Germany de.indymedia
Planned changes to the GDPR: data misuse in the workplace could soon be harder to detect
The EU Commission proposed the Digital Omnibus without first carrying out a comprehensive impact assessment. A study by the European Trade Union Institute examines the possible consequences
Deutsch (original) ·Auto-translated to English
The EU Commission proposed the Digital Omnibus without first carrying out a comprehensive impact assessment. A study by the European Trade Union Institute examines the possible consequences. According to the authors, the proposal weakens the data protection rights of employees in the EU.
Loss of control over personal data, excessive surveillance, unfair automated decisions, hidden metrics and opaque algorithmic management: these are all forms of data misuse in the workplace that could become much harder to detect in the future. This is the result of a study byhttps://www.etui.org/publications/conditions-legal-protection">Europäischen trade union institute, which examines the proposed Digital Omnibus.
Thehttps://www.europarl.europa.eu/legislative-train/theme-a-new-plan-for-eu...omnibusis currently being discussed in the European Parliament. The legislative package proposed by the European Commission affects, among other thingshttps://gdpr-info.eu/">General Data Protection Regulation(GDPR), the central EU law for the protection of personal data. For example, the proposal could restrict requests for information under the GDPR if they serve purposes that go beyond data protection, such as gathering evidence for an employment dispute.
The Commission presents the new legal framework as a measure to simplify and increase competitiveness. According to their estimates, the package could save administrative costs of up to 5 billion euros by 2029. However, more than 100 civil society organizations described the proposal ashttps://noyb.eu/sites/default/files/2025-11/The%20EU%20must%20uphold%20h...“Attempting to secretly dismantle Europe’s strongest defenses against digital threats”.
What might these changes mean for employees who want to object to how their data is used? Since the EU Commission has not carried out an impact assessment for the Digital Omnibus, the authors Aida Ponce Del Castillo and Thomas le Bonniec prepared this study on behalf of the European Trade Union Institute.
To examine the possible impact of the changes, the authors applied them retrospectively as a hypothetical scenario to four workplace cases. These had previously led to official measures or successful lawsuits against data misuse in the workplace.https://netzpolitik.org/2020/uber-fahrer-wollen-transparenz-ueber-daten-...were cases involving the ride-hailing platforms Uber and Ola.
The burden of proof shifts to employees
In one of the cases, six Uber drivers requested access to personal data and information about how the platform's systems affected their work. This included information about arranging rides, pricing and reviews. They wanted to understand how Uber's algorithmic management systems made or influenced decisions about them. A similar case was filed against Ola, a ride-hailing company based in India.
In 2023, the Amsterdam Court of Appeal finally granted the drivers' demands and required Uber and Ola to disclose certain personal data and meaningful information about certain automated decision-making systems.
The drivers used their existing rights to information under the GDPR to obtain information important for their lawsuit. The authors of the study argue that the changes to the Digital Omnibus may make comparable results more difficult to achieve in the future.
–––
Against ID checks online.
We are fighting for an open internet.https://netzpolitik.org/spenden/?via=rss">Thisonly possible with your support.
–––
Among other things, the changes would give employers or platforms more options to refuse employees' requests for information about their personal data. For example, an employer could argue that an employee is using a GDPR disclosure not to exercise their data protection rights, but for another purpose, such as gathering evidence for an employment dispute.
This distinction is important because employers and platforms often control the very data, algorithms and records that employees need to understand what has happened to them. Employees often do not have their own access to the evidence they need to support their claims.
According to the study, the changes could therefore shift more of the burden of proof to employees. They may need to make more specific requests for information, challenge denials, or seek legal assistance to obtain information that their employer or the platform already has.
Commenting on the proposed changes, study author Aida Ponce Del Castillo said: "A worker can be correct in their suspicion of unlawful surveillance and still be unable to prove it. If the EU makes it harder to get information from an employer, it will also be harder for people to take action against what happens to them in the workplace."
Automated decisions harder to challenge
In a related case, four Uber drivers fought to have their accounts deactivated after Uber systems reported suspected fraudulent activity. The drivers argued that these were momentous decisions made solely through automated processing and without significant human intervention.
For three of the four drivers, the court concluded that Uber had not demonstrated significant human intervention. The drivers were not heard. In addition, Uber had not demonstrated that the people reviewing the decisions had sufficient information and authority to change the automated outcome.
The GDPR provides protection against certain decisions based solely on automated processing. Currently, when examining whether automated processing was actually necessary, it may be relevant whether an equally effective human alternative was available.
–––
We do the work that no one else does.
We read draft laws in the original, liberate documents, dig into research and, as experts, warn against new surveillance. Your donation makes this possible.https://netzpolitik.org/spenden/?via=rss">Donatenow..
–––
The proposed changes would change this standard of review. In the future, the mere fact that a human alternative would have been possible would no longer be sufficient to argue that automated processing was not necessary.
Applied to the Uber case, the authors believe that this would put Uber in a stronger legal position. The company could argue that automated fraud detection was necessary to fulfill its contractual relationship with drivers, even if a human could have made the decision instead.
The authors conclude that legal action to achieve results comparable to those in the Uber/Ola cases would have become more difficult under the proposed changes: drivers could have faced greater hurdles in obtaining information. At the same time, Uber would have been in a stronger position to legally justify automated decisions.
Rules for high-risk AI systems will only apply later
A part of thehttps://artificialintelligenceact.eu/ai-act-explorer/digital-omnibus/">D...on the topic of AIwas already passed in July of this year. This meant that the application of the requirements of the EU AI Regulation for high-risk systems was postponed by 16 months to December 2027. This also includes requirements for certain AI systems that are used in the employment context and in the management of employees.
Taken together, the two packages of changes could reinforce each other, according to the authors: protective measures in the AI regulation that are intended to prevent harmful practices would take effect later. At the same time, changes to the GDPR could make it more difficult for employees to subsequently investigate or challenge such practices.
In other words: Employees could have less protection from the effects of AI systems. At the same time, the hurdles to finding out what happened could become higher.
–––
The hut is burning: We need your help!
We still need 472,621 euros by the end of the year. So that we can continue to look closely when freedom comes under pressure.https://netzpolitik.org/spenden/?via=rss">Nowdonate.