Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

Repression nd

Police violence | Police violence trial: broken bones and permanent damage

A police officer breaks a demonstrator's arm and nose at a pro-Palestinian rally in Berlin. Now he is on trial.

Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English

Kitty O'Brien was seriously injured by a police officer at a demonstration. Now she is a co-plaintiff in the criminal proceedings against him. Photo: IMAGO/Anadolu Agency “The damage is permanent,” says Kitty O’Brien. Her arm is still weak and numb and she is still in pain, the Irish national said on Monday in the Tiergarten district court. When asked, she shows the judge the long surgical scar on her right arm. She will carry eleven screws and a plate with her for the rest of her life because of a complicated fracture in her upper arm.

The 26-year-old was unable to work as a costume designer for months after she was beaten and brutally arrested at a demonstration on August 28, 2025. Even today it is still restricted. On Monday, the police officer who inflicted these and other injuries on her appeared in court. He is charged with assault in office. O’Brien is a co-plaintiff and is represented by lawyer Benjamin Düsberg.

There are many videos of Berlin police operations. After every demonstration, there are dozens of more or less brutal arrests on social media that spread wildly. However, what happened to Kitty O'Brien went around the world. Even the Irish embassy in Berlin got involved. Two blows, captured on video, broke her nose. When she was then arrested, the accused officer twisted O'Brien's arm behind her back, yanked it upward and broke it. However, the public prosecutor's office only considers the second punch to be disproportionate and has only filed charges on this point.

The police officer, born in 2002, testifies freely. He admits both the beating and the “cross-cuff” that broke O’Brien’s arm. The first blow with the left hand was relatively light and “expedient”. He didn't throw the second punch with his right hand with full force, but it still hit O'Brien hard. "I'm also sorry that he hit her so hard," says K. The trigger for the first blow is said to have been a kick to his shin, which he felt. Before the second blow, K. claims to have noticed a hitting movement. When he then arrested O'Brien with his colleague, she is said to have stiffened her arm. This was followed by a broken arm. “I could feel a crack in my arm,” he says. He then loosened his grip “because I thought she might have hurt herself.”

The reason for the police operation on Hackescher Markt was an unregistered demonstration that was broken up by the police. A few days earlier, the Israeli army killed 20 people, including five journalists, in a rocket attack on a hospital in Gaza. There were calls for protests on social media under the slogan “Stop the deliberate killing of journalists in Gaza.”

O'Brien wanted to take part in the demonstration, as she says in court. Before she testifies, she is informed that she does not have to testify. An investigation is still open against her because of what happened that day. She is accused of “assault” and “resistance”. When she arrived at Hackescher Markt, she joined a group. "I held up my keffiyeh and shouted slogans." She didn't hear any announcements from the police that the demonstration had been broken up. Shortly afterwards, many police officers came and started pushing. “I thought we were encircled,” she says. She then saw on videos afterwards that this was not the case.

Nils K. repeatedly pushed her, in the chest and also in the neck. “Hit me,” she said. When K. then pushed her so hard that she almost fell over, she told him he was acting like a Nazi. He then hit her in the face. She wiped blood from her face, showed K. her hands, and then wiped them on his uniform. Then came the second blow. The judge asks whether she kicked or hit K.. “That is absolutely untrue,” she says. There are so many videos that show what happened.

After she was arrested, she ran with the two officers. A few steps away from the demonstration, the defendant grabbed her arm. »Then it broke. I heard that right." When she arrived at a police car, she asked for an ambulance. She was only driven to the Charité about an hour after her arrest. A broken nose bone was discovered there. However, the injury to his arm is worse. "They then told me that they didn't know if I would be able to use my arm again."

The public prosecutor, who hardly asks the defendant K. any questions after his statement, takes O’Brien to task. He keeps asking her about things she said at the demonstration. “Why did you provoke the police officer?” and “Why did you tell the defendant to hit you,” he asks. He wants to know whether she spoke to the defendant “factually and calmly.” When he has to leave "for scheduling reasons" and another prosecutor takes a seat behind the desk, lawyer Benjamin Düsberg can't resist making a snarky comment. “Well then maybe we have a public prosecutor’s office now,” he says.

"The public prosecutor's office is structurally failing when it comes to prosecuting police violence."

Actually, several videos of the situation were supposed to be shown on this day of the hearing. But there are technical problems. Ultimately, the process participants and the audience only see a video that shows the event from an elevated point. When the recording shows O'Brien being hit the second time, the trial audience audibly winces.

The process is progressing more slowly than planned. Therefore, several witnesses are released and summoned to a later date. The three police officers who then testify can do little to clarify the facts. Nobody saw O’Brien kick Nils K.’s shin. The officer who arrested O'Brien along with Nils K. wants to remember that K. told him that there had been a kick. However, this is not mentioned in his original written witness statement. And he doesn't remember exactly when K. said that to him.

At the end of the day of the hearing, lawyer Benjamin Düsberg submits another application. He wants the court to give the defendant a warning that even if the prosecution has only charged one punch, a conviction for the other punch and the twisting of the arm could be considered.

"Like the public prosecutor's office, first saying that the individual attacks are part of the whole process, but then not wanting to deal with the first punch and the broken arm, is unlawful," Düsberg explains his application after the hearing in an interview with "nd". Since October 2023, there have been many incidents of police violence at left-wing and pro-Palestinian demonstrations. “I see this as a structural problem,” says the lawyer. It is an exception that the case being heard here has even been charged. »The public prosecutor's office is structurally failing when it comes to prosecuting police violence. Most of the time, incidents are not even charged,” he says. And in the proceedings on Monday, the public prosecutor's office only asked questions of the co-plaintiff, said Düsberg. "And their sole purpose was to attribute responsibility for the injuries inflicted on her."

Kitty O'Brien believes her case is nothing special. “What happened to me – that I was beaten at a demonstration and my bones were broken – also happened to many other people,” she says to “nd”. The only difference is that the police officer was charged. She has no hope of a conviction. “You cannot expect justice from a fundamentally unjust state that continues to support genocide,” she says.

Because of the delays, the process will take longer than planned. A verdict was actually supposed to come down on Wednesday. Now the further videos of the incident should first be shown and the other witnesses should be heard. The final hearing date will not take place until December 28th.

This article cost you nothing. Us: research, production and technology. We saved on office rent as well as printing and distribution. And we gave up salary. Nevertheless, the calculation doesn't work without you. We need 300,000 euros by the end of the year. You pay what you can, in return we keep writing.

No paywall, no small print, just one goal: that nd stays.

Originally published bynd
Read the original