Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

World Morning Star

‘Peace is union business’ – the case against Aukus

Ben Chacko is impressed with Maritime Union of Australia deputy national secretary WARREN SMITH’s warning that the trilateral nuclear pact is a disaster for Australia, Britain and the world

English (original) ·Read in Deutsch ⇄

Ben Chacko is impressed with Maritime Union of Australia deputy national secretary WARREN SMITH’s warning that the trilateral nuclear pact is a disaster for Australia, Britain and the world

Middle East / 17 November 2026 No Israeli olive branch of peace for Lebanese farmers 17 November 2026 Harvesting season in Lebanon is being done under the presence of Israeli occupation, destruction and military threats. Local olive farmers are determined to continue to defend and nurture their land against the invaders, writes STEVE SWEENEY

KENNY MacASKILL suggests that a traditional coexistence of Scottish national identity with Britishness is being replaced altogether by an assimilationism that erodes Scotland’s uniqueness

When Hugh MacDiarmid wrote the line ‘I Saw a Rose Come Loupin’ Oot,’ he was referring to a great burst of creativity and beauty emerging from within Scottish society. A century later YANA PETTICREW asks what the left can do to achieve this vision today

Asean’s annual leadership gathering is also hosting guests as diverse as Lula, Lavrov and Trump, illustrating how this important regional organisation remains dominated by global political concerns, reports KENNY COYLE from the Philippines

A report by the Regulator of Social Housing has exposed serious failings under the previous Labour administration, including more than 1,400 overdue high-risk fire safety actions. LOTTE COLLETT and MARY MASON report

While continental Europe rightly is acknowledged for its record of industrial and political militancy, this should not obscure key moments in the history of the British labour movement, argues KEITH FLETT

“WORKERS have no interest in war with China — or any other country.”

Warren Smith, deputy national secretary of the Maritime Union of Australia, set out a compelling case against the Aukus nuclear submarine pact between Australia, Britain and the United States at a CND public meeting in London on Monday night.

Australia’s Aukus Public Inquiry — an independent civil society review, bringing together unions, lawyers and retired politicians and military officers — concluded in its report published this month that Aukus was “the worst, riskiest and most costly defence decision ever made by an Australian government.”

The commissioners titled their report Surrendering Australia, and Smith stressed the pact’s role in a wider strategy to turn Australia into an Asia-Pacific forward base for US aggression, and ensure Britain and Australia are dragged into any Pacific war Washington launches.

Australians have bitter experience of their land being used by overseas powers in a nuclear arms race — and “the plans for nuclear waste dumps and military bases under Aukus will fall hardest on Aboriginal communities, as they did when Britain tested atomic bombs at Maralinga and Emu Field,” Smith warned.

One of the inquiry commissioners is Karina Lester, a First Nations woman whose father went blind from radioactive fallout from British nuclear tests in South Australia in the 1950s. 

But the commissioners came from widely divergent backgrounds: they included former Western Australia premier Carmen Lawrence, the first woman to head an Australian state government; Admiral Chris Barrie, a former chief of the Australian Defence Force (commanding the entire Australian military from 1998-2002); Australia Institute co-CEO Leanne Minshull and lead commissioner and former environment minister Peter Garrett.

It received over 1,000 public submissions and held public forums in which two former Australian prime ministers added to the damnation of a hugely costly and dangerous agreement — “the worst deal in all history,” according to ex-Labor PM Paul Keating.

The huge expansion of the HMAS Stirling naval base in Western Australia to accommodate rotating US and British nuclear-powered submarines “gives Washington and London a forward base in the Indian Ocean, funded substantially by Australian taxpayers, crewed and commanded by personnel under foreign chains of command,” was the judgement of former Liberal PM Malcolm Turnbull.

Aukus is, as CND general secretary Sophie Bolt explained, “a deal about transferring nuclear technology to a non-nuclear weapons state, Australia, to build nuclear-powered submarines… for war fighting. It’s a total breach of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty and it’s increasing tensions across the Asia-Pacific.”

Even disregarding its sinister purpose, Aukus is a terrible bargain for Australia. It “leaves Australia spending billions and billions [368 billion Australian dollars or about £190bn over 40 years by official figures, which critics believe is a significant underestimate] on facilities for US and British nuclear submarines, while the promised Australian fleet may never materialise; the submarines operating from our shores remain under foreign command.” Washington also reserves the right to refuse to sell the submarines it is supposedly building for Australia if it decides it wants them itself.

