5026 20). Print edition ISSN 1353-7024

Originally published byRed Pepper
Read the original