World Morning Star
Class representation in culture demands a fight for material advances
When Hugh MacDiarmid wrote the line ‘I Saw a Rose Come Loupin’ Oot,’ he was referring to a great burst of creativity and beauty emerging from within Scottish society. A century later YANA PETTICREW as
English (original) ·Read in Deutsch ⇄
When Hugh MacDiarmid wrote the line ‘I Saw a Rose Come Loupin’ Oot,’ he was referring to a great burst of creativity and beauty emerging from within Scottish society. A century later YANA PETTICREW asks what the left can do to achieve this vision today
Features / 16 November 2026 Haringey Labour’s housing legacy laid bare 16 November 2026 A report by the Regulator of Social Housing has exposed serious failings under the previous Labour administration, including more than 1,400 overdue high-risk fire safety actions. LOTTE COLLETT and MARY MASON report
After 35 years, the UN peacekeeping mission in Western Sahara is coming to an abrupt end. The withdrawal of the blue helmets threatens to push the region towards a new and dangerous military escalation, writes MARC VANDEPITTE
While continental Europe rightly is acknowledged for its record of industrial and political militancy, this should not obscure key moments in the history of the British labour movement, argues KEITH FLETT
SOPHIE BOLT explains why CND is hosting trade unionists from around the world this Monday in the campaign to oppose the dangerous Aukus nuclear pact between Britain, Australia and the US
BERNADETTE KEAVENEY walks us through the easiest steps to take to make sure you get the daily voice for peace and socialism. Whether you order it through local newsagents, supermarkets or sign up for a delivery there’s a simple route to getting the Morning Star every day
Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood is pushing proposals that play to the Reform UK views on migrant workers and asylum-seekers, while ignoring the need for immigration to bolster Britain’s workforce, argues DIANE ABBOTT
IN NOVEMBER 1926, poet Hugh MacDiarmid published A Drunk Man Looks at the Thistle, an intense modernist work of over 2,000 lines that sparked the Scottish Renaissance and laid the foundations of a national movement built on the dual wielding of the political and cultural images of Scotland. One hundred years on and with escalating far-right demonstrations in working-class areas punctuated by anaemic calls for a second referendum, MacDiarmid’s questioning of a national character must be further raised if we are to rebuild a class-based politic in this country.
Where MacDiarmid’s poem was seeking to uncouple Scottish identity from the British imperial provincialism that had swept Scotland in the 19th century, Scotland now requires a cultural touchstone that moves us away from the heavily manufactured exceptionalist identity parroted back to the political classes who have struggled to represent our interests since devolution began. Unfortunately, the processes behind the creation of new cultural touchstones have been taken away continuously from the working class and so we cannot produce for ourselves anymore.
The necrotising of working-class culture and art through the stripping of education around literature and art has been a conscious choice through the adoption of the Curriculum for Excellence in Scottish schools by the SNP. In particular, it is the removal of poetry as a means of communication for the class that has left a dearth of understanding from our political class who would rather entertain pithy debates around the Unesco status of the morning roll than the fact that one-in-four Scottish children live in food-insecure households.
Such debates show an alienation from purported left-wing politicians towards the workers of Scotland, an alienation built on the manufacturing of identity that is culturally socialist using cultural markers of working-class Scots, while their institutions and means of creating these cultural markers are left to rot. Before securing the cultural status of the morning roll, perhaps we should make sure everyone can eat one first. A kind of “Cultural Sturgeonism” has taken hold of parts of the Scottish left, particularly among the nominally left-wing youth, who are incredibly active online in pushing the political narrative of the SNP and Scottish Greens, but are not members of their trade unions, and are therefore themselves alienated from true democratic processes. This is indeed not the fault of Scottish youth.
The absence of a healthy political and social culture amongst working-class youth comes from the continued attacks on their conditions, whether the quality and security of work; youth rates; reforms to welfare; a lack of affordable housing; and perhaps most notably, their attention. The conditions that allowed for politicised subcultures to be founded no longer exist in an attention-based political economy, as cultural production is levelled into what gets the most likes and interactions on social media.
Cultural Sturgeonism has left us with a caricature of modern working-class life, where the shortbread tin has been wrapped in Burberry fabric and the ten-a-penny pipers have been replaced by London-based “creatives” selling our own image back to us through your granny’s favourite Scots phrases.
These same attacks on young people lay bare the conditions that the unions must organise young workers around, as abject precarity becomes normalised and participation in democracy becomes an Instagram story. Of all the bread-and-butter issues that we must organise against, cultural conditions can therefore seem less of a priority to the issues of employment, welfare and housing. They are of course, however, linked.
Improvements to employment and welfare mean that people can find more time, energy, and means with which to create. How can a care worker be expected to write poetry about her experiences and interactions with the world when she is coming off a 14-hour shift and can barely afford a notebook to write in? How can a shop steward make music when they are negotiating over redundancies all day? An affordable and secure roof over their heads means they not only have fewer material demands to meet, but they have the physical space to create.
When the working class is given the means to create cultural artefacts, the expression of the class can inform the material and political demands made by the trade unions and political parties, rather than them dictating from above. If we are to revisit the motivations behind A Drunk Man Looks at the Thistle a century afterward, where a poem could set alight a movement towards national sovereignty in the aftermath of industrial and political strife, then it cannot be handed down from high.
We must ensure that the class are fighting for an improvement of the conditions that guarantees they are the ones to create the art and literature that characterise the Scottish working class, and that it is they who control the national character and cultural narratives rather than playing the Jock to those that can afford it.
Yana Petticrew is an organiser for Unite Hospitality Glasgow
Opinion / 17 November 2026 The death of unionist nationalism in Scotland 17 November 2026 KENNY MacASKILL suggests that a traditional coexistence of Scottish national identity with Britishness is being replaced altogether by an assimilationism that erodes Scotland’s uniqueness
Voices of Scotland / 15 September 2026 Common class interests should generate shared priorities across our borders 15 September 2026 The rise of the far right on the one hand and the emergence of a new style of Labour leadership on the other, create similar challenges and opportunities for unions in Scotland and beyond, argues DAVE MOXHAM
Full Marx / 14 August 2026 Do humans have ‘inherent dignity’? 14 August 2026 Dignity is important to all humans, argues the Marx Memorial Library and Workers’ School, but it does not come about automatically. In a less than perfect world, dignity can accompany suffering, but the collective dignity of working people is achieved through acting together to change the world.
Poetry / 26 November 2025 Off the beaten track 26 November 2025 RUTH AYLETT reviews two collections of outright political poetry