The government pitches it as a job-creating programme, but the 20,000 jobs it is supposed to create over three decades works out at $19 million a job, Smith pointed out, money that could generate far more employment in other sectors; and “locked into highly specialised defence supply chains concentrated in a few sites tied to US and UK strategic priorities.”

Submarine Rotational Force West will operate from HMAS Stirling with maintenance from Henderson Defence Precinct south of Perth; “and up to 2,300 US personnel and families will be housed there. This is a US base despite denials of such. And already Australia hosts military facilities that support the US capacity to wage war.”

As with British bases like RAF Lakenheath, many so-called Australian bases “are for all intents and purposes US bases… Australian territory and infrastructure are becoming more deeply integrated into the machinery through which the United States can fight its — often illegal — wars.”

As with Iran’s retaliation against US bases in the Middle East used to attack it, a US war on China would now put Australia in the firing line for retaliation, without Australians even being informed whether their bases are housing US nuclear weapons, and “no plans to defend against [the risk of nuclear attack], no evacuation or civil defence plans for a nuclear accident…”

Not only is this familiar from the secretive uses to which British bases are put, Britain is very much threatened by its own involvement in Aukus.

“It’s a British problem too. UK shipyards and reactor plants are tied in. The UK government signed a 50-year treaty with Australia that will lock both our countries into US war plans in the Pacific.”

Australian historian Christoper Clark entitled his history of European powers’ slide into World War I “Sleepwalkers.” The British and Australian peoples too are being drawn ever closer to the brink without governments disclosing the truth about their agreements, and without a public debate on the risks.

Labour MP Brian Leishman, addressing the meeting, decried the “universal passion for militarism” at Westminster drowning out any rational discussion on the subject. Former RMT president and Communist Party general secretary Alex Gordon savaged a British elite posturing as a “19th century gunboat power sending its aircraft carriers around the South China Sea.”

But they can be stopped. Already Australia has had to pause selection of an east coast equivalent to HMAS Stirling because of mass popular mobilisations against it, union-led, in the favoured site of Port Kembla.

Those mobilisations have much in common with the mass protests against conscription and militarism across Europe described by UCU past president Dr Maria Chondrogianni, who also detailed the work that went into overturning the TUC’s position in favour of higher military spending in 2025 and again in 2026.

The Maritime Union of Australia has been at the forefront of organising to scrap Aukus, and it draws on a heroic tradition in that vein: Smith remembered the Port Kembla wharfies who refused to load pig iron on ships bound for Japan in 1938; the Australian, Indonesian, Chinese and Indian seafarers whose waterfront strikes blocked the “Black Armada” of Dutch merchant and military vessels planning to set sail from Australia to force newly independent Indonesia back under Dutch colonial rule.

“Peace is union business,” Smith stressed. “It’s as fundamental a right of workers to fight for peace as it is to fight for a wage rise. Workers die in wars.

“Peace and good jobs are not opposites. Scrap Aukus. No to nuclear submarines, no to US bases — spend the money on housing, on health, on renewable energy, on industry, on shipping — on anything but war!

“No-one can do it alone. We want to work with the British labour movement, with CND — this pact binds both our countries and only working people can break it.

“Like the wharfies of 1938 who refused to load the pig iron, our job is to refuse to let our ports, our jobs, our communities become part of US imperialism’s war drive.”

Peace / 14 November 2026 Trade unionists push for international opposition to Aukus militarisation 14 November 2026 SOPHIE BOLT explains why CND is hosting trade unionists from around the world this Monday in the campaign to oppose the dangerous Aukus nuclear pact between Britain, Australia and the US

Peace / 30 September 2026 Britain’s submarine boomerang – Aukus pact five years on 30 September 2026 The tripartite Australian, British and US militarist alliance is aimed at China, however it’s also likely to backfire on the three countries involved. Labour needs to end Britain’s Pacific ambitions, argues JENNY CLEGG

Anti-War / 24 August 2026 Communists call to mobilise against Aukus militarist alliance 24 August 2026 Communists in Australia, Britain and the US outlined a joint state agreement against their governments’ militarist provocations.

Militarism / 31 July 2026 The pushback against the US militarisation of East Asia 31 July 2026 MIKE MARTIN surveys the regional opposition to US attempts to force the region into a military confrontation with China

Originally published byMorning Star
Read the original