Skip to content
Faultline Prefer us on Google

Politics Morning Star

Milburn’s reforms attack workers as well as social security

ALAN MILBURN’S attacks on the Employment Rights Act are instructive, revealing the reforms Labour is so enthusiastically taking up are an attack on workers as well as on social security. The Prime Min

English (original) ·Read in Deutsch ⇄

Editorial / 17 November 2026 Attack on Tribune shows Palestine Action ban must be lifted 17 November 2026 Editorial / 16 November 2026 On joblessness and Brexit, Burnham’s solutions prop up a broken system 16 November 2026 Editorial / 15 November 2026 A generation that has been cast aside could usher in social change 15 November 2026 Editorial / 13 November 2026 The answer to unemployment is reindustrialisation, not cutting benefits 13 November 2026 Editorial / 12 November 2026 Sedwill threats will lead to annihilation 12 November 2026 Editorial / 11 November 2026 So much Palestine needs, so much Britain could do 11 November 2026 Editorial / 10 November 2026 Socialist advance in US has global significance 10 November 2026 ALAN MILBURN’S attacks on the Employment Rights Act are instructive, revealing the reforms Labour is so enthusiastically taking up are an attack on workers as well as on social security.

The Prime Minister’s spin that “this is not just a benefits reform, it’s a whole society change he’s calling for” could hardly be further from the reality.

Milburn’s proposals actually risk stopping long overdue reform to give workers more rights and security in a Wild West labour market where the decline of collective bargaining and union representation, combined with the explosion of an exploitative gig economy enabled by technologies workplace law lags behind, has driven a race to the bottom on pay and conditions.

At root the reason is that Milburn can only envisage increased employment on employers’ terms. Direct job creation by government is off the table for him, as is subsidised specialist training in sectors selected for strategic expansion in the “fourth industrial revolution.”

Probably, given Milburn’s record, he would not consider these options anyway. But reshaping the economy was never the remit of his report. That does not make it any less important for the labour movement to recognise that reshaping the economy is in fact the only way to address persistent high unemployment.

Without it we are left with a parody of “free market” economics where, because business is unable to deliver, the public foot the bill for “private enterprise” to underwrite corporate profits without securing a stake or even setting the terms.

This is exactly the situation with energy company SSE’s threats to close the Atwick natural gas storage facility at Hornsea unless it gets more government subsidies; an echo of threats made by Centrica regarding the Rough facility. We need that capacity — we need much more than our existing gas storage capacity, in fact — so we are held to random by for-profit providers when we should just take back ownership.

And it is at the heart of the Milburn project. The Employment Rights Act’s ban on “exploitative” zero-hours contracts is a worry, he says, because the labour market is weak and we can’t risk scaring employers off hiring. Indeed, his report cites 37 per cent of employers “planning to reduce permanent hiring because of Employment Rights Act reforms” and Milburn concludes that Labour “will need to be cautious… in terms of implementation” of the zero-hours ban in particular. The government has still not published details or a timetable for the ban to come into effect.

The logic is that if employers are reluctant to hire, then workers need to sacrifice rights to make themselves cheaper and more easily disposable.

It is a Tory logic, masked only by a jobs guarantee which is in reality just another massive subsidy to employers by providing free labour at the state’s expense, in sectors (hotels, retail) that do not expand productive capacity or create new, long-term jobs.

And, since downturns affecting hospitality are themselves linked to reduced purchasing power by an increasingly insecure and impoverished citizenry, attacking workers’ rights as a solution to unemployment becomes a vicious circle. Underlying weaknesses in the economy are worsened and government will be left looking for yet more ways to bribe employers to carry out the ordinary functions of their businesses.

The Parliamentary Labour Party is enormously complacent. Neither Corbyn nor Brexit woke it up to the gulf between its prevailing assumptions and public opinion; neither the bankers’ crash nor the end of liberal globalisation have led it to question the verities of the 1990s.

Keir Starmer thought he could repeat the word “change” while reinforcing the status quo and his popularity nosedived. Burnham’s slicker presentation suggests radical reform, but the policies will actually prevent it. 

Originally published byMorning Star
Read the original