World Green Left (Australia)
Calvary takeover raises questions over hospital licences and access to VAD
The proposed takeover of 14 former Healthscope hospitals by Catholic healthcare provider Calvary Health Care is facing scrutiny over competition, corporate accountability and the future availability o
English (original) ·Read in Deutsch ⇄
The proposed takeover of 14 former Healthscope hospitals by Catholic healthcare provider Calvary Health Care is facing scrutiny over competition, corporate accountability and the future availability of lawful healthcare services, including voluntary assisted dying (VAD).
Calvary’s proposed acquisition includes six NSW hospitals: Newcastle Private, Hunter Valley Private, Norwest, Lady Davidson, The Hills Private and The Sydney Clinic.
Calvary has confirmed it will not offer or facilitate VAD in any acquired hospital. Other excluded services under its Catholic healthcare guidelines include in vitro fertilisation (IVF) and assisted reproductive technologies, elective terminations, vasectomies, tubal ligation and gender care procedures.
The implications are particularly significant in the Hunter. Newcastle Private has an established role in providing VAD services. Go Gentle Australia reports that the hospital is understood to receive approximately one or two VAD requests each week.
Calvary says patients requesting VAD will continue to receive compassionate care and that appropriate pathways will be explored. However, transferring seriously ill patients elsewhere can create considerable practical, clinical and personal difficulties, particularly near the end of life.
The proposed takeover prompted a powerful protest on November 8, with hundreds calling on NSW Labor to protect access to existing healthcare services.
Dying With Dignity NSW supporters and Board members joined community members and healthcare professionals in raising concerns about the loss of established services.
Two regulatory approvals are required for the takeover to proceed. The NSW government is expected to determine the transfer of the six hospital licences on December 1.
Under section 15(4)(a) of the NSW Private Health Facilities Act 2007, the health secretary can consider whether the applicant is a fit and proper person to hold a hospital licence. This assessment can consider the corporate applicant itself, as well as its directors and relevant management personnel.
This raises the question of whether governance, oversight and organisational accountability findings arising from the Mater Hospital inquiry could be relevant to Calvary’s suitability. Any such findings would need to be attributable to the relevant Calvary entity; responsibility cannot simply be assumed.
Separately, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission is examining the acquisition’s implications for hospital market competition. Its assessment timetable has recently been extended to December 10.
These decisions will have consequences beyond hospital ownership, potentially affecting the availability of established healthcare services and patients’ access to lawful choices, including VAD.
[Suzanne James is an advocate for voluntary assisted dying.]