Germany nd
“Cultural Marxism” | Theory non grata
US Secretary of War Hegseth rails against “cultural Marxism.” But anti-imperialists also warn about the “corrosive” power of critical theory.
Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English
US Secretary of War Hegseth takes part in the Marines' medicine ball training - he sees the critical theory as incompatible with this. Photo: IMAGO/ZUMA Press Wire Theoretical leftists and intellectual feature writers laughed up their sleeves. Recently, the US Secretary of War and former TV presenter Pete Hegseth, who has little knowledge of theory, declared Adorno, Horkheimer and Co. to be enemies of the state, so to speak. In a speech at a Navy training and research academy on November 9th, he announced that "the philosophical teachings of the Frankfurt School, critical theory and the destructive idea of diversity, justice and inclusion" even "contradict the Constitution of the United States of America."
Obviously the speaker here didn't understand what he was talking about. Because it is of course nonsense to lump together critical theory with liberal equality efforts. Therefore, the various ciphers here simply have to be understood as synonyms for the dreaded “cultural Marxism,” which, with plenty of anti-Semitic undertones, is repeatedly invoked as the enemy of the nation and the right-wing conservative worldview. Marx and, as a result, Bolshevism were fed into US culture by Soviet agents in order to destroy the good and pure America … or something like that. In this country we are more familiar with the tamer version of the “left-green opinion dictatorship”.
Such delusions are neither new nor particularly original in detail. What's interesting, however, is that this fantasy doesn't just make it easier for right-wingers to maintain their crude worldview. There is exactly this devil legend from the left, and also very current. Just this year, the American philosophy professor and self-proclaimed “anti-imperialist materialist” Gabriel Rockhill made headlines among the theoretical left. In his book “Who Paid the Pipers of Western Marxism?” he accused the Frankfurt School of acting as CIA agents to dismantle Marxism and thereby betray the class struggle.
The fact that this crude version of history amounts to tough Stalinism was even noticed by Jacobin magazine and the Historical Materialism network, each of which wrote extensive replies to Rockhill and accused him of conspiracy thinking. Despite all the justified distinctions, it must be noted that the idea that a bourgeois softening of pure Marxism is to blame for the weakness of the left is part of the tradition of Marxism itself - Rockhill is just a particularly shrill derailment of this.
So when people laugh heartily about how simple the right-wing statements about the supposed bogeyman of Marxism are, the left unfortunately also has to take a look at their own noses. But Marx had predicted this to them and to us right at the beginning of his social criticism: De te fabula narratur - history is about you.
With us, no one has to pay to be informed. Sounds like a bad business model? It is too. But independent journalism and participation for everyone are more important to us than profit. Journalism still costs money: research, printing and all the people who do it. That's why we depend on you. We need 300,000 euros by the end of the year.
Donate once or regularly, every amount counts. So that nd remains.