Politics Novara Media
Cuts to Benefits Are Not the ‘End to Neoliberalism’ We Were Promised
Tomorrow, the government will publish the Milburn report. That’s a long-awaited review into Britain’s one million young people not in employment, education or training – the so-called NEETs. Its conte
English (original) ·Read in Deutsch ⇄
Tomorrow, the government will publish the Milburn report. That’s a long-awaited review into Britain’s one million young people not in employment, education or training – the so-called NEETs. Its contents, though, won’t come as a huge surprise, with its author, Tony Blair-era health secretary Alan Milburn, taking to the Sunday morning news rounds to pitch his plans while others briefed its contents to the press.
They’re trying to get ahead of what could be a significant rebellion amongst backbench Labour MPs. And who can blame the rebels? After all, with swingeing cuts incoming, they’re the ones who’ll have to explain to young voters with disabilities and other health issues – as well as angry parents – why their lives are apparently worth less than those just a few years older than them.
In politics, life comes at you fast. But not so fast that we can’t remember what prime minister Andy Burnham pledged just four months ago – an end to neoliberalism in this country. That’s a tricky term to define, and while Burnham mentioned deregulation, privatisation and the fantasy of trickle-down economics as its major symptoms, there’s a simpler understanding near at hand. Neoliberalism is when a state decides that corporations, rather than citizens, are its clients.
Far from killing neoliberalism off, there’s more than an element of it in Milburn’s NEET plans.
The shape of his proposals are familiar, the usual carrot-and-stick approach to welfare aimed at the bottom line, rather than the underlying conditions that put people in need of it. First, the cuts. Milburn will recommend that under-25s will no longer be able to claim sickness and disability benefits. Instead, there’ll be a one-stop “youth allowance”, capped at the standard rate of universal credit. So that will be a sharp cut to those who might expect to receive the additional universal credit health element.
Personal independence payments will also be restricted: under 25s will no longer be able to access PIP. Instead, they’ll be able to apply to “local funds” for help with specific “short-term expenses,” though those with the most severe needs will have their existing entitlements protected.
Who knew that disability or debilitating illness take on a special reality when a person turns 25? Obviously, they don’t. But that ever-present national thought is at the heart of these proposed cuts: the problems – even the health problems – of the young are always a little bit unserious. They won’t be helped by empathy or care, that thought goes on, but only discipline and downplaying.
In his government report released last month, professor Peter Fonagy lists in detail the material conditions driving the mental health crisis in the country’s youth. Increased poverty, insecurity and crippling housing costs. Atomisation, loneliness and lack of opportunity. Growing existential dread around the climate, technology and the political future. An education system impoverished by alienation, comparison and intense scrutiny.
Burnham has called the number of young people on existing benefits “a moral failure”. And it’s a profound one for sure. But it’s not their moral failure. It’s ours.
So will our collective failure be addressed in this review?
Unlikely. Instead, what’s been briefed is that the new, pared-back youth allowance will likely be contingent on recipients engaging with programmes aimed at getting them back into work. And while the scope of the cuts are crystal clear, that positive package remains vague. The papers have been told there’ll be investment for employment advisers, mental health support and internships, backed up by – potentially – a new legal duty on the government to furnish every young person with a route into work.
Great – but maybe let’s get that in place before the cuts?
No, no. Young people must always get the stick first. And business? It’s the carrot for them.
“I think we should subsidise wages,” Milburn told Laura Kuenssberg on Sunday, “Because young people today are walking into the workplace often with a mental health problem, ADHD or anxiety, and if you’re a small business, that’s a cost that you’ve got to absorb. The state has a responsibility to help them with that.”
The state has a responsibility to help businesses to solve the social problems caused by the state relying on businesses to solve the social problems caused by the state relying on…
Stop the merry-go-round, it’s making us sick.