Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

Germany nd

Background: Press Council | Noticeably one-sided

The Press Council is turning 70. How does it and other media watchdogs view German Middle East reporting?

Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English

Is German media spreading Israeli army propaganda? The Press Council sees no problems. Photo: AFP/OMAR AL-QATTAA The current moment should actually be the finest hour of the so-called non-state media supervision. She would have a lot to do, because many German editorial teams do not give a good picture when reporting on Israel and Palestine. Even self-proclaimed quality media declare hospitals to be terrorist centers by uncritically adopting Israeli military statements. Criticism of the reason-of-state policy is regularly discredited in an undifferentiated manner as anti-Semitic or anti-Israel incitement. There is little to be seen of balanced, fair reporting.

What do the Press Council and Co. say about the rampant violations of journalistic standards and fairness requirements? Is the German media regulator doing its job? To assess this, I examined the complaints about Middle East reporting, which related to journalistic contributions from October 7, 2023 and which were decided by the end of 2025. In order to discover possible tendencies, I divided the complaints into two categories: "Presumably more pro-Israel motivated" are complaints that accuse an article of trivializing the Hamas attack on October 7th or of (Israel-related) anti-Semitism. “Presumably pro-Palestinian-motivated” complaints criticize anti-Palestinian racism or the concealment or trivialization of war crimes committed by the Israeli army.

The Press Council is responsible for print publishers and their digital offerings. During the observation period, it decided on 72 complaints. Twelve times he opted for the harshest sentence: a public reprimand. It should be published by the relevant medium, which is often what happens. Ten of the complaints were directed at Springer-Verlag, eight at Bild alone.

Without exception, all of the complaints were based on complaints that were presumably motivated by pro-Palestinian sentiment. For example, bild.de's false claim that thousands of people shouted "bomb Israel" at a pro-Palestinian demonstration at the end of 2023 was criticized. The Press Council saw this as “deliberately untruthful reporting.” (In fact, “Israel bombed, Germany financed”) was shouted. Contributions from welt.de and bild.de were also criticized, which, in the opinion of the Press Council, gave the impression that reports about starving children in Gaza were propaganda.

Calling the UN refugee agency a “terrorist agency” is considered a completely normal expression of opinion.

The Press Council's rulings revealed a surprisingly clear finding: the watchdog of German press ethics only saw serious problems with articles with a pro-Israel bias. This pattern continued in 2026.

However, one can ask whether the number of complaints should not be even higher. The committee takes aggressive action against classic violations of journalistic principles, such as false allegations. However, he has little use for complaints about the blanket discrediting of Palestine solidarity and anti-Palestinian racism. He simply does not seem to see the fact that there is something like a political or even racist abuse of the accusation of anti-Semitism as a press ethics problem.

For example, the committee considered that the keffiyeh was described as a “terror cloth” and a “trademark of anti-Semites, Israel haters and Hamas terror supporters worldwide” as a completely legitimate expression of opinion. And the Press Council saw no problems with a media outlet declaring the UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA) a “terror authority” and an event in solidarity with Palestine a “Jew-hater camp.”

Twelve broadcasting councils are responsible for complaints about public broadcasting. The procedure is somewhat more complicated than with the Press Council. The director of the respective broadcasting company always answers at the beginning. Only if you contradict the results of this in-house control does a complaint end up with the respective broadcasting council.

Broadcasting councils are the highest power bodies in the public service system. However, they have a reputation for being less critical and supporting the broadcasters. They almost never make a formal complaint, comparable to a press council reprimand. Of the 72 program complaints found regarding Middle East reporting, 18 also ended up in broadcasting councils. In no case were there any complaints.

Despite all the shortcomings: Complaints are a productive opportunity for media criticism. They force editorial boards and media oversight bodies to deal with possible violations. Complaints are submitted via the respective committee's website. The Press Council is responsible for print media and their digital offerings. Twelve broadcasting councils decide on contributions from the relevant broadcasting company (such as ZDF, Deutschlandfunk or RBB). The first decision is made by the director and - only after an objection - by the respective broadcasting council. 14 media companies oversee private broadcasting as well as purely digital editorial offices and content on social media. Stefan Mey is a freelance media and IT journalist. For a study by the Rosa Luxemburg Foundation, he researched how the Press Council & Co. dealt with criticism of German Middle East reporting.

Instead, broadcasting councils rely on subtle hints. They are often characterized by the whispers of German reasons of state. Pro-Israel complaints keep saying that nothing was really done wrong. But in the future we must be more careful not to demonize Israel and promote anti-Semitism through insensitive choice of words or insufficient contextualization.

Now one could reply: It's good that broadcasting councils also pay attention to subtle forms of devaluation. However, the sensitivity only goes in one direction. It doesn't mean equally: Dear editors, please be careful not to carelessly demonize Palestine and promote anti-Palestinian racism.

Finally, there are also the 14 state media authorities. You can complain to them about private broadcasting and online content. They are also not very active. During the observation period, there were not a single complaint about the Middle East reporting on the radio. This is surprising, especially since two channels (Welt TV and Bild Live) fall under the supervision of media institutions, whose publisher (Springer) traditionally leads the complaint rankings in the print sector.

In the online area, however, media companies became active. One measure was directed against an unnamed Palestinian digital journalist and influencer with a wide reach. The Berlin-Brandenburg media authority (mabb) accused him of not having reproduced quotes verbatim and of not providing sufficient evidence for statements. He had to change social media posts and pay a 3,000 euro administration fee. (Media authorities are authorities that can charge fees for their supervisory activities.)

It is difficult to judge from the outside how justified the allegations were. But one can ask why a media outlet took action against this one actor in particular, given the many, sometimes outrageous, violations in the digital space.

Back to the original question: Is the German media regulator doing its job? The activity ranges from careful quality control to bias and blindness to anti-Palestinian racism to virtual refusal to work.

Perhaps one day German Middle East reporting will be critically reviewed. Then you will probably ask how this all happened. The answer will be: also because the media supervision has done its job so poorly in parts.

Other media have corporations or billionaires behind them. We have the nd.Genossenschaft and readers like you. That makes us independent and that’s exactly how we want to remain. But it also means: without you the calculation won't work. We need 300,000 euros by the end of the year.

You can donate directly here, one-time or regularly, so that nd stays.

Originally published bynd
Read the original